Death of cyclist in road traffic accident opens up helmet debate once again

13 Aug 2019 | Stuart Kightley
olympic park stratford london

After the death of a cyclist outside the Olympic park, Stuart Kightley, personal injury solicitor at Osbornes re-visits the question of whether cycling helmets should be mandatory.

The buzz and fanfare of the London 2012 was temporarily halted last Wednesday (1st August) after a cyclist was tragically killed just outside the Olympic Park. The 28-year-old man was knocked down by a double-decker bus and was pronounced dead at the scene.

Following the accident, perhaps fuelled by comments from our new Olympic champ Bradley Wiggins, the debate on whether cycle helmets should become a legal requirement for all cyclists was re-ignited. To be clear Wiggins later clarified his comments on twitter confirming that he hadn’t called for helmets to be made the law, he was merely suggesting that it may be the way forward to give cyclists more protection legally if involved in an accident.

That being said the pros and cons of wearing a helmet and indeed the safety of cycling inner city have been placed firmly back into the spotlight.

Back in 2008 I wrote a similar article on cycling in London and cited that the benefits of cycling included the fact that cyclists travelling short distances reduce their risk of death (largely due to lower risk of heart disease) by 22%. The health benefits were said to exceed the risks by a factor of 20. Fast forward four years and these health benefits still stand. It is estimated that cyclists can burn around 600 calories an hour and indeed you can cycle up to 1037km on the energy equivalent of a single litre of petrol! So cycling is still the healthy option and saves the environment – however what are the risks involved?

During the period June to September 2011 970 cyclists were killed or seriously injured in a road traffic accident, this is compared to 905 the year before. Overall it is calculated that 17,000 cyclist are killed or injured in reported road traffic accidents each year. By February 2012 10 cyclists had been killed whilst riding in London alone.

So it is obvious that there are risks involved in cycling, however, one should consider that in the third quarter of 2011 there were 52,499 victims of all types of road traffic accidents. The reality is that every time a person walks down the street they are putting themselves at risk of coming in contact with a bad driver especially of larger vehicles or those mounting the kerb (January 2012 saw the tragic case of 16-year-old Cassie McCord who was killed after an 87-year-old driver mounted the kerb and collided with her).

In this context choosing to cycle is no more risky that choosing to walk, drive or take public transport. However just as a person (i) would choose not to walk in the middle of the road, (ii) should always wear a seat belt when in a car and (iii) is always advised to mind the gap when boarding a tube – is it reasonable to insist that cyclists wear a helmet when cycling to negate risks of serious injury in the event of an accident?

There is a body of opinion that claims a helmet has no proven safety benefits and that if made compulsory it would actually deter people from cycling. Whilst it is true that the scientific evidence is not overwhelming for or against the wearing of a helmet it does seem to conclude that the risk of brain and serious head injury is significantly reduced by their use. The British Medical Association is one body which is now in favour of legislation to make cycle helmets mandatory.

Chris Peck who is the policy coordinator for the UK’s national cycling organisation ‘CTC’ commented that making helmets compulsory would be counterproductive. “Making cycle helmets compulsory would be likely to have an overall damaging effect on the public health, since the health benefits of cycling massively outweigh the risks and we know that where enforced, helmet laws tend to lead to an immediate reduction in cycling”.

One point in favour of wearing a helmet is however that if one is unlucky enough to suffer a head injury following an accident on a bicycle the other party’s lawyers will almost always try and claim a 25% deduction in compensation for ‘contributory negligence’, if you were not wearing a helmet.

So it seems that the jury is still very much out on whether cycling helmets should be a legal requirement. Perhaps it will be the comments of our mayor Boris Johnson that most will agree with when he said that “cyclists should be able to wear a helmet if they want”… as he arrived for a ministerial Olympic meeting at the Cabinet office – wearing a bike helmet.

Share this article

Contact

For expert advice or to start your claim, please call our specialist cycling accident solicitors today.

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    Cycling News & InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. highway code bike lights
      5.5.2022

      Top 10 Major Highway Code Changes for Cyclists

      New Highway Code rules for cyclists At the end of January 2022, the Highway Code was updated to make British roads...

      Read more
    2. 20.1.2022

      What to do immediately after a cycling accident?

      If you have been involved in a cycling accident, you may experience shock and disorientation at the scene. Depending on...

