Victory for Homeless Victim

26 Sep 2023 | Samuel O’Flaherty

Table of Contents

Mr X, whose details are anonymised to protect his privacy, fled his home country due to severe persecution from the authorities, where he had been imprisoned, tortured and sexually assaulted. He suffered serious Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and depression as a result.

After a long process of claiming asylum in the UK he was finally granted refugee status. This meant he could apply for homelessness assistance from his local council. This took a while for the Council to respond to. They eventually offered him a small studio flat, made up of a small room with an en suite cubicle. The conditions were cramped and there was insufficient space for a table and chairs. The Council told him that if he didn’t accept it they would close his case and no longer help him.

Mr X therefore accepted the offer, but instructed solicitor Sam O’Flaherty to request a statutory review of the suitability of the flat, under the Legal Help Scheme. In the meantime the Council closed Mr X’s homelessness application because they considered him to be suitably housed.

Osbornes obtained reports from a leading psychiatrist who had been assessing Mr X over the years. The reports demonstrated the triggering impact that the cramped conditions were having on Mr X’s PTSD because of his experiences when he had been imprisoned – ‘the small size of his room acted as a distressing reminder of the conditions in which he was detained and tortured’. The medical evidence showed that the particularly small size of the flat was having a major adverse effect on Mr X’s mental health conditions.

Osbornes submitted representations to the Council setting out why the offer was unsuitable and unlawful. The Council initially replied with a decision that they were still minded to treat the offer as suitable, relying on evidence from their own medical adviser.

Osbornes sent further representations challenging this decision. Mr O’Flaherty argued that the Council was not entitled to prefer the evidence of its medical adviser over the psychiatrist, because the advisor had never met Mr X, he had not been asked to assess the flat and was not as qualified to comment on mental health issues as Mr X’s psychiatrist. The Council had also unlawfully breached discrimination and equality laws in how it had treated Mr X’s disability arising from his mental health conditions.

As a result, Mr X won the statutory review. The Council accepted that the offer had been unsuitable due to its size. They reopened his homelessness application and accepted that they owed him the ‘main housing duty’. The Council have agreed to offer Mr X alternative suitable accommodation.

Share this article


Contact Sam O'Flaherty today

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    • "Sam, Brilliant solicitor!

      I am so grateful to have Mr Sam O'flaherty as my lawyer. He talked on my behalf for my housing case, the outcome was great. He is very professional and brilliant solicitor!"

      Client review

    • “His service is impeccable. He is extremely thorough in his investigations … I would highly recommend his services and that of the Osborne Law in general to anyone who needs legal representation to address such matters.”

      Audrey Litchmore, Outreach Worker at NOPA

    • “Our teams feels that Sam’s passion to affect social justice for his clients and society as a whole is at the forefront of his work”

      Donna Sinclair, CEO of Options4Change

    • "He is among the best junior solicitors I have ever worked with over many years of practice”

      Tim Baldwin, Garden Court Chambers

    • “I have been extremely impressed not only by his legal and intellectual ability but also his clear commitment to the cause not only of individual claimants and defendant tenants but the wider implication for other persons affected by unlawful acts of public bodies. Sam is truly a rising star in the world of homelessness, social housing and community care”

      Tim Baldwin, Garden Court Chambers

    • “Sam assured me and was respectful, thoughtful and had a lot of patience with my disabilities and injurys supporting me beyond his title as lawyer he help me with advice on how to keep my paper work organised and also explain everything in a language I was able to understand he understood my mental health and traumas and at all times been caring to words my pain I am truly grateful for his works and I highly recommend his services”

      Client Review

    • My case was handled by Sam O'Flaherty. He was professional throughout, I was regularly kept up to date, he was friendly, competent and positive in what was a difficult and tricky case culminating in an excellently successful result. Thank you very much you are highly recommended.

      Client review

    • Samuel O'Flaherty has managed 3 different claims regarding housing (possession/eviction order) and benefits entitlement to date. His service is impeccable. He is extremely thorough in his investigations and has achieved two successful outcomes for the client so far. I have complete faith that success with the third outcome will be achieved through his diligence and commitment to providing a top quality service. I would highly recommend his services and that of the Osborne Law in general to anyone who needs legal representation to address such matters.

