New UK Supreme Court Ruling regarding Secondary Victims in Clinical Negligence Cases
Contact
Jodi Newton
Table of Contents
The Supreme Court has today, on the 11th January 2024, upheld the Court of Appeal’s order to dismiss the claims of secondary victims in Clinical Negligence cases in the matter known as Paul & Anor v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1. Secondary victims are considered to be those who are not subject directly to potentially negligent medical treatment but are witnesses to family members suffering injury or death as a consequence of it. In the three cases at issue before the Supreme Court, all claims were by family members for psychiatric illness caused by experiencing such events.
The Law Previously
Historically, in this area it has been the case that a person is unable to make a claim for any effect that the death or injury of another person has had on them. That said, case law has developed such that witnesses to an accident resulting from negligence have been permitted to make a claim for personal injury. The landmark case in this area is Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire [1991] UKHL 5, [1992] 1 AC 310, which arose from the Hillsborough disaster and specified five ‘control mechanisms’ – the criteria to be met for a successful claim by a secondary victim. Importantly, material to the Supreme Court’s decision today is the requirement for both physical and temporal proximity to the accident.
To date, the question of whether this principle extends to cases of medical negligence has neither been addressed in legislation nor by the Supreme Court. Master of the Rolls, Sir Geoffrey Vos, in the Court of Appeal stated that, whilst he “can quite see why secondary victims in these cases ought to be seen to be sufficiently proximate to the defendants to be allowed to recover damages for their psychiatric injury”, he was bound by the previous decision in Taylor v A Novo (UK) Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 194. In that case it was held that, for such a claim by a secondary victim to succeed, the event and the negligence cannot be separate in time. It is this dichotomy that prompted the Master of the Rolls to leave the decision as to whether to depart from previous case law to the Supreme Court.
The Outcome
By a majority of six to one, the Supreme Court held that medical professionals owe a duty of care to their patients only and that witnessing the death of a close family member is not something doctors can be expected to prevent. Additionally, it was deemed that the claimant’s loved ones had not died in an ‘accident’. The Court gave varying definitions of the term but it can be encapsulated as a “discrete event in the ordinary sense of that word, meaning something which happens at a particular time, at a particular place, in a particular way”. It was further clarified that an accident is distinct from “medical crisis” such as occurred in these cases.
In effect, this ruling signifies an end to potential claims for psychiatric illness by secondary victims in clinical negligence cases. While this may bring clarity to the legal landscape, it also raises questions regarding the broader implications for victims of clinical negligence and their families. It could be argued that limiting the scope for secondary victims to claim compensation could hinder access to justice and overlook the profound emotional toll these incidents can have on the families involved.
The Wider Effect
While the decision has a restrictive impact on secondary victims in matters of clinical negligence, the scope for secondary victims of other accidents, such as a Road Traffic Accident, has potentially increased. The Court held that secondary victims in such circumstances no longer need to show that the incident was ‘objectively horrifying’, or that the injury suffered by the secondary victim need be caused by ‘sudden shock’. This leaves the requirements to be met as follows; presence at the time of the accident or its aftermath, witnessing the accident or its aftermath, and a close tie of love and affection with the primary victim.
In light of this development, should you continue to have queries regarding your potential claim as a secondary victim or are uncertain as to how this precedent may be applicable to you, please contact us.
Share this article
“Osbornes handles a wide range of high-value and complex clinical negligence cases, with particular expertise in birth injury, delayed cancer diagnosis, spinal injury, and fatal claims.”
“Osbornes Law is an established firm which handles a breadth of complex and high-value clinical negligence matters.”
Contact a Clinical Negligence Solicitor Today
Call us 0207 485 8811
For all new enquiries, please submit your details via the contact forms on our website. This will ensure your query reaches the right team and is handled promptly.
He also has a niche specialism in claims involving cauda equina syndrome.
Elline Demetriou is building a strong practice as a clinical negligence solicitor, handling a wide variety of cases including delayed diagnosis, surgical negligence and birth injuries.
