The manufacturing industry employs 10% of the British workforce but accounts for 25% of all fatal workplace accidents and 16% of reported accidents.
The factory can be a dangerous environment and whilst there have been improvements in worker safety over recent decades there is still room for improvement.
The main source of safety improvements has been the imposition of European legislation over the last 20 years, which built on the 1961 and 1974 Factories Acts. This legislation covers a wide area of activities in the workplace, and ensures that risk assessments are at the centre of operations.
Machinery injuries and strict liability
In factories, machinery poses a particular risk. The regulations mean that if a machinery is defective, for whatever reason, and this causes injury to a worker, then the employer will be liable to pay compensation for those injuries. This is one of the few examples of ‘strict liability’ in UK law, where it is not necessary to prove fault on the part of the defendant. Strict liability is imposed in this situation for the protection of workers – there is an inequality of status between the employee and employer, which would make it difficult for the employee to produce the necessary evidence to prove that a machine malfunctioned because of some negligence on the part of the employer.
So for example, Osbornes acted for Mrs V, a Bulgarian lady who worked in an industrial bakery in London and spoke little English. She was operating a machine on the production line, a machine she was trained on and had no problems with before, when suddenly and without warning part of the machine, a metal block, swung out and hit her on the head, throwing her across the factory floor and knocking her out. She was unable to say what the part was and how or why it ejected from the machine and she had no details of witnesses. Proving fault on the part of her employer would have been extremely difficult, but because the machine had malfunctioned the employers were strictly liable and so she was compensated for the head injury that interfered with her work for the next three years.
Strict liability does not apply to most other work activities, so for most employees it is necessary to prove the cause of an accident and to show that the employer was at fault in some way. Fortunately there are other regulations that help, because they impose various safety duties on employers. Legislation controls how machinery and other work equipment is used and how the factory is organised, so that worker safety is taken into a consideration. For example, many factories have vehicles such as forklift trucks and pallet trucks moving about on the ‘shop floor’ and there are rules about how pedestrian walkways should be used to keep traffic away from pedestrians. This is elementary safety procedure but it is surprising how many cases we come across where a factory worker has been injured by a vehicle that has been allowed to operate in an area where pedestrians are moving about.
Hazardous and toxic substances are often used in the manufacturing process, and there are regulations designed specifically to control their use so as to minimise the dangers to health and safety.
Common sense approach
Much is said about the ‘health and safety culture’ and the need to apply a common sense approach to risks and to reduce the burden of bureaucracy. This may be true in some areas, but in the factory setting it is vital that there are proper rules, strictly applied, to make sure that employers take their responsibilities for worker safety seriously. So it is a real concern that the Government has rushed through parliament an amendment to the Enterprise Bill to prevent injured workers relying on the safety regulations in a claim for compensation. If the amendment is made law accident victims will once again have to rely on proving negligence by their employers and we will be left with a Victorian style safety regime where it will be much more difficult to succeed with a claim against an employer.
Accreditations







Latest Personal Injury News
Osbornes listed in The Times Best Law Firms 2021 Guide
Osbornes Law is delighted to be featured in The Times ‘Best Law Firms 2021’ guide for the third consecutive year. The 2021 guide has once again singled out the advice, […]
Read MoreHighway Code changes just the start – cycling lawyers
Changes to the Highway Code do not go far enough to change driver behaviour and protect cyclists and pedestrians, leading cycling lawyer, Stuart Kightley, has told the government. Stuart Kightley, […]
Read MoreInquest into Croydon tram crash adjourned due to COVID
The Senior Coroner for South London, Sarah Ormond-Walsh has adjourned the Croydon Tram Inquests, which were due to start on Monday 19 October. Coroner Sarah Ormond-Walshe said there was insufficient […]
Read MoreOsbornes partners with leading Brain Injury Charity to produce a new Q&A video series
Lights, Camera, Legal Advice! This week marks the launch of a new series of 16 legal advice videos with brain injury charity, Headway East London. The charity supports people affected […]
Read MoreCyclist suffered broken back and pelvis after motorist veered into him on the wrong side of the road
An avid cyclist had his ‘body broken’ and was left unable to walk unaided for almost a year after a motorist drove into him while on the wrong side of […]
Read MoreCyclist whose career nearly ended following collision in London tells his story to the Evening Standard
As reported in the evening standard, a jewellery designer and maker to the stars had his career almost ended when an Uber driver ploughed into him and broke his hand. […]
Read MoreOsbornes Law joins legal panel of national road collision charity.
Osbornes is delighted to announce that the firm have joined the legal panel of the national charity for road crash victims, Roadpeace. The award winning personal injury department at Osbornes […]
Read MoreSenior lawyer to be promoted to partner while four become associates at Osbornes
London law firm Osbornes Law has announced that one of their Senior Catastrophic Injury Solicitors will become a partner in the latest round of promotions. Rob Aylott, who has 26 […]
Read MoreSenior Catastrophic Injury Solicitor Robert Aylott gains further APIL recognition
Rob Aylott, senior solicitor in the Personal Injury team has recently been confirmed as an APIL Accredited Fatal Accidents Specialist (AFAS). Already an APIL Senior Litigator Rob demonstrated to the […]
Read MoreOsbornes Law fundraiser for national brain injury charity #HatsforHeadway
Recently staff from Osbornes Law took part in #HatsforHeadway to support the fantastic work Headway do to help improve lives for those affected by brain injury. Headway is the UK-wide […]
Read More