Warehouse Worker Fights Aldi’s False Dishonesty Claims
Contact
Jaro Bernat
Table of Contents
Aldi’s worker suffers ‘mental torture’ after the supermarket giant falsely accuses him of lying
In a shocking case that highlights the struggles faced by workers against powerful corporations, a warehouse worker endured four years of ‘mental torture’ after the supermarket giant, Aldi, accused him of being ‘fundamentally dishonest’ about a workplace accident which left him struggling to walk and with tinnitus. Despite clear evidence of his injuries, Aldi’s relentless accusations left the worker fighting not only for his health, but also for his integrity.
What happened ?
Tibor Muranyi, 56, from Derby, was unable to work for four months after his warehouse vehicle was hit by another one from behind, injuring his back.
Despite the incident being caught on CCTV and Aldi admitting breach of duty, the company claimed Tibor was lying about the severity of his injuries, accusing him of fundamental dishonesty. If proven, his fundamental dishonesty could have resulted in up to two years in jail.
Aldi eventually settled the case for £20,000 two weeks before the trial, earlier this year.
Jaro Bernat, a specialist personal injury lawyer at Osbornes Law, who represented Tibor, says defendants are increasingly making spurious claims of fundamental dishonesty against claimants.
The impact on Tibor’s life
The accusation left Tibor distraught and feeling bullied. He said: “I couldn’t comprehend why they were claiming that I was being dishonest after everything I had suffered. I had a good life before and I was happy, so there was no reason for me to lie.
I have never felt so bullied and subjugated in my life. It was like they were gaslighting me, telling me that what I had been through wasn’t true and that I was exaggerating everything.
It was a mental torture and this shouldn’t be allowed to happen. It didn’t seem a litigation, but more of a psychological war. They may think it’s just a game where lawyers battle it out, but this affects and ruins ordinary people’s lives.”
Tibor’s accident occurred at the Aldi’s warehouse in Derby in November 2020. Following the incident he struggled with back pain and developed tinnitus which affected his sleep and mental health.
Tibor said: “The accident had a devastating impact on my life, both financially and psychologically. I was constantly worried about money when I was off work and this put pressure on my relationship of six years which eventually ended. I was unable to sleep and I was generally angry.
When I went back to work it felt like they were constantly criticising me. I was expected to work at the same rate as before the accident, but I was in a lot of pain. People stopped talking to me and I felt like I was being excluded. This was mental torture for me, so I decided to leave. But when I started the legal action the mental torture continued as they claimed I was a liar.”
Conclusion and thoughts
Jaro Bernat and the team at Osbornes Law worked tirelessly to ensure that Tibor’s voice was heard and his suffering acknowledged. Jaro’s expertise in personal injury law and his unwavering belief in Tibor’s honesty played a crucial role in challenging Aldi’s unfounded accusations. His relentless pursuit of justice not only helped Tibor secure a settlement but also highlighted the importance of holding powerful entities accountable for their actions. Moreover, our client was able to find some measure of justice and begin the process of rebuilding his life.
Jaro Bernat said:
“I always believed my client was telling the truth, but Aldi subjected him to a horrific ordeal, persistently questioning his integrity to the point where he potentially faced claims of fundamental dishonesty in court. It must be incredibly difficult for the claimant to deal with this; you bring a genuine claim, but instead of waiting to receive damages, you have to fight to avoid up to two years in jail.
This is an outrageous behaviour from a corporate giant, but unfortunately spurious allegations of fundamental dishonesty are becoming a well-used tactic by defendant lawyers. I am pleased that Aldi finally saw sense and settled this claim allowing Tibor to move on with his life, but it should never have gone this far.”
How can we help?
This case serves as a reminder of the critical role that compassionate and skilled legal representation plays in ensuring that the voices of the vulnerable are heard and that justice is served. If you or someone you know has been unfairly treated or falsely accused following a workplace accident, don’t hesitate to seek legal assistance. Please contact the personal injury team at Osbornes Law by:
- Filling in our online enquiry form; or
- Calling us on 020 7485 8811
Share this article
“Osbornes is a well-regarded personal injury practice well equipped to advise on high-value and high-profile claims.”
“Osbornes deals with injuries incurred during traffic and workplace accidents.”
Contact us today
Call us 020 7485 8811
Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you
Osbornes Law is a really strong team with a lot of depth.
Osbornes work professionally as a team, responding diligently to emails or telephone calls.
Osbornes clients are individuals whose cases are treated with the focus required when dealing with life changing injuries.
Fielding a ‘first class, very well resourced’ team of litigators, the personal injury department at Osbornes is rated for its diverse workload of complex, high-value injury claims, representing both domestic and international claimants.
Osbornes is an excellent firm, made up of lawyers with flair and pedigree.
Osbornes lawyers are smart, well trained, experienced and well managed.
Osbornes personal injury practice is first class; very well resourced and second to none.
Osbornes is becoming one of the top players in the claimant personal injury market. A large team with a great number of very high quality solicitors.
Osbornes is a highly proficient serious injury firm. They bring all the benefits of the biggest firms in the market but none of the downsides.
Osbornes prepares cases well; the whole team is good and lawyers there know their stuff.
They deal with people compassionately and take on the right amount of detail. The firm has some really brilliant key solicitors.
The personal injury team is responsive and its level of service towards clients and other professionals is exceptional and high quality
The team offers specialist expertise in cycling-related injury claims and regularly acts for foreign nationals.