Elline is always a pleasure to work with and always on top of complex cases.
Elline is a gifted lawyer and possesses a powerful combination of legal and medical skills, being tactically astute and having strong client care skills.
Elline is a delightful to work with and super reliable; you know she'll do a perfect job.
She advises on spinal injury claims.
Jodi Newton acts for clients on claims arising from negligent obstetric care, sepsis and delays in diagnosis and treatment.
Jodi is passionate and balances that with the ability to see the right way to run a case from her first involvement.
Jodi is very knowledgeable, gets outstanding results for her clients, and is always available when assistance is required.
Jodi is an absolute star.
Hugh has particular strength handling issues of causation and informed consent.
Hugh Johnson advises on claims regarding failures to diagnose and manage spinal injuries, as well as failings in psychiatric care.
He thinks outside the box and is always thinking a step ahead of his opponent.
Hugh is utterly charming, highly empathetic and a first rate lawyer. He always comes in with good observations.
Osbornes Law offers experience in obstetric and fatal claims as well as niche cauda equina cases.
The team has particular expertise in cases stemming from delays in diagnosis as well as surgical injury and wrongful birth claims.
Osbornes Law is an established firm which handles a breadth of complex and high-value clinical negligence matters.
They are a very tight team. They're very friendly, helpful and obtain excellent results for clients.
A quality firm of solicitors with excellence at all levels of the team.
They know the law inside out and proactively work with counsel to drive cases forward. They are a go-to for complex claims.
Ben Posford, head of catastrophic injury, is well-known for spinal cord and cauda equina claims, including high-profile fatality work.
Josie Robinson brings 20 years of experience to the team, with specialist insight into pelvic mesh claims and maternal death cases.
Elline Demetriou supports the team on catastrophic injury cases and has a growing caseload in maternity and care home negligence.
Elline Demetriou is an up and coming associate. She is thorough and empathetic, with great client care skills.
Nicholas Leahy leads the firm’s inquests work and has developed a specialism in stillbirth and surgical fatality claims.
Nicholas Leahy is a very impressive associate. He is sharp and gets to the crux of the case quickly.
Jodi Newton is a fierce advocate for her clients and a very genuine person. She cares about each case.
Jodi Newton is fantastic. She's detail orientated and a really capable head of birth and paediatric negligence. She's a joy to work with.
Jodi Newton is particularly noted for her work on cerebral palsy and maternal injury claims.
Osbornes handles a wide range of high-value and complex clinical negligence cases, with particular expertise in birth injury, delayed cancer diagnosis, spinal injury, and fatal claims.
I am always happy to get instructions from Osbornes. They have excellent quality work, the team knows exactly what they are doing and are a real pleasure to work with. Excellent legal knowledge.
The team has excellent leadership and provide an above and beyond service for their clients.
A close knit team with excellent knowledge and technical acumen across the board.
You get a real sense that they care about clients and each other, working together to get the best results.
The team works very well together as they are genuinely kind and friendly people.
Hugh's technical knowledge is superb.
He is excellent with very complex cases and their nuances.
I am very confident with Hugh representing me and always value his expertise and advice. He's always many steps ahead.
He is a master tactician and so on the ball; not a single thing goes under his radar. He really understands the medical side and is always thinking about how to achieve the best outcome for clients.
Hugh Johnson is fiendishly intelligent, with a laser sharp focus on the issues that matter.
Josie Robinson- very experienced, caring and professional. Excellent.
Elline Demetriou is one to watch for the future. She is determined and thoughtful, with a real dedication to her clients.
She is very tough, a real fighter, and drives a hard bargain for her clients. She has good judgment, and a good sense of the strengths and weaknesses of a case.
Jodi Newton is a passionate, hard-working and committed partner. She is excellent with clients, and gives absolutely 100% to all of her cases.
Nicholas Leahy - understands client needs very well, very responsive and proactive.
