Supreme Court sets High Threshold for Local Authorities to Avoid Mandatory Order to Comply with Main Housing Duty

Contact
Table of Contents
Judgment was handed down on 28 November 2023 by the Supreme Court in an important case regarding the main housing duty. The decision provides helpful guidance on the factors the courts will take into account when deciding whether to order a local authority to provide suitable accommodation to those owed the main housing duty.
The main housing duty is a duty that is owed to people who make a homeless application and are found to be eligible for assistance, homeless, in priority need and not intentionally homeless. Under the main housing duty, local housing authorities must ensure that suitable accommodation is provided. This accommodation could be social or ‘council’ housing or, if it meets certain criteria, accommodation in the private rented sector. If the accommodation is in the private rented sector, then it must be long-term accommodation – a tenancy of at least one year.
A local housing authority can also provide applicants with temporary accommodation whilst it looks for more long-term accommodation. In the recent case of Imam, R (on the application of) v London Borough of Croydon (2023) UKSC 45, the Supreme Court considered the conditions that a court should take into account when deciding whether to make a mandatory order to make the local authority to provide suitable accommodation under the main housing duty. A mandatory order is an order from the court that requires a certain action to be performed.
The Supreme Court upheld the findings of the Court of Appeal, that where the main housing duty is owed there is “an immediate, non-deferrable, unqualified duty to secure that suitable accommodation is available.” (Please see our previous post on the 4 May 2022 Court of Appeal case of (R) Elkundi v Birmingham City Council and (R) Imam v London Borough of Croydon [2022] EWCA Civ 601 for further details of a local authority’s duty to provide suitable accommodation to individuals owed a main housing duty.)
In Ms Imam’s case she was owed the main housing duty by the London Borough of Croydon. She had been moved to a property that Croydon accepted was unsuitable following a suitability review. Ms Iman was not moved to a suitable property after this decision however and in 2021, more than five years after Croydon decided her property was unsuitable, she challenged this decision in the Courts.
Croydon defended the claim in the Administrative Court, stating that it had no suitable housing available, that it faced severe budgetary pressures, and that it would therefore be unfair to make a mandatory order. Croydon were successful in the High Court. Ms Imam then appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal found that simply citing a lack of resources was not reason enough to avoid granting a mandatory order, and that a local authority would need to provide detailed evidence of their budgetary limitations to succeed. Croydon appealed this decision to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court dismissed Croydon’s appeal. The Supreme Court confirmed that there is a very high threshold for a local authority to argue that they cannot comply with the main housing duty due to lack of funds. If a local authority seeks to rely on a lack of resources it will need to show that it is virtually impossible to provide suitable housing and will need to provide detailed evidence to back this up.
The decision also sets out five factors that a court may take into account when deciding whether to make a mandatory order requiring a local authority to provide suitable accommodation. They are as follows:
- Whether a local authority has considered using its general contingency fund to find suitable accommodation for the Claimant and if not, why not.
- Whether the local authority has received sufficient notice of the problem in relation to non-performance of its duty. If a local authority has not taken action for an extended period of time, then it will be likely that a court will make a mandatory order.
- The impact on the Claimant. The more serious the negative impact of the local authority failing to provide suitable accommodation, the more likely it is the court will make a mandatory order.
- The steps the local authority are taking to resolve the situation. If there is no indication the local authority are taking action then the court will be more likely to make a mandatory order.
- The need to ensure that a situation is not created that is unfair to others.
The judgment helpfully clarifies that local authorities cannot simply refuse to provide suitable accommodation to individuals owed the main housing duty by citing a lack of resources, and that very detailed evidence would need to be provided if a local authority were to cite this as a reason for a court not to make a mandatory order. The judgment also provides useful guidance to potential claimants who may wish to seek a mandatory order against a local authority.
Share this article
“Osbornes has a particular strength in handling social housing challenges with a focus on homelessness and assisting children with disabilities.”
“The lawyers at Osbornes Law work with passion, putting in all their best.”
Contact Tom today
Call us 020 7485 8811
Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you
Excellent work as usual Team Osbornes Law. Our service users have experienced some of the exceptional outcomes yourselves have achieved as outcomes for their housing and social issues.
Keep up the excellent work.
Osbornes Law represents tenants in the full variety of housing law matters,
Osbornes Law are a very highly regarded firm who are at the coalface. They are very on top of their cases.
The Osbornes team is capable and responsive.
William Ford is the best housing and public law solicitor of his generation.
Osbornes are a fantastic team who really stand out in the market in the fields of housing and social care.
Their mix of private client work and legal aid means that legally aided clients are (unusually) able to access a professional and top-flight law firm and get treated with real respect
The social housing team at Osbornes is exceptional. The solicitors are highly competent, professional, and committed.
A large, experienced, and capable team with in-depth knowledge covering the entirety of housing and homelessness law
The group has developed expertise in several specialist areas, such as advising EU nationals on their legal status and bringing challenges in asylum age assessment cases.
The team has demonstrable experience in advising clients on issues involving vulnerable clients who have claims against local authorities and housing associations.
"The team explains things clearly, is very responsive and goes the extra step to help those who need it."
"I was impressed and grateful from the very beginning - the team are extremely detailed, very thorough, helpful and reassuring at the same time. I would absolutely recommend Osbornes Law."
"Osbornes Law is efficient and focused, and clearly prioritises the client's interests."
‘Osbornes are very approachable; in a time where many firms are unwilling to take on cases that do not look promising, they are prepared to look at difficult situations and find a way to assist their clients.
"Osbornes is one of the firms that I consistently recommend. Excellent service, and thorough and knowledgable lawyers."
‘From the very first moment, I was aware and grateful to have been put in touch with Osbornes. The expertise, advice, leaving no stone unturned right from the first minute until the very last, I would most certainly recommend every single time.’
"The associates have a thorough knowledge of the area of law, communicate effectively and are incredibly easy to work with."
"They are a firm that likes a challenge and are prepared to do the groundwork to develop cases, even if it means much preparation without remuneration."
"It is clear the firm put the interests of the client first at all times."
"There’s a real sense of team ethic. It’s clear that internal communication and case recording are strong because if a solicitor handling a case is away the person covering is fully up to speed, has the necessary documents available to them and nothing falls through the cracks."
"If a short deadline comes up on an urgent case, solicitors are active in collaborating to ensure it can be met."
"The practice is ‘undoubtedly one of the best in the business‘ and has a strong reputation for complex disrepair cases and possession claims against local authorities and housing associations."
"The people I have worked with have been fantastic; they are truly passionate about the work they do and are exceptionally good at building good relationships."
"This is an outstanding firm with great attention to detail. They work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for their clients. They have excellent client care skills and are extremely organised."
This is a very high-end law firm, which treats its legal aid clients with the same seriousness and respect as its privately paying clients.
Very strong team – incredibly knowledgable with good cross-over knowledge in mental capacity and community care. Thorough, dedicated and very professional. Clients will feel they are getting a gold standard service.
At the top of the social housing tree. Their team provides high quality advice and great client care. They can offer a holistic approach, so where a housing problem also requires community care or other aspects, this can be provided.
Will Ford – very experienced, highly professional and with a wide and deep knowledge of social housing litigation and related social welfare areas of law.
Osbornes has an impressive social housing team and the quality of their work that I have seen is very high.
"Osbornes are an exceptional team. They have a wealth of housing experience and knowledge that is ‘top notch’. Clients are safe in their hands. As colleagues, they have a fantastic working relationship with each other and, feeding off of each other’s expert knowledge, their solicitors work to ensure that no stone is unturned."
"The team at Osbornes is inspired by its leader Will Ford, a truly first-rate, modern lawyer’s lawyer. The team have blossomed under his Will and are now packed with conscientious, dedicated and excellent lawyers who always give their clients 100%."
"Alex McMahon – thorough and committed. Very easy to work with."
