Y v Y – Balancing inheritance, family wealth and the needs of individuals

25 Mar 2019 | Lisa Pepper
kyance mews london

The recent case of Y & Y looks at how the Courts have been dealing with inherited assets and confirms that the needs of the parties will outweigh any “right” to ring-fence inherited assets as ‘non-matrimonial’. If the needs of a party justify an invasion of inherited assets in order to meet those needs and provide a fair result, then the Court can and will make an Order that involves the distribution of the inherited assets.

Facts of the case

The parties were married for 26 years and enjoyed an exceptionally high standard of living through the marriage. There were five children of the marriage, some of them were still of school age. The lion’s share of the wealth came from a large country estate that the husband had inherited from his family.

The wife sought a capital lump sum of £11.2m in order to rehouse and set up an investment fund. The husband offered £7m of which £3.5m he suggested to be used to re-house. The husband wanted to retain the estate and Baron J commented that the husband was clearly seeking to reduce Wife’s claim to make it affordable to him.


Baron J looked at the leading cases in this area and in particular at White, Miller and McFarlane and Charman, where the consistent principle was that inherited assets and in particular those that included the matrimonial home, could and should be considered part of the available assets. This was not to necessarily say that they should be split equally, but that the longer the marriage and the way it was treated by the parties would be telling as to the weight that should apply when looking at the division to achieve fairness and met the other parties’ needs.

The Wife was awarded £8.74m, which was 32.5% of the available assets and was described as a ‘fair and justified’ invasion of the inherited assets in this case.

This case provides further clarification as to how the Court deals with inherited assets (and possibly by implication other non-matrimonial assets such as pre-acquired or post-separation assets). The principles of sharing and compensation are less likely to be applied to these types of assets which are to some extent ring-fenced from these aspects of case law but it is clear that needs arguments will override any ringfencing arguments.

Share this article


Insights about Divorce Financial SettlementsVIEW ALL

  1. two people walking

    Does it matter if you’re a breadwinner...

    When it comes to deciding how wealth is split, English courts do not discriminate based on your role within the...

    Read more
  2. couple holding hands

    Are trusts protected from divorce?

    Can trusts protect an inheritance from your spouse? A trust is a separate legal entity. Neither spouse owns its assets. ...

    Read more
  3. cube cafe camden

    Is a limited company protected from divorce?

    Is my spouse entitled to half of my business? If you are involved in running a limited company, then it...

    Read more
  4. man looking out

    How is a pension split in a divorce?

    Pensions and Divorce In a divorce, pensions are taken into account together with all other financial assets. Once all assets...

    Read more
  5. Camden house red door

    Who gets the house in a divorce?

    How is a house divided in a UK divorce? For most people contemplating divorce, one of the main concerns will...

    Read more
  6. 8.12.2022

    The courts approach to costs in financial proceedings...

    WC V HC – a recent costs case in financial proceedings on divorce The recent case of WC v HC [2022] EWFC 40...

    Read more
  7. 6.10.2022

    How to set aside an order in financial...

    My ex-spouse didn’t tell the truth about their finances when we divorced, can anything be done? Can the financial...

    Read more
  8. 30.8.2022

    What are the rules on pension sharing?

    Pensions are one of the biggest assets of a marriage, yet many people are uncertain about whether they are entitled...

    Read more
  9. 6.5.2022

    My ex has cut me off during divorce

    Unfortunately, it is far too common that when a client says it’s over, their spouse with the “purse strings”...

    Read more
  10. 6.5.2022

    How the Court views loans from parents during...

    Getting a loan during a divorce A frequent issue in financial divorce cases is a loan from a spouse’s...

    Read more
  11. mesher order house

    Mesher Orders Explained

    What is a Mesher order? A Mesher Order allows the sale of the family home to be postponed in a...

    Read more
  12. 11.4.2022

    Divorcing couples reaching financial settlement through Private FDR

    The Runaway Advantages of the Private FDR Our specialist lawyers are keen to ensure our divorcing clients achieve cost-effective outcomes...

    Read more
  13. 9.12.2021

    Negotiating financial settlements in divorce

    Costly and acrimonious divorces: a lesson in what not to do  If you’re determined to pursue your financial claims...

    Read more
  14. squirrel hiding assets

    Uncovering hidden assets in your divorce

    Hiding Assets During a Divorce As part of your divorce, you and your ex will have to agree on how...

    Read more
  15. 9.11.2021

    I helped build my spouse’s career

    What is the impact on our divorce settlement? It’s been almost two years since The Da Vinci Code author...

    Read more
  16. 9.11.2021

    6 cases that shape your divorce settlement

    Part of what makes our divorce lawyers experts in their field is knowing what way a judge is likely to...

    Read more
  17. separate paths in the snow

    Does Divorce Revoke A Will?

    Divorce and Wills In the midst of a divorce or separation, it’s rare for couples to think about making...

    Read more
  18. beneficial interest in property review at the court of appeal

    Beneficial Interest in Property

    Andrew Watson, a London-based divorce lawyer in our family department and Resolution accredited cohabitation lawyer, summarises the law in relation...

    Read more
  19. 27.4.2021

    Divorce in your 60s – The Financial Implications

    How common is a divorce in your 60s? The latest divorce figures from the Office of National Statistics (ONS) show...

    Read more
  20. 18.2.2021

    Tax implications for divorcing couples

    As the end of the Stamp Duty holiday looms on 31 March 2021, that is not the only deadline that separating and...

    Read more
  21. london houses

    When can you claim PPR Relief on more...

    Family lawyers are familiar with ‘Mesher Orders‘ where the court orders that as part of the financial settlement on divorce,...

    Read more
  22. father with child

    Setting aside a financial remedy order

    What has been the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on financial remedy orders? Can you do it at all? Barder...

    Read more
  23. family in poppy field

    Divorcees could appeal financial settlements if they lose...

    Billions of pounds have been wiped off shares as uncertainty builds amid the coronavirus crisis, but what does this mean...

    Read more
  24. 23.1.2020

    Financial negotiations on divorce outside court

    A reminder from another court that an honest statement is best There was an interesting case in the Court of...

    Read more