Wrongful birth claim successfully settled

12 Jan 2022 | Nicholas Leahy
Pregnant woman holding blanket,

Table of Contents

Background

Our client, J, fell pregnant in October 2015 and took the difficult decision to undergo a termination. She booked an appointment at BPAS in Portsmouth where she consented to a termination of pregnancy on 14 October 2015. She said that she would like a general anaesthetic and a coil fitted as she could not risk getting pregnant again.

J underwent the termination on 24 October 2015 at BPAS and apparently, she was told by a Clinical Practitioner that Nexplanon was the best form of contraception for her. She was told that this could be inserted after the termination. At the time she advised the treating clinician and nursing staff at the clinic that she suffered from epilepsy and that she was taking Carbamazepine (200mg morne and 400mg nocte) and had done for many years previously. Carbamazepine is a liver enzyme-inducing drug, which increases the metabolism of female sex hormones, eliminating the drug from the body faster and so lowering blood levels. When this increased metabolism happens to a woman using a hormonal contraceptive, the contraceptive can become less effective and pregnancy can result.

Despite this, J was still advised that Nexplanon was the most appropriate form of contraception for her. She did not know any different and accepted the information that was given to her by the medical professional. J had clearly explained that she did not want to get pregnant again.

J, therefore, had the Nexplanon device inserted in her left arm on 24 October 2015. She informed the nurse prior to this procedure that she had taken carbamazepine at 06:00 that same morning and this was evident from her medical notes.

Everything seemed to go well for her initially and the Nexplanon implant did not bother her at all. She did not feel unwell or suffer any adverse effects from it and she carried on with her life as normal.

However, in early December 2017, 26 months after the insertion of the Nexplanon device, J fell pregnant. After much consideration J decided to continue with her pregnancy as she could not face another termination.

J attended all antenatal appointments at the hospital and at her GP Surgery. She was unwell during the pregnancy. She was sick and suffered headaches. Her blood pressure was monitored and she was referred by her GP to hospital on 10 May 2018 as her BP was raised and she was also suffering from nausea.

J suffered pre-eclampsia and HELLP syndrome as she had in her previous pregnancy. Her baby’s placenta was small and her baby stopped growing. As a result, J had to have an emergency C-section, for which she had a spinal anaesthetic. J’s daughter was born at 27 weeks and she had to remain on the special care baby unit for several weeks following her birth. Following her discharge home from hospital, she remained dependent on supplemental oxygen until May 2021.

Civil Case

J instructed Nicholas Leahy to pursue a civil claim against the British Pregnancy Advisory Service for wrongful birth.

Supportive expert evidence was obtained from an expert in community sexual and reproductive health (on breach of duty and causation) and from a Consultant Respiratory Physician on Condition and Prognosis.

Our expert believed it was a breach of duty for BPAS to advise J to have a Nexplanon Implant when it was known that she was taking anti-epileptic medication. Further, our expert opinion is that there was a failure by the staff at BPAS to provide an explanation and a warning about this drug interaction and therefore to advise on an alternative method such as an intrauterine device.

J’s daughter was born prematurely at 27 weeks. In respect of condition and prognosis, expert evidence was obtained from a Consultant Respiratory Physician who diagnosed J’s daughter with significant chronic lung disease of prematurity (new bronchopulmonary dysplasia). He believed that J’s daughter was at increased risk of wheezing illnesses associated with viral illnesses in her early years which could stretch well into adolescence and adulthood.

Proceedings

A Letter of Claim was sent to BPAS on 6 September 2019. However, liability was denied in full in a Letter of Response which was served on 27 April 2020. The Defendant argued that J was appropriately counselled regarding available forms of contraception and that she gave her informed consent to the insertion of Nexplanon. The Defendant alleged that they had discussed the possible interaction between Carbamazepine and Nexplanon, although notably were unable to adduce any evidence of such a discussion.

Causation was also denied, with the Defendant arguing that no contraception is 100% effective and that it was open to J to proceed with a termination of pregnancy in December 2017 in any event. They also alleged J was aware that her baby could be born disabled since Carbamazepine itself could cause fetal abnormalities given that J had not taken folic acid from conception.

