Government opens consultation on tougher penalties for corporate manslaughter

13 Aug 2019 | Ben Posford

Despite widespread condemnation, the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act came into force in October 2013, and in part 5 of the Act’s inappropriately titled “Reduction of legislative burdens” section was included a provision changing the law on civil liability (section 69 of the Act).

This meant the Act removed civil liability for a breach of health and safety regulations, which with hindsight seems extraordinary unwise.  At the time, many legal commentators wrote about their fears that this would be interpreted as reducing the “legislative burden” on employers, and the devastating effect this could have on employees and employers alike.  Many of those who act for people affected by negligence, including the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers, campaigned against the removal of civil liability, arguing that any employer complacency could reverse the trend in workplace fatalities and would inevitably lead to a call for tougher penalties when employees are killed in the workplace.

It is with tentative approval therefore that a consultation paper has been published at the beginning of July 2017 in which the Sentencing Council is now looking at tightening the guidelines for manslaughter by gross negligence, and employers who inadequately consider the safety of employees could face longer prison sentences under full sentencing guidelines for manslaughter offences. Factors to consider will now include negligent conduct motivated by financial gain or cost-saving.

Whilst it is hoped this might reverse the damage done in recent years, it is feared that any sentencing changes will not go far enough.  Health and safety is a state of mind, and adherence to its rules and the core principle of undertaking suitable and sufficient risk assessments are absolutely crucial to keeping employees and others safe.

Reinstating civil liability for regulatory breaches, and reversing the underfunding of the HSE would be two very good starting points, and would likely have a more beneficial effect than simply increasing the penalties for corporate manslaughter.

Ben Posford is a partner and head of catastrophic injury at Osbornes, and acts exclusively for injured and killed claimants and their families, including those killed in the workplace. He is also instructed in relation to the Croydon Tram Crash.

Ben Posford’s previous articles on these issues for The Times and the Solicitors Journal written in September 2013 are still available to view online.

Share this article

Contact

Contact the Personal Injury team today

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    Personal Injury InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. highway code bike lights
      5.5.2022

      Top 10 Major Highway Code Changes for Cyclists

      New Highway Code rules for cyclists At the end of January 2022, the Highway Code was updated to make British roads...

      Read more
    2. 20.1.2022

      What to do immediately after a cycling accident?

      If you have been involved in a cycling accident, you may experience shock and disorientation at the scene. Depending on...

      Read more
    3. 24.11.2021

      Ben Posford named catastrophic injury lawyer of the...

      Osbornes Law are delighted to announce that Ben Posford has been named as ‘Catastrophic Injury Lawyer of the Year’ at...

      Read more
    4. 23.9.2021

      Croydon Tram Crash Inquest Recommendations Welcomed

      The families of victims killed in the Croydon tram crash today welcomed a coroner’s recommendations to prevent another tragedy....

      Read more
    5. 16.9.2021

      The law around E-bikes and E-scooters explained

      Why are electric bikes legal but not scooters? E-bikes and e-scooters are the new rides on the block. To many,...

      Read more
    6. 26.8.2021

      Osbornes Sponsor Leading Medico-Legal Conference

      Osbornes Law is delighted to be the principal sponsor of the Cambridge Annual Medico-Legal Conference. This year conference, which is...

      Read more
    7. 2.8.2021

      London Tube Sign Causes Head Injury

      Serious brain injury claim after falling London tube sign knocks pedestrian unconscious. An airline pilot ‘miraculously’ survived after a 20kg...

      Read more
    8. 22.7.2021

      Croydon Tram Crash Inquest Concludes

      Families of Croydon tram crash victims disappointed by Inquest conclusion The families of victims killed in the Croydon tram crash...

      Read more
    9. ogden tables for personal injury
      2.2.2021

      Compensation Tables for Personal Injury

      What are the Ogden Tables? If you have been injured in an accident that was not your fault, you may...

      Read more
    10. 5.1.2021

      Farming accidents high risk for self-employed

      Agriculture represents a dangerous industry in the UK, and according to the Health and Safety Executive’s report 2020/2021, farm deaths...

      Read more
    11. 31.12.2020

      Bike Boxes – what are the rules?

      Cycle boxes at traffic lights I read a post recently on a London cycling forum in relation to some confusion...

      Read more
    12. highway code road signs
      2.11.2020

      Highway Code changes just the start in protecting...

      The 2020 changes to the Highway Code do not go far enough to change driver behaviour and protect cyclists and pedestrians,...

      Read more
    13. Accidente en almacén
      15.10.2020

      Fatal Accidents In The Workplace

      A new article from the BBC takes a looked at fatal accidents at work. The report states that since 1981, there...

      Read more
    14. school children writing
      13.10.2020

      When To Seek Advice Following An Accident At...

      Autumn is upon us and it’s the start of another academic year. With a 7 year old boy recently being...

      Read more
    15. zebra crossing
      8.10.2020

      Pedestrian hit by car on zebra crossing settles...

      Blanca Diego, Solicitor in the Osbornes Personal Injury Department, recently settled a claim for a Spanish client who sustained injuries...

      Read more
    16. 21.9.2020

      Motorcyclists – Could your actions be invalidating your insurance?

      Insurance cover for you and your bike is vital in the event of an accident or theft but beware – insurance...

      Read more
    17. headway east london brain charity
      17.9.2020

      Osbornes partners with leading Brain Injury Charity

      Lights, Camera, Legal Advice!  This week marks the launch of a new series of 16 legal advice videos with brain injury...

      Read more
    18. injury at work
      30.7.2020

      Self-Employed Injury At Work

      Dealing with a personal injury claim as a self-employed worker Being self-employed has its advantages, including independence, creative freedom, job...

      Read more
    19. 15.7.2020

      Osbornes Law joins legal panel of national road...

      Osbornes are delighted to announce that the firm has joined the legal panel of the national charity for road crash...

      Read more
    20. 29.6.2020

      The Dangers of Working on Farms

      According to the Health and Safety Executive, over the last 10 years, almost one person a week has been killed as...

      Read more
    21. divorced man with empty wallet
      19.6.2020

      What happens if a solicitor goes bust?

      What happens if my solicitor has ceased trading? Like many business, some solicitors’ practices are struggling at the moment financially...

      Read more
    22. accident at work injury
      19.6.2020

      Changes to employer’s liability for work accidents

      As it now stands employers are automatically liable for some workplace injuries, (without the Claimant having to prove “fault”) is...

      Read more
    23. APIL logo
      9.6.2020

      Senior Catastrophic Injury Solicitor Robert Aylott gains further...

      Rob Aylott, senior solicitor in the Personal Injury team has recently been confirmed as an APIL Accredited Fatal Accidents Specialist (...

      Read more
    24. 9.6.2020

      The importance of parks for cycling

      I ventured outside the comfort of my home this past weekend for the first time in 11 weeks. As I walked...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL