Pre Nuptial Agreements become Enforceable
17 Jun 2010 | Lisa PepperToday 20th October 2010 the highest court in the land had the final say in one of the most eagerly awaited judgements of modern times, finally giving judicial weight to the contractual agreements between potential spouses.
Ironically the judgement is being delivered at exactly the same time as the government delivers its own judgement on the state of the nation’s finances, presumably whittling away much of the wealth that prenuptial agreements are set to protect.
Katrina Radmacher, a German Heiress married Nicolas Grantino a successful financier in 1998. Three months before the wedding, Katrina asked Nicolas to sign a German prenuptial agreement, which prevented either from making a claim against each other. Nicolas did not take independent legal advice and did not see a translated version of the agreement…neither did he have any formal information about Katrina’s wealth at the time.
When Nicolas went to court for the first time in 2008, the Judge (Florence Baron QC) gave some weight to the agreement and awarded Nicolas £5.5 million, about 10% of Katrina’s wealth. This was low for a 9-year marriage where Nicolas was fully involved with the children (and had given up a well-paid job to become a student) but high compared to the Prenuptial agreement. The problems with the agreement itself were manifest and outlined earlier in this article and that is why the judge did not bind Nicolas to the letter of the agreement.
In 2009 Katrina went to the Court of Appeal arguing that the original judge did not give enough weight to the Pre Nuptial Agreement. The Court of Appeal agreed and reduced the award to £1 million as a capitalised needs payment to allowed Nicolas to care for the children.
In many ways both the original High Court judgement and the later Court of Appeal judgement were right. This was an imperfect agreement, but an agreement none the less. So what has the Supreme Court done?
The leading judgment states:-
“The court should give effect to a nuptial agreement that is freely entered into by each party with a full appreciation of its implications unless in the circumstances prevailing it would not be fair to hold the parties to their agreement.”
Pre Nuptial Agreements have historically held little sway over the Courts in the UK, although this position has been changing recently. This most recent judgment suggests that the UK has now fallen into line with most European countries in giving significant weight to such agreements.
The Supreme Court dismissed the difficulties with the original agreement and declared that it would be “Patronising” and “Paternalistic” for the Courts to impose a different settlement on adults who had made their own “Nuptial” agreements.
In a fascinating epitaph to the case, Lady Brenda Hale dissented from the majority of the other judges declaring that in her view both the original trial judge and the Court of Appeal had made the wrong decision and that “ marriage still counts for something in the law of this country and long may it continue to do so”. Lady Hale was the only woman in the panel of 9 judges and the only Family Lawyer and it is telling that the Supreme Court reached their majority view without her.
Our specialist pre-nuptial agreement lawyers at Osbornes Law specialise in family law and can advise on and draft your pre-nuptial agreement. Our lawyers also help already married couples who are seeking a post-nuptial agreement.
To speak with our lawyers call us or fill in an online form and we will contact you.
Share this article
Contact
Contact us today
For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811
Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you
More from LisaVIEW ALL
- 8.12.2022
The courts approach to costs in financial proceedings...
WC V HC – a recent costs case in financial proceedings on divorce The recent case of WC v HC [2022] EWFC 40...
Read more - 7.12.2022
Judge ignores pre-nuptial agreement but factors in non-matrimonial...
Case Law One of the reasons I am still passionate about family law, after 20 years in the field, is that...
Read more - 24.10.2022
Thirty lawyers at Osbornes noted by Legal 500 2023
Osbornes Law has once again been ranked in The Legal 500 2023. The Legal 500 is an independent legal guide which ranks leading...
Read more - 30.8.2022
What are the rules on pension sharing?
Pensions are one of the biggest assets of a marriage, yet many people are uncertain about whether they are entitled...
Read more - 30.8.2022
What is a transfer of equity?
Transfer of equity in divorce Transfer of equity refers to the process of transferring part or all of a property...
Read more - 30.8.2022
5 ways to avoid Court during a divorce
In 2020, there were 103,592 divorces granted in England and Wales (ONS statistics). The Rt Hon Sir Andrew McFarlane, who is President...
Read more - 1.8.2022
Couples struggling to agree divorce settlements amid cost...
The cost of living crisis and uncertainty about future mortgage rates are scuppering divorce negotiations as couples fear reaching financial...
Read more - 30.7.2022
Elon Musk affair rumours highlight the many benefits...
Elon Musk hit the headlines recently, denying rumours that he had an affair with the wife of Google cofounder Sergey...
Read more - 19.5.2022
How to get a divorce
Step-by-step Guide to Getting Divorced In April 2022, new no-fault divorce rules replaced the old fault-based system in England and Wales....
Read more - 6.5.2022
My ex has cut me off during divorce
Unfortunately, it is far too common that when a client says it’s over, their spouse with the “purse strings”...
Read more - 6.5.2022
How the Court views loans from parents during...
A frequent issue in financial divorce cases is a loan from a spouse’s parent, often to pay legal fees,...
Read more - 12.4.2022
Mediation or Arbitration: What’s best for me?
Few divorcing couples want to end up in court, which is why mediation and arbitration are faster and more effective...
Read more - 11.4.2022
Divorcing couples reaching financial settlement through Private FDR
The Runaway Advantages of the Private FDR Our specialist lawyers are keen to ensure our divorcing clients achieve cost-effective outcomes...
Read more - 28.2.2022
Divorce applications shut down from 31 March 2022
From last year all divorce petitions in England and Wales were to be submitted to the court using the court...
Read more - 20.1.2022
Family Mediation: a cost-effective alternative to court action
Mediation is increasingly important for our clients in their efforts to resolve children and financial issues divorce. This week (17 to 21...
Read more - 18.1.2022
6 cases that shape a private children dispute
Family disputes involving children can be particularly emotive, which is why our expert children lawyers work tirelessly to understand how...
Read more - 13.12.2021
Who Pays Child Maintenance?
Child maintenance is regular, reliable financial support that helps towards a child’s everyday living costs. The Child Maintenance Service (...
Read more - 9.12.2021
Are irreconcilable differences grounds for divorce?
If you have come across this article it may have been as a result of an online search to see...
Read more - 9.12.2021
Negotiating financial settlements in divorce
Costly and acrimonious divorces: a lesson in what not to do If you’re determined to pursue your financial claims...
Read more - 25.11.2021
Child arrangements for going abroad when separated
I am separated from my spouse – can I take the children abroad on holiday? The answer to this question is...
Read more - 9.11.2021
Keeping social media out of divorce proceedings
We’ve recently seen the playing out on twitter and Instagram of the high-profile separation of actor Ioan Gruffudd and...
Read more - 9.11.2021
I helped build my spouse’s career
What is the impact on our divorce settlement? It’s been almost two years since The Da Vinci Code author...
Read more - 9.11.2021
How to speed up a divorce
6 steps to speed up the divorce process For many people, once they have made the decision that their marriage is...
Read more - 9.11.2021
6 cases that shape your divorce settlement
Part of what makes our divorce lawyers experts in their field is knowing what way a judge is likely to...
Read more