"William Ford - A good technical lawyer with a strong commitment to his clients"
"A committed and well-organised team with a good knowledge of the law and who work hard to secure a good outcome for their clients"
"Osbornes has an impressive social housing team and the quality of their work that I have seen is very high. Will Ford is a very well-regarded figure in the housing law world and leads a team of high quality and committed lawyers."
"Osbornes provide an incredibly high-quality service to their clients. The firm treats its legal aid clients with the same respect and commitment as if they were important private clients, which is rare and admirable. Their housing solicitors are also highly skilled and knowledgable."
"He goes the extra mile for his clients."
"He is an excellent lawyer with exceptional attention to detail. He leaves no stone unturned in finding the right solution for his clients."
"This is an outstanding firm with great attention to detail. They work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for their clients. They have excellent client care skills and are extremely organised."
“Osbornes has an impressive social housing team and the quality of their work that I have seen is very high. Will Ford is a very well-regarded figure in the housing law world and leads a team of high quality and committed lawyers. The existence of family and property law teams at the firm, amongst others, means that they are able to offer a holistic and expert approach to their clients.”
William Ford is "highly committed to his clients and leaves no stone unturned in seeking to assist them with their problems"
William Ford "is an astute litigator, and his breadth of knowledge allows him to take a holistic approach to clients’ situations."
"They are at the forefront of legal developments in the field of social housing and community care. They are committed to using their multidisciplinary expertise to achieve the best possible outcomes for clients."
"This a great team - the quality of their work is amazing and they are very professional"
"An exceptional outfit. They take on difficult cases, fight hard and win."
"William Ford frequently represents tenants in possession proceedings, homelessness appeals and disrepair claims... and is praised for his dynamic and hard-working approach."
"Osbornes team is noted for cross-practice expertise in areas such as housing and community care, which it brings to bear in disrepair, possession and homelessness cases involving vulnerable adults, individuals with language difficulties, the elderly and those with no recourse to public funds."
"The absolutely brilliant William Ford."
I was very happy with the excellent service from Osbornes in my disrepair case. They obtained a great result in my case and always pushed hard for my rights.
The social housing team is friendly, approachable and genuinely care about its clients.
A broad knowledge places the social housing department one step ahead of others when it comes to community care knowledge.
The social housing department always go the extra mile.
The social housing team has a strong track record in representing tenants in claims against local authorities and housing associations, with particular expertise in complex disrepair and possession cases.
The social housing department provides an excellent service and is able to react quickly in critical situations.
Thanks for all your support during this very difficult time for my family.
William Ford receives effusive praise for his dedication and commitment to social housing. Interviewees highlight his technical understanding and background in housing law, and describe him as highly impressive."
The team understand vulnerable clients and young people, and on the front line they are prompt and efficient.
Edward Taylor undertook my case from an almost unwinnable position. From our first meeting, Edward's enthusiasm was apparent. He was determined, diligent and most professional when dealing with my case, keeping me informed at every stage. I wholeheartedly thank Edward for his endeavours and would not hesitate in recommending him and Osbornes Solicitors to others.
Osbornes Solicitors give us the confidence and strength to continue and input the belief that the case would turn in our favour … What was most important was the transparency in communication that Osbornes provided.
Osbornes Solicitors are the pinnacle of professionalism and have gone beyond to assist with this case … I felt that I wasn't only dealing with just one dedicated solicitor but I had a good knowledgeable team behind me at all times.
I have been extremely impressed with the level of patience and guidance provided in the case … I would like to thank you for your sympathetic approach and understanding towards my mother’s case and I would strongly recommend Osbornes Solicitors to anybody.
'First-class lawyer' William Ford is 'completely dedicated to making a positive difference', and is acting in cases challenging the 'bedroom tax'.
Osbornes is commended for its 'rare level of commitment'.
William acts on possession, disrepair and homelessness cases, and has particular expertise in the protection of tenancy deposits under the Housing Act 2004
More Housing InsightsVIEW ALL
- 2.9.2024
Transferring a Council House Tenancy to a Family...
Tenancy Succession Rules The loss of a loved one is always a difficult time. It is important that time is...
Read more - 30.7.2024
Single Mother Wins in High Court Homelessness Challenge
Claim for judicial review against Redbridge Council This case involved a claim in the High Court for judicial review against...
Read more - 15.7.2024
How To Deal With Rent Arrears
What can I do if I am struggling to pay off rent arrears? There are many reasons why one might...
Read more - 16.4.2024
When can you challenge public body decisions about...
An introduction to public law Public law governs the relationship between public bodies, such as central government or local government,...
Read more - 16.4.2024
Short-Form Assessments of Unaccompanied Asylum-Seeking Children
Age is just a number? Shining a light on Local Authorities’ Short-Form Assessments of Unaccompanied Asylum-Seeking Children A recent report...
Read more - 23.1.2024
Case Reiterates Local Authorities should follow Allocation Scheme
R (on the application of Kukhtyak) -v- London Borough of Hounslow [2023] EWHC 2914 (Admin) This sad case concerned an elderly couple...
Read more - 16.5.2022
Immediate, Non-Deferrable and Unqualified
Judgment was handed down on 04 May 2022 in the Court of Appeal in an important case regarding the main housing duty....
Read more - 5.11.2021
Council overturns unlawful housing policy
Homeless teenager claims victory for more than 1,200 homeless people after forcing council to overturn unlawful housing policy A homeless teenager...
Read more - 3.9.2021
Homeless Teenager takes London Council to High Court
A homeless teenager is taking a London council to the High Court for ‘unlawfully’ banning hundreds of homeless people from...
Read more - 19.8.2021
Housing Disrepair Mitcham, South London
Awful housing conditions Following an investigation by ITV nearly 500 homes in the Eastfields Estate in Mitcham, south London, owned by...
Read more - 8.4.2021
Council to amend unlawful housing allocation banding process
For the last 8 years Brent Council has stopped the majority of homeless applicants from bidding for rehousing, treating them as ‘...
Read more - 25.1.2021
Hackney Council ignore vulnerable resident’s request
Paranoid schizophrenic ignored by Hackney Council for four years wins legal battle over unsafe front door A man who suffers...
Read more - 25.1.2021
Teenage asylum seeker wins legal battle against Council...
Vulnerable teenage asylum seeker wins age case against the council which unlawfully assessed him A vulnerable teenager who sought asylum...
Read more - 23.12.2020
EU Nationals with Pre-Settled Status entitled to benefits...
Court Judgment means EU Nationals with Pre-Settled Status can access benefits and housing On 18 December 2020 the Court of Appeal handed...
Read more - 2.12.2020
Education provision to age disputed migrants
The thorny issue of education provision to age disputed migrants There was an interesting article in The Guardian last week...
Read more - 20.11.2020
You are homeless because you are in shared...
It is well established that shared facilities are not suitable for families with children as long term accommodation. The client...
Read more - 13.8.2020
Judicial review – friend or foe?
The Government announced on 31st July 2020 that an independent panel has been asked to look at judicial review to consider...
Read more - 24.7.2020
Rejecting tenants on housing benefit deemed indirect discrimination
In a recent decision in the County Court at York it was held that a letting agent’s policy of...
Read more - 27.5.2020
I am vulnerable and homeless but the Council...
Homelessness law and procedure can be very complicated. We hope this blog gives you some helpful pointers but it is...
Read more - 5.5.2020
I have lost my job and I have...
The impact of the current pandemic is being felt by many, but the prospect of losing your job or not...
Read more - 4.5.2020
I am renting from a private landlord and...
The ONS reported in 2019 that between 2007 and 2017 the number of households in the private rented sector in the UK increased...
Read more - 28.4.2020
When does a Local Authority have to provide...
Absolutely anyone can be struck down by misfortune and find themselves in a situation where they are homeless. Though many...
Read more - 30.3.2020
I have a disrepair issue can I withhold...
Withholding rent is not your best course of action I see the logic in using the non-payment of rent as...
Read more - 21.2.2020
Fitness for Human Habitation Act 2018
Understanding the Fitness for Human Habitation Act 2018: Your Rights as a Tenant “Home is a safe haven and a comfort...
Read more