Jodi is very experienced and knowledgeable
It is a pleasure to work with Jodi. She has an excellent understanding of the issues and provides a good service.
Osbornes are always professional and diligent in respect of their clients.
Osbornes has an excellent depth of experience across the team.
Across the board, they are all a pleasure to work with. They always keep a pragmatic head and all have an eye on the best outcome for the client.
Jodi Newton - very hands on, gives every case her heart and soul
Jodi Newton is rapidly becoming the go-to partner for cerebral palsy cases. She has the determination to fight for her clients and is involved in some of the biggest cases at the moment.
Nicholas Leahy is a very safe pair of hands and really compassionate with clients. I expect great things from him in future.
Small but very effective and experienced team so every client benefits from the personal touch but also highly skilled litigation know-how. Capability of the team means they can handle all aspects of very complex cases as well as straightforward matters.
Ben Posford typically operates in the team’s spinal cord and cauda equina syndrome litigation.
Jodi Newton holds over 20 years of experience in birth and surgical injury cases, including those pertaining to cerebral palsy, negligent treatment of sepsis, and negligent A&E treatment.
The team frequently represents claimants in complex cognitive and spinal injury disputes, involving hypertensions, spinal fractures, as well as inadequate treatment of heart and blood diseases.
The team handles a host of complex maternal claims, including cognitive injuries as a result of delayed birth treatments, cerebral palsy, and vaginal mesh litigation.
Josie Robinson is fantastic with clients, very commercial and hugely experienced. Opponents respect her and she gets great results.
Osbornes is a very respected firm in the marketplace.
They handle really complex cases very well
The clinical negligence team are knowledgeable and professional in their approach and demonstrate a high level of skill in litigation work.
Osbornes Law offers experience in obstetric and fatal claims as well as niche cauda equina cases.
Osbornes Law is an established firm which handles a breadth of complex and high-value clinical negligence matters.
Jodi is really tenacious; she demands the best results and manages to secure them. She's got real drive and energy.
Jodi is passionate about what she does and is a good lawyer.
Jodi is very astute and compassionate.
Jodi Newton is passionate about her work and is a really creative lawyer, always trying to find practical and innovative solutions to problems encountered.
Jodi Newton is knowledgeable and well regarded.
Jodi Newton has specific expertise regarding birth negligence cases, including those which involve cerebral palsy and Erb’s palsy injuries.
Osbornes has a skilled team of solicitors advising clients on a wide range of clinical negligence matters.
Hard working, approachable, good knowledge of clinical negligence and clients’ specific conditions
A joy to work with and always 100% client focused at all times.
The clinical negligence team at Osbornes is much lauded for its ability to ‘represent the diverse range of London-based clients
“The team is very quick and efficient in responding."
"Obsbornes Law is always client-focused and works tirelessly to obtain the best outcomes for clients."
Ben Posford leads the catastrophic injury team and regularly represents claimants in neurological injury and fatal accident claims. He also has a niche specialism in claims involving cauda equina syndrome.
Jodi Newton acts for clients on claims arising from negligent obstetric care, sepsis and delays in diagnosis and treatment. She also advises on spinal injury claims.
"She is really wonderful in sensitively handling clients in extreme situations and is a real fighter."
"Jodi Newton is approachable and always has the client's best interest at heart."
‘They are ambitious for their clients and expect high standards from all who work with them.’
"Osbornes somehow combine the accessibility of a local firm, with the professional standards of a national or city outfit."
"I’ve been hugely impressed by Jodi Newton – she’s truly passionate about her cases and her clients, a real fighter and a star in the making."
"Jodi Newton has carved out a niche specialism in cerebral palsy and serious claims arising out of childbirth. She is so committed to her clients and their claims that she always gains and deserves their respect. A true specialist."
"Osbornes, is described as having ‘superb judgement and a medical knowledge that is second to none."
"Ben Posford’s particular expertise in this area focuses upon cauda equina claims, of which he is an undisputed powerhouse."