It has considerable experience in cases arising from motor accidents and accidents at work
Osbornes is a well-regarded personal injury practice well equipped to advise on high-value and high-profile claims.
Their team includes bright, hard-working solicitors dedicated to achieving successful outcomes for their clients from partner level to paralegal. Their client care is exceptional.
They are a team who are highly respected in the PI sector.
This is an excellent PI team doing a broad range of PI work.
Osbornes’ ‘highly respected‘ personal injury team is experienced in a range of complex, high-value claims, with notable strength in acting for European clients for whom English is not a first language.
Osbornes’ ‘highly respected‘ personal injury team is experienced in a range of complex, high-value claims
Osbornes’ ‘highly respected‘ personal injury team is experienced in a range of complex, high-value claims.
"They punch well above their weight. The quality of service they provide equals that of any of the larger top-name firms in this area"
Ben Posford is fiercely bright, with an unrivalled passion for his clients’ cases. His encyclopaedic knowledge of all things PI is second to none. His foresight and commercial nous have propelled Osbornes into the highest echelons of the market where they rightly belong.
The firm has an excellent and innovative line in cases involving non-English speaking claimants, managed by recruiting paralegals with multi-language skills – an impressive route for expansion of the caseload.
Great expanding team with expertise and respect in the sector. Led by a commercially savvy and business minded team.
A really excellent group of PI solicitors, notable for their individual quality.’
A niche firm that punches well above its weight in the catastrophic injury sector, borne out by the quality of work they obtain.
This combination of experience and diligence reaps massive rewards for clients, Osbornes being well known in the industry as a fantastic firm.
The Osbornes personal injury team now comprises some of the most technically adept and hard hitting lawyers in the business.
Excellent coverage of personal injury, and traumatic brain injury. There is a real specialism in claimants who do not speak English as a first language.
The group is noted for its expertise in matters relating to cycling injuries, and is the official legal partner of the London Cycling Campaign charity.
To complement its strong reputation for high-value and complex personal injury work, the firm continues to develop its 'excellent and innovative line in cases involving non-English speaking claimants'
"Osbornes comprises some of the most technically adept and hard hitting lawyers in the business"
Related InsightsVIEW ALL
22.10.2024£75,000 Settlement for Head Injury at College
Accident During a College Class Eloise Mears, Solicitor at Osbornes Law, represented a student who sustained a head injury while...
Read more
26.4.2024Head Injury Following Slip at Work
Client who slipped at work obtains a good settlement Laura Swaine recently settled a work accident claim for a client...
Read more- 26.4.2024
Six-Figure Settlement for Head Injury at Work
Settlement for a client injured at work Laura Swaine recently settled a claim for a client who was injured while...
Read more - 14.3.2024
Strawberry Picker Receives £10,500 After Accident at Work
Incident in the Strawberry Field Our client was at work, walking in the field and carrying cages with strawberries, when...
Read more - 13.3.2024
Accident at Work Compensation Examples
Factory Worker Receives £14,000 for Hot Water Burns Our client was working in a food producing factory. He was injured when...
Read more 
13.2.20245-figure Payout for Death of Hungarian Lorry Driver
Hungarian lorry driver tragically dies Siobhan McIvor, a Partner and Personal Injury lawyer, has successfully settled a fatal accident compensation...
Read more
6.12.2023Accident at work claim settled for Romanian driver
Siobhan McIvor, a Partner in the Personal Injury Department, has successfully settled an accident at work claim arising from an...
Read more- 5.12.2023
£75,000 Compensation After Accident Leads to Blood Clot
£75k Settlement Following Injury at Work Serious injury lawyer, Blanca Diego Casas recently represented an individual who suffered serious medical...
Read more - 23.11.2023
Accident at work claim settled for Hungarian factory...
Forklift trucks are a common cause of warehouse injury claims due to human error on the part of the forklift...
Read more 
11.4.2023£250,000 settlement for client injured in forklift accident
Sophie Davies, a specialist personal injury lawyer at Osbornes Law, recently represented a client who suffered life-changing injuries following a...
Read more- 17.11.2021
£100,000 settlement for tripping at work
Osbornes Law secures £100,000 settlement for Hungarian woman who tripped over a shopping bag at work Siobhan McIvor, a Partner in...
Read more - 17.11.2021
£165,000 settlement for factory accident
Siobhan McIvor, a Partner in the Personal Injury Department of Osbornes Law, has settled a £165,000 accident at work claim, with...
Read more - 31.8.2021
Kitchen Accident Claim
Our client, a hospitality supervisor instructed Osbornes after he slipped and fell on oil and food debris on the floor...
Read more - 18.5.2021
Construction Site Accident at Work
Our client suffered numerous fractures to their left leg requiring surgery following a work accident on a construction site. He...
Read more - 18.5.2021
Compensation for Amputation on Construction Site
Our client worked as a carpenter/bricklayer on a building site at a residential property in North London. He was...
Read more - 2.9.2020
Lasting damage to ankle following construction accident settles...
Sam Collard, a Partner in the Osbornes’ catastrophic injury team, recently settled a construction accident claim for a Romanian man...
Read more - 13.8.2019
Fatal Accident Conviction Highlights Health & Safety
Construction bosses guilty of gross negligence manslaughter Conrad Sidebottom, 46, and Richard Golding, 43, were jailed for their part in causing the...
Read more