      Audrey Litchmore Outreach Worker, NOPA

    • “I am very happy with the service I was provided by Sam, he is very good at his job. Really impressed with the service.”

      Client review

    • “Best lawyer, Thank you for your wonderful work Sam O’Flaherty.”

      Client review

    • “Osbornes represented me in a housing matter against a local authority for over 3 years. They provided an excellent service and a better result than expected. I’m especially grateful to have had the help of their solicitor Sam O’Flaherty who pursued my case relentlessly and was always very approachable and clear in his explanations of what is going on at each stage. I really recommend them.”

      Client review

    • "Sam will keep fighting for his clients after many others would have thrown the towel in, and is exceptionally creative in finding a route to success."

      Ed Fitzpatrick, barrister at Garden Court Chambers

    • I received an excellent service with Osbornes law, and more specifically Samuel O'Flaherty. Samuel's communication with me was awesome he was efficient and supportive in decisions making Samuel help me and my son to secure a home even when I almost lost hope, l will would highly recommend Osbornes law especially Samuel. am very pleased with the service I received. Thank you Samuel.

      Tina T

    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. housing discussions

      Supreme Court sets High Threshold for Local Authorities...

      Judgment was handed down on 28 November 2023 by the Supreme Court in an important case regarding the main housing duty. The...

      Read more
    2. 28.9.2023

      Gatekept homeless teenager accommodated by local housing authority

      Miss X, a 17 year old whose details are anonymised to protect her privacy, left her family home in March 2022 following...

      Read more
    3. 28.9.2023

      Homelessness case successfully settled for elderly disabled lady

      Ms X, whose details are anonymised to protect her privacy, had been living in a privately rented one-bedroom flat for...

      Read more
    4. 28.9.2023

      Client successfully rehoused following refusal by local authority

      Osbornes Law represented a client who had been found intentionally homeless by his local authority. He was extremely vulnerable and...

      Read more
    5. 28.9.2023

      Client rehoused and £16,000 arrears cleared

      Osbornes Law were instructed to assist a client to suspend a warrant for possession. The client had fallen into arrears...

      Read more
    6. 26.9.2023

      Victory for Homeless Victim

      Mr X, whose details are anonymised to protect his privacy, fled his home country due to severe persecution from the...

      Read more
    7. 13.9.2023

      Successful homelessness judicial review case against Redbridge Council

      This matter involved a claim in the High Court for judicial review against Redbridge Council for failure to comply with...

      Read more
    8. 13.7.2023

      Family Unlawfully Evicted Receives Damages of £22,000

      This matter involved an unlawful eviction claim brought by our clients against their private landlord (“the Landlord”). Our clients were...

      Read more
    9. Churchill Gardens neighborhood in Pimlico

      High Court finds Westminster Council’s Housing Scheme...

      Westminster City Council’s housing allocation scheme found to be unlawful The High Court has today handed down judgment finding...

      Read more
    10. Business people hands applauding at meeting

      20 Years of Celebrating Legal Aid Lawyers

      This year the litigation team at Osbornes attended the 20th anniversary of the Legal Aid Lawyer of the Year 2022 (“LALY 2022”)...

      Read more
    11. Homeless Teenager

      Council overturns unlawful housing policy

      Homeless teenager claims victory for more than 1,200 homeless people after forcing council to overturn unlawful housing policy A homeless teenager...

      Read more
    12. shoreditch london

      Homeless Teenager takes London Council to High Court

      A homeless teenager is taking a London council to the High Court for ‘unlawfully’ banning hundreds of homeless people from...

      Read more
    13. 22.10.2019

      Lambeth Council failed homeless applicant

      The Court of Appeal has quashed a council decision that said a young man with mental health problems and at...

      Read more
    14. 13.8.2019

      Osbornes bring High Court challenge to secure accommodation

      Edward Taylor has challenged Westminster City Council at the High Court after the local authority failed to meet its absolute...

      Read more
    15. 25.3.2019

      Homelessness- The suitability of bed and breakfast accommodation

      There is tremendous pressure on local authorities to house individuals and families for many reasons including unaffordable private rents and...

      Read more
    16. 25.3.2019

      Where will the homeless go?

      In news this week it has been confirmed that London Councils are preparing to send thousands of families into temporary...

      Read more