Dr Jane Barton Report

18 Jun 2018 | Stephanie Prior

The latest scandal facing the NHS is the case of now retired Doctor Jane Barton, who on her watch between 1988-2000, at the Gosport War Memorial Hospital in Portsmouth, signed the death certificates of 833 patients. A report commissioned by the Gosport Panel will reveal its findings on Wednesday 20th June. The accusation is that Barton unnecessarily prescribed an opium drug for pain relief, contributing to the death of some of her patients. Families allege that patients at the hospital were “almost routinely” given strong painkillers in high doses, which in some cases led to their deaths. Many believe that patients were given high doses of drugs to ‘keep them quiet’.

Stephanie Prior, head of medical negligence at Osbornes Law, spoke to Nick Ferrari on LBC breakfast on the 17th June. Stephanie, a former A&E nurse commented that the report was hopefully going to provide answers to the families involved.

The remit of the report is not to establish whether Barton is guilty of manslaughter or murder. Prior comments that access to justice for the families will be limited as Barton is retired and her being ‘struck off’ will have little impact. Quite astonishingly Barton was found guilty of “multiple instances of serious professional misconduct” by the General Medical Council in 2010 but was not struck off!

There is also a strict time limit as to when a person can bring a claim for medical negligence, which sadly, has long elapsed. As Stephanie says, the only way to bring a claim after such a long time is in very exceptional circumstances.

James Jones, The former Bishop of Liverpool, who published a report on the Hillsborough tragedy, will deliver his findings to families of patients who died on Wednesday 20th June. Many of the families are hoping that the report will provide enough evidence to escalate proceedings to the Crown Prosecution Service.

It is expected that both Theresa May and Health Secretary, Jeremy Hunt, will make statements to the House of Commons on the reports findings.

Prior made the point during her interview that hospitals usually carry out investigations to prevent incidents such as what occurred at Gosport War Memorial Hospital from repeating. Sadly, however this did not prove to be the case and Prior suggests that patients age and other health problems, may have masked the issue and decisions of Barton.

You can listen to the full interview below.

To contact Stephanie Prior or a member of the medical negligence team at Osbornes call us on 020 7485 8811 or fill in our online form.

Share this article

Contact

Related InsightsVIEW ALL

  1. 31.1.2022

    Recent fatal medical negligence cases

    Osbornes Law specialises in helping families who have suffered a fatality due to inadequate medical care. Our specialist team is...

    Read more
  2. syringe
    15.12.2021

    Vaccine Related Blood Clots And Delays in Diagnosis

    Deep Vein Thrombosis, Pulmonary Embolism and Vaccine Induced Blood Clots The worldwide COVID-19 immunisation programme has been in full swing...

    Read more
  3. 9.7.2021

    Clinical Negligence Resulting in Death – Legal Options to...

    The loss of a loved one is an extremely distressing time for their family, made even more distressing if there...

    Read more
  4. stethescope
    8.7.2021

    Failure to prescribe anti-coagulant medication proves fatal

    Executor of the Estate of DS and another v James Paget University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust The Clinical Negligence team...

    Read more
  5. hospital monitor
    18.5.2021

    Fatality of child caused by incorrect diagnosis

    KRB was born in 2000 and was a patient at Whipp’s Cross Hospital. In the Autumn of 2014 he was feeling...

    Read more
  6. blue water
    13.10.2020

    Statutory Parental Bereavement Pay & Leave

    Pregnancy and childbirth can be a very exciting but anxious time for both parents.  The uncertainty and the anticipation of...

    Read more
  7. anxious woman
    27.8.2020

    Reform is needed for inquests and inquiries relating...

    It has been reported that an ‘influential thinktank has urged the Lord Chancellor to grant automatic legal aid to bereaved...

    Read more
  8. 17.1.2020

    Inquest held for former cab driver

    A former black cab driver starved himself to death in hospital after being allowed to refuse food and drink despite...

    Read more
  9. clouds
    13.11.2019

    Fatal Claim against West London NHS Trust

    I recently acted in a claim for a fatality against West London NHS Trust for damages under the Law Reform (...

    Read more
  10. syringe
    4.7.2019

    Stephanie Prior explains possible causes of fatal Strep...

    In an article published by the Essex Chronicle, Stephanie Prior, Head of Medical Negligence, shares her view on what could...

    Read more
  11. 22.5.2019

    Bereavement Award

    A Historic Decision In the case of Smith v Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust & Ors (Rev 2) [2017] EWCA Civ 1916,...

    Read more
  12. Ambulance
    29.4.2019

    Successful Claim After Ambulance Delay

    Stephanie Prior, Head of Medical Negligence acted for J, who was a dependent of C his partner. C suffered from...

    Read more
  13. 18.6.2018

    Dr Jane Barton Report

    The latest scandal facing the NHS is the case of now retired Doctor Jane Barton, who on her watch between 1988...

    Read more
  14. thermometer
    19.1.2018

    Fatal Sepsis Misdiagnosed As Flu

    First of all, a bit of background on the current UK flu season. Right now, in health-related media matters a...

    Read more
  15. 18.9.2016

    Inquest finds negligence led to man’s death

    On Tuesday 13th September 2016, Chelmsford coroner’s court recorded a narrative verdict and found that serious medical failings led to...

    Read more
  16. 26.10.2015

    Inquest rules negligence after death of 14 year old

    An inquest has ruled that Whipps Cross Hospital, which is part of the Bart NHS Trust was negligent in the...

    Read more

VIEW ALL