      Read more
    3. 16.9.2021

      The law around E-bikes and E-scooters explained

      Why are electric bikes legal but not scooters? E-bikes and e-scooters are the new rides on the block. To many,...

      Read more
    4. 31.12.2020

      Bike Boxes – what are the rules?

      Cycle boxes at traffic lights I read a post recently on a London cycling forum in relation to some confusion...

      Read more
    5. highway code road signs
      2.11.2020

      Highway Code changes just the start in protecting...

      The 2020 changes to the Highway Code do not go far enough to change driver behaviour and protect cyclists and pedestrians,...

      Read more
    6. 9.6.2020

      The importance of parks for cycling

      I ventured outside the comfort of my home this past weekend for the first time in 11 weeks. As I walked...

      Read more
    7. bike rider at night
      11.5.2020

      Bike Cam Prosecutions

      Have you ever been cut up by a van turning left? Or been riding along only to find the tarmac...

      Read more
    8. 11.5.2020

      Helmet Cameras: Personal Safety and the Law

      Helmet cameras have become one of the must-have items for cyclists, especially those commuting to and from work.  They offer...

      Read more
    9. Laura swaine indoor cycling
      7.5.2020

      Around the World In One Day for NHS...

      On Thursday 30th April 2020 I took part in a 240 mile cycle, raising money for the NHS.  This ride was to...

      Read more
    10. cycling across a bridge in London
      7.5.2020

      Boom time for bikes – London Mayor’s new...

      Yesterday Sadiq Khan unveiled his ‘London Streetspace’ programme designed to transform London’s streets to accommodate a possible ten-fold increase...

      Read more
    11. 5.5.2020

      Highway code refresher for cyclists

      As we start week 7 of lockdown, there is one thing that is more noticeable on the roads…cyclists. Whether you...

      Read more
    12. 27.4.2020

      How can liability insurance offer peace of mind...

      Stuart Kightley, managing partner writes in the Spring ‘20 issue of the London Cycling Campaign (LCC) magazine and explores the question...

      Read more
    13. cycling across a bridge in London
      9.4.2020

      Staying safe whilst cycling during the COVID-19

      We are all having to change our lifestyles as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and its effects on society....

      Read more
    14. 12.12.2019

      Cycling injuries – some Frequently Asked Questions

      I thought I would reflect on some of the questions I am frequently asked by my cycling clients and take...

      Read more
    15. potholes in the road
      3.12.2019

      Cycling Accidents involving potholes

      If a cyclist is injured as a result of a pothole or defect on the road they were travelling on...

      Read more
    16. santander cycles in london
      26.11.2019

      Do I need insurance for cycling?

      There is no legal requirement for cyclists to hold insurance cover in order to cycle in the UK. That includes...

      Read more
    17. cyclist in London
      22.11.2019

      Tips for a cycle commuter

      Two weeks ago I was cycling home from hockey training along Upper Richmond Road. I was literally 2 minutes from my...

      Read more
    18. olympic park stratford london
      13.8.2019

      Death of cyclist in road traffic accident opens...

      After the death of a cyclist outside the Olympic park, Stuart Kightley, personal injury solicitor at Osbornes re-visits the question...

      Read more
    19. cycling in london
      21.6.2019

      E-Bikes – are they the future for commuting?

      The Government released some clarification last week in relation to the upper limit of the cycle to work scheme. Many...

      Read more
    20. car driver
      31.5.2019

      Intimidatory driving to become breach of traffic law?

      A new driving offence of ‘intimidatory driving’ is being considered by the government to crack down on close passes by...

      Read more
    21. cycling across a bridge in London
      11.5.2019

      Can a ‘bike backie’ get you in trouble?

      London’s controversial mayor Boris Johnson has been caught by The Sun newspaper giving his lawyer wife Marina Wheeler a...

      Read more
    22. bicycle accident
      11.5.2019

      Ealing cyclists up in arms over latest death

      After 51-year-old Met Police officer, Claudia Manera was killed in a bike accident at the junction of The Broadway and...

      Read more
    23. accidente de bicicleta
      25.3.2019

      The risks and rewards of cycling in London

      Stuart Kightley of Osbornes solicitors asks the question: is cycling in London good for your health? I acted for a...

      Read more
    24. roundabout in london
      14.2.2019

      Cyclists, Roundabouts and the Highway Code

      The Highway Code is more than just a guide to how to pass your driving test. It is intended to...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL