Handwriting Expert Witness Concludes Will Forgery

20 Oct 2021 | Katie de Swarte
fraud file

Table of Contents

Successful contesting a will claim following testimony of handwriting expert

It’s not unheard of for an individual to forge someone’s will with the aim of securing an inheritance. In a recent case, the combination of contradictory evidence from a key individual involved in the forgery, and expert witness testimony, led to the rightful beneficiary succeeding in her claim in contesting a forged will.

The contentious probate solicitors at Osbornes Law have a successful track record in representing clients with speed and sensitivity at a time when they may still be grieving.

Forged will case study

This was a bitter family dispute following the death of a grandmother. The court had to decide which of two wills, purportedly made a month apart, was genuine. 

The first will was drafted and witnessed in February 2018 by a firm of solicitors and appointed the deceased’s niece, Ann, as an executor. She was close to her aunt and was also named as the sole beneficiary of the whole estate. At the same time, Ann was appointed as the deceased’s attorney under a Lasting Power of Attorney

The second will was purportedly a homemade will drafted by one of the deceased’s sons, Paul, executed in March 2018. This left the estate to three grandchildren. When Ann discovered Paul had obtained Grant of Probate (on 9 January 2019) on the basis of the March ‘will’, she brought proceedings claiming it was a forgery. 

  • For more information on the rise of older and vulnerable people being pressured into changing their will, read our blog post: What is fraudulent calumny?

Evidence that deceased’s signature was forged

The court heard testimony from several witnesses, including expert witnesses concerning the deceased’s signature and a picture on Paul’s iPhone. 

The niece and the defendants had their own handwriting experts, but their evidence was at odds. The niece’s expert, for example, found strong evidence that the deceased had not signed the March will herself. However, the defence expert said there was “moderate” evidence it was genuine. On considering their evidence, the court preferred that of the niece’s expert. On the basis of that and the wider factual background, the court found that, on balance, the March will was a forgery. 

Importantly, a crucial element of Paul’s case was expert evidence relating to a digital photograph which he claimed was of the original executed March will taken on 7 March 2018. The expert was asked to examine it and extract the internal metadata. 

It’s fair to say this backfired somewhat. Although the expert said the metadata showed the photograph was taken at 08.57 on 7 March 2018, he conceded that both the metadata and the GPS time stamp could be modified and manipulated – even by someone who could cheat at computer games. Paul’s own expert could not convince the court that the photo was taken when he claimed. 

The court concluded that the forged will was concocted sometime between 11 December 2018 and before the grant of probate was obtained. This meant the March will would stand, and Ann would inherit her aunt’s estate as intended. 

Defence undermined by handwriting expert

The evidence from Ann’s handwriting expert was a particularly strong reason for the court finding the will to be a forgery. That said, the expert evidence concerning the metadata was insufficient to cast doubt on Ann’s case and seriously undermined Paul’s defence.  

The case illustrates the value of employing appropriate expert witnesses in probate disputes to ensure all bases are covered – one expert witness’s evidence can make or break a case.

How Osbornes Law can help

Katie de Swarte is an associate solicitor who specialises in contested claims. Katie can advise you on whether you can bring such a claim based on the facts of your circumstances and can assist in defending such a claim. Katie is featured in the Legal 500 as a recommended solicitor in London.

Please call 020 7485 8811 or complete an online enquiry form to speak with Katie.

Share this article

Contact

Contact Katie de Swarte today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    • Katie de Swarte and Elspeth Neilson have both instructed me recently, and both seemed to me to be able to build excellent relationships with their clients and to run their practices very efficiently

      Legal 500 2022

    • Katie de Swarte is hardworking and has great empathy for her clients

      Legal 500 2022

    More Insights about Contentious ProbateVIEW ALL

    1. Forged will pic
      22.3.2024

      Forged Wills

      If the contents of a will comes as a surprise, then one of the things to consider is whether the...

      Read more
    2. international map and money
      9.6.2023

      Will Dispute Case Law

      New Births And New Relationships? Review Your Will To Avoid A Dispute You’d imagine a wealthy businessman with assets...

      Read more
    3. older couple
      9.6.2023

      Of Bad Character: Undue Influence Claim Succeeds

      Naidoo v Barton: undue influence and the risks of mutual wills Can someone’s bad character be used to prove...

      Read more
    4. Woman signing document
      25.10.2021

      Inheritance Claims CFA Success Fee Judgment

      The Court of Appeal upholds the recoverability of CFA success fees in 1975 Act claims. An individual who claims reasonable provision...

      Read more
    5. scrap metal
      20.10.2021

      Evidence Needed When Contesting A Will

      ‘Scrap King’ Multi-million Inheritance Dispute Confirms the High Standard of Evidence Needed to Contest a Will   Gary Goodwin, son of...

      Read more
    6. inheritance tax form
      20.10.2021

      Dispute Surrounding Interpretation of Will

      The ‘nil rate band’ offers an incentive to testators to make their will in a tax-efficient manner, maximising the amount...

      Read more
    7. fraud file
      20.10.2021

      Handwriting Expert Witness Concludes Will Forgery

      Successful contesting a will claim following testimony of handwriting expert It’s not unheard of for an individual to forge...

      Read more
    8. couple holding hands
      20.10.2021

      Understanding Testamentary Capacity

      What is testamentary capacity? Testamentary capacity refers to a person’s legal and mental ability to create a valid will....

      Read more
    9. toy houses on coins
      20.10.2021

      Unsuccessful Inheritance Act Claim

      The case of Shearer v Shearer The recent reported case of Shearer v Shearer highlights that adult children cannot expect...

      Read more
    10. two ladies talking
      13.11.2017

      Mutual Wills

      The High Court’s decision in the recent case of Legg and Burton v Burton [2017] has highlighted the issues surrounding...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL