High Court finds Westminster Council’s Housing Scheme Unlawful
Contact
William Ford
Table of Contents
Westminster City Council’s housing allocation scheme found to be unlawful
The High Court has today handed down judgment finding that Westminster City Council’s housing allocation scheme is unlawful, on the grounds that it fails to afford reasonable preference to homeless persons.
Background
The two Claimants were homeless applicants and had both applied to join the Council’s housing register. Both Claimants’ applications were refused. The Council had, however, accepted that the relief duty applied to both Claimants. The relief duty applies where a local authority is satisfied that an applicant is homeless and eligible for assistance, and the local authority is then required to take reasonable steps to help the applicant to secure that suitable accommodation becomes available for the applicant’s occupation’ for at least six months.
However, at the time of the Claimants’ applications to be placed on the housing register the Council had not yet accepted that they were under a duty to provide the Claimants with suitable accommodation (often referred to as the “main housing duty”). The main housing duty is owed where a local authority is satisfied that a homeless application is homeless, eligible for assistance, in priority need of accommodation, and not homeless intentionally. The Claimants’ homeless applications were still under consideration at the time of their application to be placed on the housing register.
The Council’s housing allocation scheme provide as follows in relation to homeless applicants:
- Homeless
8.1. Households to whom Westminster City Council has accepted a statutory duty under the Housing Act 1996 as amended.
8.1.1. Households accepted as homeless will be given points as set out in section 2.6.33. If a homeless applicant becomes ineligible for housing (see section 1.2.3), the Council’s duty will end. …..”
8.1.2. Reasonable preference for homeless people is given on the basis that the applicant has satisfied the requirements that give rise to a statutory duty to provide accommodation under Part VII of the Act (except the interim duties to accommodate under sections 188 and 200 (1)). For those who are homeless and have not applied for housing assistance under Part VII of the Act, the Council will treat an application under Part VI as though it includes an application under Part VII for the purposes of assessing reasonable preferences.
8.1.3. Applicants who are owed the prevention duty under section 195 of the Act or the relief duty under section 189B of the Act will be provided with personalised housing plans. They will not generally be considered for inclusion on the housing register until a decision has been made as to what (if any) duty to provide accommodation is owed to them, although the Director of Housing can exercise discretion to consider them for inclusion at an earlier stage.
Whilst it is possible to read this part of the allocation scheme various ways, the Council confirmed prior to the issue of proceedings, and throughout the duration of the claim before the High Court, that the meaning of “households accepted as homeless” in this part of the policy was that the household was only considered to be eligible for inclusion on the housing register if the main housing duty has been accepted by the Council.
When drafting housing allocation schemes, local authorities are required to give “reasonable preference” to certain groups, which includes homeless persons. The relevant law can be found at s166A(3) of the Housing Act 1996 (“the Act”), which provides as follows:
3)As regards priorities, the scheme shall, subject to subsection (4), be framed so as to secure that reasonable preference is given to—
(a)people who are homeless (within the meaning of Part 7);
(b)people who are owed a duty by any local housing authority under section 190(2), 193(2) or195(2) (or under section 65(2) or 68(2) of the Housing Act 1985) or who are occupying accommodation secured by any such authority under section 192(3);
Claim
In the claim for judicial review we argued that the allocation scheme failed to provide reasonable preference to homeless persons who fall within section 166A (3)(a) of the Act, and all applicants who are owed accommodation duties as set out in section 166A (3)(b) of the Act other than those owed the main housing duty under section 193(2) of the Act.
It became clear during the Court proceedings from the Council’s own data that only 30% of the total number of applicants who were accepted to be homeless were found to be owed the main housing duty, and thus placed on the housing register. Everyone else was excluded.
The High Court has now found that the Council’s allocation scheme is unlawful. Whilst it is possible to exclude people to whom reasonable preference is owed from the housing register by reference to factors of general application (such as persons who have rent arrears, or those guilty of anti-social behaviour), it was not possible to exclude people by simply because they were homeless but not owed the main housing duty.
The Court found that the scheme operated in such a way as to thwart the aim of the legislation. In effect it amounted to a redefinition of the statutory class of those owed reasonable preference, effectively striking a line through s166A(3)(a) and excluding 100% of homeless applicants who were not also found to be in priority need and owed the main housing duty.
The judgment can be read in full here.
If you have any questions related to housing, please fill out the online enquiry form below and William Ford will be happy to help.
Share this article
“Osbornes has a particular strength in handling social housing challenges with a focus on homelessness and assisting children with disabilities.”
“Osbornes Law represents tenants in the full variety of housing law matters, including issues of possession, eviction, disrepair and anti-social behaviour.”
Contact William today
Call us 0207 485 8811
For all new enquiries, please submit your details via the contact forms on our website. This will ensure your query reaches the right team and is handled promptly.
His practice covers areas such as community care and welfare benefits, particularly in relation to migrants.
William Ford is experienced in representing tenants in disrepair and possession claims, as well as homelessness appeals and judicial reviews concerning allocation of housing.
Will picks up complex points very quickly and has good judgement. He can explain very complicated and technical things into plain language.
William is a very talented lawyer. He is very good on technical points and public law.
William Ford is a legend. He is really knowledgeable, determined and tenacious.
William is a real expert in his field.
William Ford has acted in numerous successful judicial reviews on behalf of vulnerable clients.
William Ford leads the team, bringing extensive experience across public law, including housing, welfare, community care, and migrant support.
William Ford heads the practice and has experience representing clients in a broad range of housing matters, including homelessness appeals, defending disrepair claims and unlawful evictions, as well as acting for clients in judicial review challenges.
William Ford is an excellent solicitor.
Will has conducted difficult cases in the highest courts, but is equally at home achieving difficult results for clients entirely under the radar.
William Ford is one of the top figures in the field, with a towering reputation.
William is rightly regarded as a leader in the fields of both housing and community care and a real go-to for complex claims.
William Ford is a powerhouse. He is extremely sharp and has great tactical judgement.
Will is the best housing solicitor there is and he has the best housing law mind I have come across. He is really exceptional and incredibly helpful for both clients and people in the sector.
He is the best lawyer someone could ever ask for. He is always proactive in working with his clients.
William Ford achieves exceptional results for his clients.
William is always well prepared and knowledgeable.
William Ford is incredibly helpful for clients and people in the sector.
William Ford is simply an amazing fellow. He is diligent, outstanding, amazing, reliable and dedicated to his work.
He is brilliantly committed and dedicated to this area of law.
William Ford leads the team as an excellent example of a highly committed, tenacious, and effective public lawyer.
William Ford has a forensic knowledge of housing law and is extremely intelligent, very thorough, and excellent with clients
William Ford is one of the most highly-regarded solicitors in his area.
Will is a knowledgeable and experienced litigator. He is adept at achieving great results for his clients.
William Ford has long been a leading individual in the housing law world.
William has taken some brilliant cases to the highest court. He is diligent, intelligent and very dedicated to his clients.
Ford is well-equipped to bring judicial review claims, and he has a strong focus on supporting migrants.
Practice head William Ford is praised as ‘the best housing and social security lawyer in the sector.
Incredibly knowledgeable and very intelligent. Will knows how to use public law to the advantage of his clients
Will Ford is exceptional
William Ford is unbelievably clever and very considerate to his clients
Will is a very down-to-earth guy who produces really fantastic work; it is a joy to work on cases with him
Will is a very able and unbelievably clever lawyer who is on top of his subject and is very considerate to his clients.
Modern practice headed by Will Ford who has developed an excellent team. Able to take on the most difficult cases at short notice and prepare excellent electronic paperwork for the courts.
William Ford is the best housing and public law solicitor of his generation.
Will Ford is a stand-out expert and is incredibly dedicated to the field.
There are some incredibly committed and knowledgeable lawyers, such as Will Ford.
Will is involved in cutting-edge cases in the higher courts as well as invaluable frontline work and brings the same focus and dedication to both
Will Ford is a highly respected practitioner who has an encyclopaedic knowledge of housing law. He is extremely intelligent and very hard-working.
Will Ford is hands down one of the best housing lawyers out there. Clever, pragmatic, good with clients, reasonable with opponents, incredibly knowledgeable and, as a result, extremely effective
Ford is particularly notable in community care matters and its crossover with housing law, an area which is a growing specialism for the team.
The social housing team at Osbornes is led by William Ford, a ‘standout‘ expert in all aspects of social housing who is ‘involved in cutting-edge cases in the higher courts as well as invaluable frontline work'
William Ford is experienced in representing tenants in disrepair and possession claims, as well as homelessness appeals and judicial reviews concerning allocation of housing.
"He has a really good eye for detail, able to untangle and trace complicated matters. He has real expertise in welfare public law issues."
"Will is very technically competent and smart and he's very generous with his time."
"William is truly extraordinary. He is wonderful, clever, bright, and helps everyone in understanding the law."
"He is absolutely brilliant and is a very effective litigator for clients who don't have many options. He is very pragmatic, measured and reasonable - he appeals to common sense, which makes him an effective negotiator."
"William Ford is truly extraordinary - he helps everyone and knows the law better than anyone."
"Will Ford is a test case lawyer whose practice spans Social Housing and Welfare issues, his breadth of knowledge in both fields in invaluable to those working in his team."
"Osbornes’ team have grown in size and stature under the excellent leadership of Will Ford."
"Will Ford stands out as an exceptional and highly regarded lawyer in the field."
"The lawyer that was helping me with my case was William Ford was simply amazing – if a partner shows all these qualities, this must, I’m sure, filter down to the rest of the employees due to the example set."
"Will Ford recently took over a case from a departing colleague and was immediately on top of all the issues in a fact-heavy case; he is always available to speak to and in a case against a hard-to-manage litigant in person he was excellent."
"He is excellent - meticulous attention to detail and very knowledgeable."
Practice head William Ford takes on public law challenges involving housing rights, community care, welfare benefits and support for migrants, among other areas. His work in the field of housing law often involves challenging local authorities' refusals to honour statutory obligations.
William Ford is a very well-known and well-respected solicitor who has acted in some of the most important recent public law cases involving housing and welfare issues. He is extremely intelligent, always on top of the latest legal developments, and very committed to his clients.
Will Ford – one of a handful of specialists in social security law. Outstanding experience & knowledge of complex statutory schemes.
Will is an astute litigator, and his breadth of knowledge across the fields of housing and social welfare law allows him to take a holistic approach to clients’ situations.
Will Ford is a leading figure in the social housing field. He is highly committed to his clients and leaves no stone unturned in seeking to assist them with their problems.
Will Ford – very experienced, highly professional and with a wide and deep knowledge of social housing litigation and related social welfare areas of law.
Will Ford is a very well-regarded figure in the housing law world and leads a team of high quality and committed lawyers.
"William Ford has an impressive track record handling a variety of possession, homelessness and unlawful eviction matters. He is also adept at community care cases where these issues intersect with housing law. Sources praise him for being 'completely on top of the law and a very good negotiator who gets the most for his clients.'"
“William acts on possession, disrepair and homelessness cases, and has particular expertise in the protection of tenancy deposits under the Housing Act 2004.”
“William Ford is impressive and devoted to the sector.”
“Associate William Ford receives effusive praise for his dedication and commitment to social housing. Interviewees highlight his technical understanding and background in housing law, and describe him as highly impressive.”
“The ‘very thorough’ and ‘incredibly committed’ William Ford is a respected practitioner acting predominantly for tenants facing possession and eviction proceedings, homeless applicants or clients who are making disrepair claims. He understands the links between different parts of the law and housing – how your immigration status might link to housing, for example, or how care provisions might link to housing.”
“William Ford is a ‘tenacious litigator with a lovely manner that, combined with intelligence, knowledge and pragmatism, makes him a pleasure to work with."
“He is brilliant – he’s really intelligent and has great strategic capabilities.”
"The team at Osbornes is inspired by its leader Will Ford, a truly first-rate, modern lawyer’s lawyer. The team have blossomed under his Will and are now packed with conscientious, dedicated and excellent lawyers who always give their clients 100%."
"William Ford - A good technical lawyer with a strong commitment to his clients"
“Osbornes has an impressive social housing team and the quality of their work that I have seen is very high. Will Ford is a very well-regarded figure in the housing law world and leads a team of high quality and committed lawyers. The existence of family and property law teams at the firm, amongst others, means that they are able to offer a holistic and expert approach to their clients.”
William Ford is "highly committed to his clients and leaves no stone unturned in seeking to assist them with their problems"
William Ford "is an astute litigator, and his breadth of knowledge allows him to take a holistic approach to clients’ situations."
"He is one of the most passionate lawyers I've ever worked with. He's a rare commodity."
"William Ford frequently represents tenants in possession proceedings, homelessness appeals and disrepair claims... and is praised for his dynamic and hard-working approach."
"The absolutely brilliant William Ford."
William Ford receives effusive praise for his dedication and commitment to social housing. Interviewees highlight his technical understanding and background in housing law, and describe him as highly impressive."
'First-class lawyer' William Ford is 'completely dedicated to making a positive difference', and is acting in cases challenging the 'bedroom tax'.
William acts on possession, disrepair and homelessness cases, and has particular expertise in the protection of tenancy deposits under the Housing Act 2004
William Ford is impressive and devoted to the sector.
Related Insights VIEW ALL
11.6.2026Challenging Thurrock Council’s Relocation Decision
Multiple challenges to Thurrock Council’s decision to send a family 280 miles away through Reloc8 We brought several urgent cases...
Read more
4.6.2026Winning Judicial Review Against Home Office Housing Decision
Judicial review success against Home Office reneging on decision to accommodate activist safely This case involved an urgent application for...
Read more
23.4.2026Unlawful Eviction and Tenant Re-Entry Success Case
Wrongful eviction from HMO: Court orders re-entry for tenant This case involved an application for re-entry after an eviction had...
Read more- 15.9.2025
Council Unlawfully Assesses Disabled Child’s Housing Needs
Local Authority fails to lawfully assess the housing needs of a single mother and her disabled child This case involved...
Read more - 6.8.2025
High Court Rules in Favour of Former Relevant...
‘Significant Unfairness’ and ‘Unlawfulness’: High Court Takes Exceptional Step of Directing Local Authority to Exercise Discretion to Treat Claimant as...
Read more - 17.7.2025
Trapped No More: High Court Orders Tower Hamlets...
The High Court has ordered Tower Hamlets to provide suitable accommodation to a homeless disabled woman whom it had left...
Read more 
30.5.2025Asylum-Seeking Child Wins Age Dispute Court Case Against...
Vulnerable unaccompanied asylum-seeking child vindicated in relation to his age following four day hearing in damming judgment against Local Authority...
Read more- 30.4.2025
Torbay Council Fined £8,400 for Failing Child’s Needs
Torbay Council ordered to pay £8,400 for year-long neglect of child’s needs The Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman has...
Read more - 24.4.2025
Age Re-Assessment Ordered by High Court
‘Illogical’ and ‘unlawful’: High Court rules in favour of unaccompanied asylum-seeker against Local Authority On 16 April 2025, His Honour Judge Dight...
Read more - 2.4.2025
Significant Damages Secured in Disrepair Case
Significant Damages for Disrepair secured following breach of Court Order Our client approached Osbornes Law having previously brought a disrepair...
Read more - 30.1.2025
Osbornes Wins Judicial Review on Legal Aid Fees
Osbornes successful in judicial review of Lord Chancellor over legal aid fees for Welfare Benefits On 28 January 2025 the High Court...
Read more - 13.1.2025
Osbornes Law Secures Mental Health Support for Asylum...
Home office backs down over decision to deny mental health support to suicidal torture victim seeking asylum The Home Office...
Read more - 7.10.2024
Disabled Woman Wins £34,000 Benefits Case
The Background to the Case In 2019 Ramona Cerbu was crossing the road when she was hit by a car and...
Read more - 5.4.2024
DWP Exposed for £32,000 Underpayment of Disability Benefits
Osbornes Law has assisted a vulnerable client to recover underpaid disability benefits totalling over £32,000. Our client, a disabled young man,...
Read more - 28.9.2023
Gatekept homeless teenager accommodated by local housing authority
Miss X, a 17 year old whose details are anonymised to protect her privacy, left her family home in March 2022 following...
Read more - 28.9.2023
Homelessness case successfully settled for elderly disabled lady
Ms X, whose details are anonymised to protect her privacy, had been living in a privately rented one-bedroom flat for...
Read more - 28.9.2023
Disrepair Claim for Single Father
Summary: A single father faced ongoing housing disrepair issues, including leaks and malfunctioning heating, affecting his and his son's living...
Read more - 28.9.2023
Client successfully rehoused following refusal by local authority
Background to the case Osbornes Law represented a client who had been found intentionally homeless by his local authority. He...
Read more - 28.9.2023
Client rehoused and £16,000 arrears cleared
Osbornes Law were instructed to assist a client to suspend a warrant for possession. The client had fallen into arrears...
Read more - 26.9.2023
Victory for Homeless Victim
Mr X, whose details are anonymised to protect his privacy, fled his home country due to severe persecution from the...
Read more 
13.9.2023Successful homelessness judicial review case against Redbridge Council
This matter involved a claim in the High Court for judicial review against Redbridge Council for failure to comply with...
Read more
13.7.2023Family Unlawfully Evicted Receives Damages of £22,000
Case Summary: Unlawful Eviction Claim Against Private Landlord This matter involved an unlawful eviction claim brought by our clients against...
Read more- 21.4.2023
Success in Court of Appeal in child disability...
The Court of Appeal has today handed judgment in the case of Harrington v Secretary of State for Work and...
Read more 
14.11.2022Housing allocation case questions lawfulness of council’s...
Until February 2022, the social housing allocation scheme for the London Borough of Newham allowed people who lived outside the borough...
Read more