Following the denial of liability by BPAS, Counsel (Katarina Sydow of Outer Temple Chambers and latterly Tom Gibson of Outer Temple Chambers) was instructed to advise J on the prospects of success in her case.

During the civil case, it became evident that J’s daughter was making greater progress than was at first anticipated, despite remaining on supplemental oxygen at night until May 2021. Updated medical records were requested by BPAS and these were obtained in 2021.

Wrongful birth – The Law

The courts have significantly curtailed the damages which can be sought in birth injury claims, such that at present a claim can be made for:

  • a conventional award (currently £15,000) for loss of the Claimant’s freedom to limit the size of their family;
  • damages in respect of the personal injury suffered by the mother because of the pregnancy and labour, and incidental consequential losses and expenses; and
  • the additional costs of bringing up the child, consequent upon the disability.

J claimed the conventional award, a sum for the pain and suffering of her unwanted pregnancy, and additional costs related to bringing up her daughter, consequent upon her disability. This included the care which she was required to provide in respect of taking her daughter to numerous hospital appointments and in ensuring that her daughter was able to access supplemental oxygen support throughout each evening and night.

The parties were unable to agree in relation to liability. However, in early 2022, following a period of negotiation in which various offers of settlement were exchanged, a five-figure settlement was agreed with the Defendant.

Nicholas Leahy, J’s Solicitor in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes said:

Wrongful birth cases are complex and interesting cases and this is an area of law that is still being regularly interpreted by the courts. This particular case caused significant additional distress to J but I am very pleased that we were eventually able to negotiate a successful outcome for her, which recognises the avoidable harm which was caused to her because of her unwanted pregnancy”.

If you would like to discuss your case with a medical negligence expert, please call Nicholas Leahy, or complete an online enquiry form.

 

Share this article

Contact

Contact Nick today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    • "Nicholas Leahy works extremely hard and understands the commercial sensitivities of clinical negligence litigation."

      Legal 500 2023

    • Excellent service from Osbornes throughout on a difficult clinical negligence claim. Nicholas Leahy who handled the claim was responsive and professional throughout, while also providing pragmatic advice and clear drafting.

      Client review

    • Working with Osbornes Law was the best decision I could have made. Nick was really attentive to my issue and did a very thorough job. He truly made the process headache free! Highly recommend them.

      Client review

    • Nick Leahy has been my Solicitor throughout this journey and has been absolutely amazing; kind, approachable and extremely supportive... Through some dogged determination by Nick we achieved our goal without having to go to trial. I cannot thank Nick, Stephanie and all of the team at Osbornes highly enough for achieving a very favourable settlement, the outcome of which will make a huge difference to myself and my family.

      Client review

    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. baby
      13.5.2024

      Birth Trauma Inquiry: Is poor maternity care the...

      Call for overhaul of maternity and post-natal care An All-Party Parliamentary Group has called for a huge overhaul of maternity...

      Read more
    2. 5.1.2024

      Delayed Pre-Eclampsia Diagnosis Resulting in Tragic Baby Loss

      Introduction to the Case Nick Leahy, Associate in our Clinical Negligence department, has recently settled a birth injury claim against...

      Read more
    3. 23.11.2023

      Claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant, C, in her birth negligence claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust for negligent...

      Read more
    4. baby
      31.8.2023

      Hyponatraemia – Symptoms, Causes & Negligence

      What is hyponatraemia? Hyponatraemia is a condition where sodium levels fall below a certain level, which can be dangerous. All...

      Read more
    5. pregnant lady
      23.3.2023

      Private Pregnancy Scans and Substandard Care

      In the news, it has been reported that private clinics that offer pregnancy scans to women are not meeting the...

      Read more
    6. baby hand in mothers hand
      7.3.2023

      5-figure settlement for infusion leak to mother

      Elline Demetriou has reached another successful outcome for a Claimant, who pursued a post C-section birth injury to mother claim...

      Read more
    7. water
      9.2.2023

      Perineal Tear case settles for 6-figure sum

      Stephanie Prior recently settled a claim relating to a woman who delivered her baby after a traumatic labour. Her son...

      Read more
    8. pregnant lady making a heart shape
      2.10.2022

      Tragic Case Involving a Home Water Birth

      Introduction to the case Nicholas Leahy is acting for a young woman who had a water birth at home and...

      Read more
    9. Hospital sign MATERNITY
      21.9.2022

      Are maternity services safe? – Part 2

      In April last year I wrote a piece about government setting up a taskforce to look into why there are...

      Read more
    10. Pregnant woman performing cardiotocography CTG
      8.9.2022

      Poor interpretation of CTG can result in stillbirth...

      Poor interpretation of a Cardiotocograph, more commonly known as a CTG, is a leading cause of stillbirth and brain injuries...

      Read more
    11. child with blue paint on hands
      2.9.2022

      Mother & Baby Suffer Life-changing Injuries

      Claim after mother and baby suffered life-changing injuries during birth Jodi is acting for both mother and baby in a...

      Read more
    12. Medical doctor in empty hospital corridor
      1.8.2022

      Bereavement Following Treatment at Basildon Maternity Unit

      Case Overview Stephanie Prior’s death by medical negligence claim relating to the death of Gabriela Pintilie has been settled...

      Read more
    13. doctor women at office
      29.6.2022

      Nottingham Maternity: Donna Ockenden to Chair Independent Inquiry

      An interim report on the state of maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust has just been released. However,...

      Read more
    14. 23.5.2022

      Successful Claim Against King’s College Hospitals

      The birth injury lawyers at Osbornes Law have recently negotiated the settlement of a case in which our client sustained...

      Read more
    15. Neglijenta medicala spital din UK
      23.2.2022

      Women from ethnic minorities experience worse maternity care

      It has been reported today that the government has set up a new task force to look into why there...

      Read more
    16. pregnant lady
      17.2.2022

      999 Call Handlers Maternity Instructions Report

      HSIB Report on Maternity Pre-arrival Instructions from 999 Call Handlers The Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch (“HSIB”) investigate NHS maternity incidents that...

      Read more
    17. Pregnant Woman and Gynecologist Doctor at Hospit
      2.2.2022

      Lifelong Consequences for Newborn Baby

      Osbornes Law specialises in assisting families who have experienced birth injuries. We have represented families who have faced the loss...

      Read more
    18. cute kid with disability playing
      27.1.2022

      Six-figure claim allows family to move home

      Six-figure compensation payment for a client Jodi Newton has secured a six-figure compensation payment for her client with cerebral palsy....

      Read more
    19. lesiones de nacimiento
      24.1.2022

      Likely settlement of £15-20 million

      A client who suffered cerebral palsy injuries at birth was awarded £200,000 as an interim payment in a claim against NHS...

      Read more
    20. Pregnant Woman and Gynecologist Doctor at Hospit
      2.1.2022

      Justice for Family Who Faced Loss of Newborn

      Osbornes Law specialises in assisting families who have experienced birth injuries. We have represented families who have faced the loss...

      Read more
    21. maternity sign
      17.11.2021

      NICE revises guidelines on Induced labour

      Most babies are born naturally at around 40 weeks gestation. However, some pregnancies continue for longer. According to data from the...

      Read more
    22. girl looking through binoculars
      2.10.2021

      Cerebral Palsy Compensation Supports Rehabilitation & Housing

      Six-figure sum compensation for client with cerebral palsy Jodi achieved a six-figure sum compensation for her client with cerebral palsy....

      Read more
    23. hospital bed
      20.7.2021

      Osbornes Successfully Settle Wrongful Birth Claim

      Nicholas Leahy, clinical negligence lawyer at Osbornes Law has recently negotiated the successful settlement of a wrongful birth case. Our...

      Read more
    24. white lilies
      1.7.2021

      Stillbirth following water birth at home

      Nicholas Leahy acted for a young woman who had a water birth at home and two midwives were allocated to...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL