Successful settlement for negligent care during kidney transplant by NHS Trust

14 Dec 2022 | Stephanie Prior
hands of surgeon

Claimant v Royal Free London NHS Trust

Osbornes have reached a settlement agreement on behalf of a Claimant who brought proceedings against an NHS Trust for the negligent care provided to him during a kidney transplant in 2018.


The Claimant, a professional sportsman, was born with Alport Syndrome, a genetic condition, inherited from his mother; characterised by kidney disease, hearing loss and eye abnormalities.

In 2018 Claimant needed a kidney transplant due to his kidney failure, and his 41-year-old father was identified as a match. Claimant underwent a kidney transplant with the kidney donated by his father.

When a kidney is transplanted, there is always a short period when the kidney is deprived of blood and at risk of progressive damage. The risk is high when the kidney is warm as the issue remains metabolically active at this time. To minimise this risk the kidney must be rapidly cooled to reduce metabolic activity and preserve function.

However, Claimant’s father had been diagnosed with sickle cell trait and cold agglutinins, which puts the kidney at high risk of damage during a transplant. For patients with this syndrome, once the Kidney is removed, it should be perfused with large volumes of warm perfusion fluid to remove the donor blood and therefore all the cold agglutinins. After which, it should be cooled in the conventional way.

In this case, one of the operating surgeons was aware of the father’s cold reactive antibody but did not predict it would have a detrimental effect on transplantation. It is unclear if both surgeons were aware of the father’s condition. The surgeons did not flush father’s kidney with warm water; instead, immediately cooling the kidney after removing it from his body.

The kidney failed to function following the surgery, and the Claimant was informed that had they of known of the cold reactive anti agglutinin they would have first performed the warm flush, before the cold-water flush.

Claimant required a further living donor kidney transplant, which finally took place at the end of December 2020.

As a result of the failed surgery, the Claimant suffered a hiatus in his sporting career, and would have returned to full fitness by mid-2019. He would not have required additional treatment including the need for re-transplantation. He also would not have suffered an anticipated reduction in life expectancy.


A Letter of Claim was sent to the Defendant in May 2021.

The allegations against the Trust included, but were not limited to:

  • Failure to warn the Claimant about his father’s blood conditions
  • Failure to discuss the presence of donor cold agglutinins and sickle cell trait with a consultant haematologist before transplantation.
  • Failure to consider or mitigate the risk of agglutination and haemolysis related to the donor cold agglutinins and sickle cell trait respectively or to warn father or Claimant of the possibility of associated complications

A Letter of Response was received from the Defendant in January 2022. The Trust admitted failure by the renal team to discussing the presence of cold agglutinins in the father’s blood with the haematology department. They admitted that had such discussion taken place, it would have resulted in an alteration to the conventional perfusion method (i.e. the donor kidney would have been perfused in warm fluid first). This in turn, would have avoided the failed kidney transplant.

Following the Trust’s admission of liability, an offer was put forward by the Defendant in the sum of £140,000. Osbornes put forward a counteroffer of £165,000, and the Defendant’s thereafter put forward a counter-offer of £160,000 plus reasonable costs, which was accepted by the Claimant.

The Claimant was pleased with the outcome, which will hopefully compensate for the years of his career missed due to his ill-health and the impact it has had on his career going forwards.

Claimant’s Solicitor

Stephanie Prior, Partner, Osbornes Law


Chris Stephenson

Defendant’s Solicitor

Tania Kahlon, Bevan Brittan

Our medical negligence department is ranked as a leading team in London by Chambers UK and The Legal 500. We are also approved solicitors of Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA). This means we have demonstrated our specialist legal expertise and experience in running clinical negligence claims for patients. To speak with Stephanie regarding surgical negligence or other medical negligence case, please complete the online enquiry form below.

Share this article


Contact Stephanie today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    • Stephanie Prior leads the team with real experience and commitment to her clients. Able to spot a good case early on and see it through to conclusion.

      Legal 500 2024

    • Stephanie Prior leads a strong and competent team.

      Legal 500 2024

    • With 10 years of experience as a registered general nurse, stephanie is well placed to support clients through complex and sensitive claims.

      Legal 500 2024

    • Stephanie Prior ‘leads the team with real experience and commitment to her clients’

      Legal 500 2024

    • "Stephanie Prior is very empathetic and practical, she gets to the heart of a case quickly."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "Stephanie Prior is highly respected in the marketplace, with a great wealth of experience, superb judgment and medical knowledge that is second to none."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "Stephanie has always shown great judgment and common sense whilst building valuable relationships with her opponents."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "Stephanie Prior is a standout solicitor."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "Stephanie Prior is an experienced lawyer with immense knowledge of her specialism, which allows her to run her cases with strategic precision."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "Stephanie knows her way effortlessly around any clinical negligence issue and has a great strategic mind."

      Legal 500 2023

    • "I know [we have] expressed our appreciation, but I also wanted to thank you for all your hard work, time and patience in pursuing mum’s claim through to a successful outcome - your kind and professional approach was genuinely appreciated."

      Client review

    • “May I take this opportunity to thank you for your patience and true compassion in yet another very tough year of representation on the behalf of my wife. I certainly must say you did it all with amazing stamina and positivity which regenerated my self-esteem…. You honestly eased the pain and I can see a healing process ahead.”


    • Stephanie has developed a particularly strong reputation for her handling of birth injury claims, as well as cases concerning surgical negligence and delays in surgery.

      Chambers UK

    • "Stephanie Prior takes on complex cases and gets excellent results. She has a background in medicine which serves her clients well and is a realistic but tough litigator."

      Legal 500 2021

    • "Stephanie Prior is hugely dedicated, adored by her clients, tenacious, efficient and extremely knowledgeable."

      Legal 500 2021

    • "Stephanie Prior is very good with troubled clients and is easily able to make them feel at ease."

      Legal 500 2021

    • "Stephanie shows sensitivity and deals with things in an understanding way."

      Chambers UK 2021

    • The lawyers in the team are highly experienced and will drive cases very hard on behalf of their clients.

      Legal 500 2020 - Clinical Negligence

    • "Stephanie Prior has a realistic attitude to the complexities of the cases. She wins the trust of her clients and goes the extra mile to ensure they get the best outcomes."

      Legal 500 2020 - Stephanie Prior

    • Stephanie’s background in medicine gives her an ability to read between the lines where medical records and expert evidence are concerned and is a great asset.

      Legal 500 20202 - Stephanie Prior

    • "Her knowledge base is second to none and her understanding of the litigation process stands out, as does her ability to work collaboratively."

      Chambers UK

    • "Stephanie Prior... manages a varied caseload, including obstetric claims, child and adult brain injury cases and fatal and non-fatal spinal cord injury cases."

      Chambers UK

    • "Stephanie is experienced, knowledgeable of all aspects of clinical negligence work, and strategic in running cases."

      Chambers UK

    • "Key team members include the approachable, compassionate and efficient Stephanie Prior."

      The Legal 500

    • Stephanie Prior is always very professional and kind. Highly recommended.

      Medical Negligence Client

    • Stephanie Prior is ‘very warm’ and ‘caring’, and an ‘exceptional professional’.

      Legal 500

    • Stephanie Prior continues to receive widespread praise from clients, who state that she explains the legal aspects of the case very clearly, and she is also a caring person who handles cases on a personal level.

      Chambers UK

    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. 23.11.2023

      Maternity Negligence Claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant, C, in her birth negligence claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust for maternity...

      Read more
    2. Cancer treatment in a modern medical private clinic

      Large Compensation for Delayed Laryngeal Cancer Diagnosis

      Actress receives financial award after life-changing missed cancer diagnosis. Jodi Newton acted for a client who was belatedly diagnosed with...

      Read more
    3. Fatal Medical Negligence Claim

      Delayed cervical cancer diagnosis claim

      Jodi Newton acted for a woman who died following a delayed cervical cancer diagnosis. The deceased could have been diagnosed...

      Read more
    4. hospital

      Fatal Claim: failure to diagnose appendicitis case settles...

      Stephanie Prior was instructed in a claim against Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust, where our client’s mother (JC) tragically passed...

      Read more
    5. model of a spine

      Spinal Fracture Case Settles for 6-figure Sum

      Spinal Fractures following cessation of Denosumab injection Stephanie Prior was instructed in a spinal injury claim against Mid and South...

      Read more
    6. Beautician hold syringe for young female client

      Delayed skin cancer diagnosis

      We are pleased to have successfully settled a client’s claim for a delayed cancer diagnosis – Basal Cell Carcinoma (“BCC”)....

      Read more
    7. Fatal Medical Negligence Claim

      Failure to Treat Bowel Condition

      Jodi Newton, a Partner in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes Law, has recently settled a long running case against...

      Read more
    8. hospital

      Prison Healthcare Negligence

      Nicholas Leahy, a solicitor in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes Law, has  recently successfully settled a long running case...

      Read more
    9. Confidential file

      Osbornes Instructed After Local Authority Data Breach

      Osbornes Law has recently negotiated a settlement on behalf of two clients who had their personal information inadvertently released to...

      Read more
    10. baby hand in mothers hand

      5-figure settlement for infusion leak to mother

      Elline Demetriou has reached another successful outcome for a Claimant, who pursued a post C-section birth injury to mother claim...

      Read more
    11. water

      Perineal Tear case settles for 6-figure sum

      Stephanie Prior recently settled a claim relating to a woman who delivered her baby after a traumatic labour. Her son...

      Read more
    12. dentist

      Court avoided after settlement agreed in dental negligence...

      The Medical Negligence team have recently negotiated the settlement of a complex dental negligence case. Our client experienced a number...

      Read more
    13. Doctor With Stethoscope And Files

      Delayed diagnosis of appendiceal cancer

      The medical negligence team at Osbornes Law has recently settled a case involving a patient who passed away following a...

      Read more
    14. hands of surgeon

      Successful settlement for negligent care during kidney transplant...

      Claimant v Royal Free London NHS Trust Osbornes have reached a settlement agreement on behalf of a Claimant who brought...

      Read more
    15. Modern dental office interior

      Successful claim against dental practice after negligent treatment

      Osbornes Law have reached another successful outcome for a client, who pursued a claim against dental practitioners due to medical...

      Read more
    16. pregnant lady making a heart shape

      Osbornes Act for Family after Tragic Stillbirth

      Nicholas Leahy is acting for a young woman who had a water birth at home and two midwives were allocated...

      Read more
    17. child with blue paint on hands

      Life-changing Injuries during birth

      Claim after mother and baby suffered life-changing injuries during birth Jodi is acting for both mother and baby in a...

      Read more
    18. Medical doctor in empty hospital corridor

      Successful settlement for birth injury that led to...

      Stephanie Prior’s case relating to the death of Gabriela Pintilie has been settled and approved by the High Court....

      Read more
    19. Doctor

      GP Negligence claim leading to fatality successfully settled

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant who brought proceedings on behalf of the estate of her late son, X, relating to...

      Read more
    20. Neglijenta medicala spital din UK

      Justice for client who suffered serious birth injuries

      The birth injury lawyers at Osbornes Law have recently negotiated the settlement of a case in which our client sustained...

      Read more
    21. Female surgeon wearing surgical mask

      Severe abdominal pain prolonged due to failed surgery

      Jodi Newton was instructed in a claim against London North West University Healthcare NHS Trust where our client suffered serious...

      Read more
    22. Anatomy of Shoulder

      Nerve injury following bowel surgery

      Stephanie Prior was instructed in a claim against Luton & Dunstable University Hospital where our client sustained an injury to...

      Read more
    23. Pregnant Woman and Gynecologist Doctor at Hospit

      Child Left with Brain Injuries at Birth

      Osbornes Law specialises in assisting families who have experienced birth injuries. We have represented families who have faced the loss...

      Read more
    24. Female surgeon with medical reports running

      Recent fatal medical negligence cases

      Osbornes Law specialises in helping families who have suffered a fatality due to inadequate medical care. Our specialist team is...

      Read more