"Jodi Newton is a tenacious and intelligent fee earner. She fights tooth and nail for her clients and gains their trust and respect from the outset."
"Nicholas Leahy works extremely hard and understands the commercial sensitivities of clinical negligence litigation."
"Her persistence, perspicacity, determination and efficiency are simply outstanding, as are her legal, analytical and negotiating skills."
They are an excellent firm who achieve fantastic outcomes for their clients. They are also very prominent in injuries to those travelling to or from Europe. Multiple languages are spoken by the team.
This firm is responsive and efficient. Their rapidity in dealing with complications or hiccups is excellent.
Jodi Newton is brilliant – a very capable, experienced and empathetic solicitor who has experience of handling high value and complicated cases. I am working with her on a cerebral palsy case at the moment, in which she has obtained an admission of liability and a substantial interim payment. A first class addition to the team.
Really great clinical negligence practice, staffed by experienced practitioners who know how NHS Trusts work. They also build great rapport with clients.’
The team at Osbornes was recently strengthened by the arrival of 'experienced and empathetic' associate Jodi Newton. She joins a department noted for its expertise in delayed diagnosis and wrongful birth claims.
A stand-out solicitor with a huge track record of successful clinical negligence work. She is forensic in her attention to detail, but also sees the broad sweep of strategic considerations”.
Excellent service from Osbornes throughout on a difficult clinical negligence claim. Nicholas Leahy who handled the claim was responsive and professional throughout, while also providing pragmatic advice and clear drafting.
Working with Osbornes Law was the best decision I could have made. Nick was really attentive to my issue and did a very thorough job. He truly made the process headache free! Highly recommend them.
Nick Leahy has been my Solicitor throughout this journey and has been absolutely amazing; kind, approachable and extremely supportive... Through some dogged determination by Nick we achieved our goal without having to go to trial. I cannot thank Nick, Stephanie and all of the team at Osbornes highly enough for achieving a very favourable settlement, the outcome of which will make a huge difference to myself and my family.
“The stand-out solicitor is Jodi Newton, who has a huge track record of successful clinical negligence work. She is forensic in her attention to detail, but also sees the broad sweep of strategic considerations”.
"An excellent firm which achieves fantastic outcomes for clients."
Osbornes provides a very intimate and personal client service which is increasingly rare in this sector.
The lawyers in the team are highly experienced and will drive cases very hard on behalf of their clients.
"An exceptional outfit. They take on difficult cases, fight hard and win."
"Offers specialist expertise in cauda equina syndrome cases."
"Osbornes often handles claims valued at over £1m, particularly relating to severe brain and spinal cord injuries and niche areas such as cauda equina syndrome and cycling accidents."
"The team were extremely professional in putting my needs first. There was a joined-up approach to catering for the client, and all lawyers involved were briefed and constructive."
Quite simply excellent, with a highly competent and well-rounded team. They understand complex medical litigation and have been our lifesavers, and we will always owe them our immense gratitude.
More from JodiVIEW ALL
26.6.2026NHS Maternity Failures: Nottingham Ockenden Report 2026
Nottingham maternity negligence: what the Ockenden Report means for affected families The Independent Maternity Review into maternity services at Nottingham...
Read more
2.6.2026BBC Panorama Exposes Maternity Failures at Nottingham NHS...
A new BBC Panorama investigation, “Maternity Failures: The Fight for Justice”, has brought renewed and deeply concerning attention to the...
Read more
20.4.2026Sussex maternity review: scope confirmed and more than 1,000...
First published 15 April 2026 · Updated 22 May 2026 In April 2026, the government announced that senior midwife Donna Ockenden would lead an independent review...
Read more- 13.4.2026
Racism in Maternity Care Still Persists
Racism in Maternity Care: Persistent Inequalities and the Urgent Need for Reform Racism in maternity care has once again been...
Read more - 3.3.2026
New Report Exposes Fundamental Failures in NHS Maternity...
Baroness Amos’ interim report lays bare a maternity system “not working for women, babies and families.” Last week the government-commissioned...
Read more - 19.2.2026
Supreme Court Allows Children to Claim Lost Years...
Landmark Supreme Court ruling: children can now claim lost years compensation for medical negligence On 18 February 2026 judgment was handed down...
Read more - 3.12.2025
Liability Secured for Child with Cerebral Palsy
Full admissions of liability secured on behalf of child with quadriplegic cerebral palsy Jodi Newton, Partner in our Medical Negligence...
Read more - 30.10.2025
Addenbrooke’s Hospital Complaints
Review finds harm to children by surgeon at Addenbrooke’s Hospital An independent review by Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation...
Read more - 27.8.2025
HSSIB Review Exposes NHS Maternity Failures
Patient safety body HSSIB publishes exploratory review of maternity and neonatal services As Head of Paediatric and Birth Negligence cases...
Read more - 10.7.2025
£700K Settlement for Crohn’s Disease Negligence
Negligent delay in diagnosing Crohn’s disease leads to £700K settlement Jodi Newton, Partner, was instructed in a case against...
Read more - 12.5.2025
Complaints Against Suspended Surgeon Ms Kuldeep Stohr
Ms Kuldeep Stohr, orthopaedic surgeon at Addenbrooke’s Hospital suspended In February 2025, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (CUH) confirmed...
Read more - 6.5.2025
Six-Figure Settlement for Negligent C-Section Delivery
Osbornes secures a six-figure settlement following a negligent caesarean section delivery Jodi Newton, Partner and head of our Obstetric and...
Read more 
14.10.2024Multi-Million Settlement in Cerebral Palsy Negligence Case
Judge awards multi-million settlement in cerebral palsy medical negligence claim Jodi Newton, Partner and specialist medical negligence lawyer at Osbornes...
Read more- 12.9.2024
Great Ormond Street Hospital Negligence & How to Claim
Review of negligence at Great Ormond Street Hospital At Osbornes Law, we’ve supported families through some of the most...
Read more - 29.8.2024
AB v Central London Community Healthcare NHS Trust
Background Our client, AB, had been using the Nexplanon contraceptive device for 6 years. She had a Nexplanon device inserted into...
Read more - 30.7.2024
What Is the Role Of a Physician Associate?
What does the Position of Physician Associate Mean for the NHS? There are many different jobs within the NHS, each...
Read more - 9.5.2024
Claim Against Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust...
Client obtains settlement after being victim of a surgical negligence Jodi Newton, Partner in our Clinical Negligence department, recently settled...
Read more 
11.1.2024Secondary Victim Claims
Secondary victims in clinical negligence cases What is a secondary victim in clinical negligence cases? Most compensation claims are concerned...
Read more- 26.9.2023
Maternity and Neonatal Scandals: Lessons Learned
Will investigations into NHS maternity services lead to real change? Over the past 15 to 20 years, NHS maternity services have come...
Read more - 19.9.2023
Spinal Fracture Case Settles for 6-figure Sum
Spinal Fractures following cessation of Denosumab injection Case Overview Osbornes Law were instructed in a spinal injury claim against Mid...
Read more - 31.8.2023
Can you sue the NHS for waiting times?
The NHS is facing an unprecedented challenge with 7.47 million people waiting for routine treatments. This crisis impacts everyone, from those...
Read more - 31.8.2023
Hyponatraemia – Symptoms, Causes & Negligence
What is hyponatraemia? Hyponatraemia is a condition where sodium levels fall below a certain level, which can be dangerous. All...
Read more - 10.8.2023
Ambulance Delays Affecting Rapid Patient Treatment
Failure to Meet Ambulance Response Targets In 2017, the Secretary of State for Health accepted the new ambulance performance standards recommended...
Read more - 1.8.2023
Bowel Ischaemia Fatality – Client Story
Jodi Newton, a Partner in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes Law, has recently settled a long running fatal medical...
Read more
