Impacted Fetal Head During Labour

23 Jun 2021 | Stephanie Prior
nurse in hospital

Table of Contents

According to the World Health Organisation, labour is considered obstructed when the fetus cannot progress along the birth canal, despite strong uterine contractions. The obstruction can be alleviated by caesarean section or instrumental delivery, such as forceps. Unfortunately, worldwide, neglected, obstructed labour is a major cause of both maternal and newborn morbidity and mortality.

Currently, there are no UK or International guidelines on managing an impacted fetal head: there are many potential techniques, but no single method has been deemed superior.

Is a fractured skull in the neonate evidence of obstetric negligence?

There is still an ongoing debate as to whether a fractured skull discovered in the neonate after a caesarean section is evidence of negligence. The British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology published an article by Philip J Steer on 25 January 2016 which reviewed 4 fetal deaths over 3 years from the push technique. The alternative technique is the pull method (ie reverse breech) and apparently, this is faster, the article says this resulted in less maternal morbidity than push from below (ie push technique) but there is less difference in birth trauma. These 4 perinatal deaths were associated with a skull fracture and caesarean section when the mother was fully dilated (10cm), and there had been no prior attempt at instrumental delivery. In each case, there were repeated attempts by the Obstetrician to deliver the head by passing the obstetrician’s hands from the uterus down past the fetal head.  This enabled the Obstetrician’s hands to get underneath the baby’s head and pull it up. There was also pressure from an assistant’s hand in the woman’s vagina.

This article concludes;

These cases suggest that it may be best to avoid further compressing an impacted fetal head by pushing a hand past it while also applying force from below. However, such anecdotal evidence does not necessarily mean that on the balance of probability, the injury would have been avoided if the pull method had been employed.’

2020 Doncaster and Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

A recent BBC news article raised the issue of fetal head injury during labour. It cited the story of newborn Clay Wankiewicz, who died from multiple skull fractures, seemingly caused by a poorly performed labour and forceps delivery at the Doncaster and Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust.

Beth Wankiewicz carried Clay to term, and her pregnancy was deemed low risk. In July 2020, Beth went into labour around her due date.  After 24 hours, the labour was not progressing, so an inexperienced junior doctor made two attempts to deliver Clay with forceps, as no senior doctor was available on site. Finally, Clay was pushed back into the womb so that a caesarian section could be performed. Tragically, Clay was declared dead 20 minutes after his birth. The staff told Clay’s parents that he had been stillborn. Notably, stillbirths are not reported to the coroner for post-mortem or investigation.

Post Mortem

A midwife later told the couple that Clay had been born with a heartbeat and could not be deemed stillborn.  Eventually, Clay was referred to the coroner for a post-mortem, which indicated that he had died from multiple skull fractures.

Unsurprisingly, his family believe that Clay was initially deemed stillborn to avoid the scrutiny of a coroner’s inquest.

2016 review of Doncaster and Bassetlaw Maternity Services

Unfortunately, the circumstances that led to Clay’s death had already been flagged as safety issues as far back as 2016. A review of the Doncaster and Bassetlaw NHS Trust’s maternity services was conducted by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and found serious patient safety concerns, including a lack of appropriate leadership and consultant availability. The results of the review were never made public, despite being required to do so, following the 2015 Bill Kirkup Inquiry.  Had the safety concerns been addressed, perhaps Clay would be alive today.

The Bill Kirkup Inquiry

In 2015, the report of the Kirkup independent public inquiry into maternity and neonatal care provided by the Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust was published. Kirkup found that in the Trust, between 2004 and 2013, there was a ‘serious failure of clinical care’ due to the dysfunctional unit providing substandard care by staff deficient inappropriate skills and knowledge. The failure was deemed to have resulted in the ‘tragic and unnecessary deaths of 11 babies and one mother.

The requirement to publish not enforced by law

Following the Kirkup review, the government determined that NHS trusts are required to publicly publish summaries of external reviews and share them with their regulatory body. However, there is no law to enforce this. This means crucial patient safety reports are easily concealed if the results are unfavourable to the Trusts.

As already discussed, the 2016 review of the Doncaster and Bassetlaw NHS Trust’s maternity services by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists was not made public. This concealment is not unusual. Indeed, a Panorama investigation into the matter, broadcast on the 19th May 2021, found that some Trusts keep critical reports hidden from the regulator and the public when care goes wrong.

Scandal after scandal: disregarding Kirkup recommendations

The Clay family’s case is not unusual, either in the failure of clinical care or the cover-up of a previous critical review.

In 2017, in a Margate hospital, inexperienced junior doctors were left in charge of a labour that was failing to progress. They were required to perform an emergency caesarean section to deliver baby Harry, as no senior doctor was available for the procedure. His traumatic delivery and delayed resuscitation left newborn Harry with brain injuries due to lack of oxygen, and he soon died. Initially, Harry’s death was not reported to the coroner. Still, when it was finally referred, the inquest found that Harry’s death was ‘contributed to by neglect’ and his death deemed ‘wholly avoidable’.

As with the Doncaster and Bassetlaw Trust, a review into the Margate Trust’s maternity services had been commissioned 2 years previously. The report alerted the Trust to the risks inherent in forcing unqualified doctors to take responsibility for emergencies due to lack of onsite consultant support.

Poor clinical practice seems to be being identified but not addressed across the UK. This raises the question: what is the point of commissioning an expert review if the risks to patient safety are not acted upon?

At Osbornes Law, we serve many clients who do not speak English as their first language. In our experience, this has created significant issues for pregnant women under the care of the obstetric team at their local hospital. We are currently acting for several women who have each delivered babies with catastrophic brain injury, many women who have delivered babies who were stillborn and also the family of a young mother who died post caesarean section. The common thread in these cases is that communication was poor, and the urgency of each situation was not appreciated by the medical and nursing staff caring for the mother due to the significant language barriers.

The prosecution may focus the minds of Trust leaders

Perhaps the only way to ensure that patient safety concerns are appropriately addressed is through the application of the Law. The Margate hospital involved in Harry’s death is to be prosecuted. Accused of exposing Harry and his mother to ‘significant risk of avoidable harm’ in ‘terrifying’ and ‘chaotic’ circumstances’, the Trust faces 2 charges under Regulation 12 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008, for failing to provide safe care and treatment. This is thought to be the first time that the Care Quality Commission has brought a prosecution for clinical care safety breaches.

It is right that independent professional bodies such as the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists should conduct investigations into patient safety concerns. However, the same mistakes will be repeated unless the concerns are acted upon and changes made. By holding to account the Trust within a legal framework, rather than scapegoating nurses and doctors through their professional bodies, this groundbreaking prosecution may represent a sea change in how senior managers and CEOs take responsibility for the safety of patients under their care.

Our team have experience in dealing with cases of this nature so if you would like to discuss your issue further please call 0207 485 8811 or complete an online enquiry form.

Share this article

Contact

Contact us today

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. 5.1.2024

      Delayed Pre-Eclampsia Diagnosis Resulting in Tragic Baby Loss

      Introduction to the Case Nick Leahy, Associate in our Clinical Negligence department, has recently settled a birth injury claim against...

      Read more
    2. 23.11.2023

      Claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant, C, in her birth negligence claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust for negligent...

      Read more
    3. baby
      31.8.2023

      Hyponatraemia – Symptoms, Causes & Negligence

      What is hyponatraemia? Hyponatraemia is a condition where sodium levels fall below a certain level, which can be dangerous. All...

      Read more
    4. pregnant lady
      23.3.2023

      Private Pregnancy Scans and Substandard Care

      In the news, it has been reported that private clinics that offer pregnancy scans to women are not meeting the...

      Read more
    5. baby hand in mothers hand
      7.3.2023

      5-figure settlement for infusion leak to mother

      Elline Demetriou has reached another successful outcome for a Claimant, who pursued a post C-section birth injury to mother claim...

      Read more
    6. water
      9.2.2023

      Perineal Tear case settles for 6-figure sum

      Stephanie Prior recently settled a claim relating to a woman who delivered her baby after a traumatic labour. Her son...

      Read more
    7. pregnant lady making a heart shape
      2.10.2022

      Tragic Case Involving a Home Water Birth

      Introduction to the case Nicholas Leahy is acting for a young woman who had a water birth at home and...

      Read more
    8. Hospital sign MATERNITY
      21.9.2022

      Are maternity services safe? – Part 2

      In April last year I wrote a piece about government setting up a taskforce to look into why there are...

      Read more
    9. Pregnant woman performing cardiotocography CTG
      8.9.2022

      Poor interpretation of CTG can result in stillbirth...

      Poor interpretation of a Cardiotocograph, more commonly known as a CTG, is a leading cause of stillbirth and brain injuries...

      Read more
    10. child with blue paint on hands
      2.9.2022

      Mother & Baby Suffer Life-changing Injuries

      Claim after mother and baby suffered life-changing injuries during birth Jodi is acting for both mother and baby in a...

      Read more
    11. Medical doctor in empty hospital corridor
      1.8.2022

      Bereavement Following Treatment at Basildon Maternity Unit

      Stephanie Prior’s case relating to the death of Gabriela Pintilie has been settled and approved by the High Court....

      Read more
    12. doctor women at office
      29.6.2022

      Nottingham Maternity: Donna Ockenden to Chair Independent Inquiry

      An interim report on the state of maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust has just been released. However,...

      Read more
    13. 23.5.2022

      Successful Claim Against King’s College Hospitals

      The birth injury lawyers at Osbornes Law have recently negotiated the settlement of a case in which our client sustained...

      Read more
    14. Neglijenta medicala spital din UK
      23.2.2022

      Women from ethnic minorities experience worse maternity care

      It has been reported today that the government has set up a new task force to look into why there...

      Read more
    15. pregnant lady
      17.2.2022

      999 Call Handlers Maternity Instructions Report

      HSIB Report on Maternity Pre-arrival Instructions from 999 Call Handlers The Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch (“HSIB”) investigate NHS maternity incidents that...

      Read more
    16. Pregnant Woman and Gynecologist Doctor at Hospit
      2.2.2022

      Lifelong Consequences for Newborn Baby

      Osbornes Law specialises in assisting families who have experienced birth injuries. We have represented families who have faced the loss...

      Read more
    17. cute kid with disability playing
      27.1.2022

      Six-figure claim allows family to move home

      Six-figure compensation payment for a client Jodi Newton has secured a six-figure compensation payment for her client with cerebral palsy....

      Read more
    18. lesiones de nacimiento
      24.1.2022

      Likely settlement of £15-20 million

      A client who suffered cerebral palsy injuries at birth was awarded £200,000 as an interim payment in a claim against NHS...

      Read more
    19. Pregnant woman holding blanket,
      12.1.2022

      Wrongful birth claim successfully settled

      Background Our client, J, fell pregnant in October 2015 and took the difficult decision to undergo a termination. She booked an...

      Read more
    20. Pregnant Woman and Gynecologist Doctor at Hospit
      2.1.2022

      Justice for Family Who Faced Loss of Newborn

      Osbornes Law specialises in assisting families who have experienced birth injuries. We have represented families who have faced the loss...

      Read more
    21. maternity sign
      17.11.2021

      NICE revises guidelines on Induced labour

      Most babies are born naturally at around 40 weeks gestation. However, some pregnancies continue for longer. According to data from the...

      Read more
    22. girl looking through binoculars
      2.10.2021

      Compensation supports rehabilitation and housing

      Six-figure sum supports rehabilitation and housing. Jodi achieved a six-figure sum compensation for her client with cerebral palsy. The financial...

      Read more
    23. hospital bed
      20.7.2021

      Osbornes Successfully Settle Wrongful Birth Claim

      Nicholas Leahy, clinical negligence lawyer at Osbornes Law has recently negotiated the successful settlement of a wrongful birth case. Our...

      Read more
    24. white lilies
      1.7.2021

      Stillbirth following water birth at home

      Nicholas Leahy acted for a young woman who had a water birth at home and two midwives were allocated to...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL