Evidence Needed When Contesting A Will

20 Oct 2021 | Katie de Swarte
scrap metal

Table of Contents

‘Scrap King’ Multi-million Inheritance Dispute Confirms the High Standard of Evidence Needed to Contest a Will  

Gary Goodwin, son of self-made millionaire Tom Goodwin, recently claimed his late father’s £4 million fortune after a legal battle with his sister over his father’s will. 

‘Scrap king’ Tom Goodwin, a scrapyard merchant and farming business owner from Yorkshire, had a turbulent relationship with his three children, Gary, Jacqueline and Gillian. He had fallen out with all of them over the years, resulting in several will changes before Mr Goodwin’s death. The siblings asked the High Court to determine which version should prevail. 

Despite his limited ability to read and write, Mr Goodwin had amassed a significant business and property portfolio worth approximately £4 million. There was a lot at stake for the family – and the case confirms some key principles of law for anyone who is thinking of contesting a will.

Family breakups and reconciliations

Mr Goodwin’s first will in 2000 gave daughter Gillian the lion’s share of his estate. But after they fell out, she did not appear in any of her father’s future wills. 

In 2005, Mr Goodwin made a new will placing ownership of the farming business into a trust for the benefit of his granddaughter Nicola. The rest of the estate was split between his second wife and his 10 grandchildren. Son, Gary – who was out of favour with his father at the time – would inherit only his father’s Rolls Royce.

However, father and son reconciled over the years and Gary gave up his job to work in the farming business. Mr Goodwin wrote a new will in 2017, under which Gary would be put in control of the company and inherit most of Mr Goodwin’s £4 million fortune.

Just a year later, the pair fell out again, upon which Mr Goodwin contacted his solicitors to discuss cutting Gary out of his will. Mr Goodwin died in November 2018 before a new will could be formalised.

Allegations of duress and lack of capacity

In court, Nicola and her mother Jacqueline argued that the 2017 will should be set aside as it was made as a result of undue influence placed by Gary on his father. The pair claimed that Gary “physically dominated Tom, acting in an aggressive and controlling manner towards him in his old age.”

Pointing to Mr Goodwin’s near illiteracy, they also alleged that Tom was not of sound mind when making the 2017 will which left everything to Gary.

However, after much evidence had been heard, these allegations were dropped mid-way through the trial. The judge approved Mr Goodwin’s will of 2017, which made Gary the main beneficiary. 

Giving judgment, the judge said that Mr Goodwin “knew his own mind” and was not pressured into making the 2017 will. In 2017, the scrap merchant was still active on the farm and carrying bales of hay. 

The judge determined that Mr Goodwin was not scared of his son and was not “overawed by or in any way subject to the undue influence of anybody, certainly at the time of his execution of the 2017 will.” 

The judge was also satisfied that Mr Goodwin retained full mental capacity. Witnesses testified that the terms of the will reflected his wishes and had been discussed with him before he executed it.

What does this mean for challenging a will?

This case confirms that there must be a clear legal reason to contest a will on someone’s death, backed up by strong evidence. 

For cases involving mental capacity, the initial presumption is that the person has capacity. While every matter is fact specific, there will generally need to be medical records, or the opinion of a medical expert, to show that the deceased had an impairment in the functioning of the mind. The inability to read and write does not amount to a mental impairment, as the courts are only concerned with the deceased’s ability to make and understand a will.

For a claim of undue influence to succeed, it must be proven that the person making the will acted against their own volition. The burden of evidence is high. The court will need to be satisfied that there is no other reasonable explanation for the testator’s actions other than that coercion was applied. Specifically, there must be evidence that the person acted out of character, doing something very different to the wishes they’ve expressed before. 

That did not happen in the Goodwin case. The judge agreed that Tom Goodwin had a history of “bitter and protracted” fallouts with his family. He also had a tendency to stray from the truth and tell people things they wanted to hear, making promises he did not keep to his children regarding property rights. 

Mr Goodwin’s behaviour was in no way out of character, the judge decided. As such, the judge concluded that there were no reasonable grounds to raise a case regarding undue influence, and the claim should never have been brought.

  • For more information on the rise of older and vulnerable people being pressured into changing their will, read our blog post: What is fraudulent calumny?

How can we help?

Katie de Swarte is an associate solicitor who specialises in contested claims. Katie can advise you on whether you can bring such a claim based on the facts of your circumstances and can assist in defending such a claim. Katie is featured in the Legal 500 as a recommended solicitor in London.

Please call or complete an online enquiry form to speak with Katie.

Share this article


Contact Katie de Swarte today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    • Katie de Swarte and Elspeth Neilson have both instructed me recently, and both seemed to me to be able to build excellent relationships with their clients and to run their practices very efficiently

      Legal 500 2022

    • Katie de Swarte is hardworking and has great empathy for her clients

      Legal 500 2022

    More Insights about Contesting a WillVIEW ALL

    1. waiting

      Can a Lasting Power of Attorney Be Challenged?

      The number of people recognising the importance of making a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) has risen dramatically in recent...

      Read more
    2. 10 tips

      Wills Disputes: The Duty To Account Is Not...

      Beneficiaries frequently ask us whether trustees or personal representatives can be required to provide a financial account. Their request may...

      Read more
    3. international map and money

      Will Dispute Case Law

      New Births And New Relationships? Review Your Will To Avoid A Dispute You’d imagine a wealthy businessman with assets...

      Read more
    4. older couple

      Of Bad Character: Undue Influence Claim Succeeds

      Naidoo v Barton: undue influence and the risks of mutual wills Can someone’s bad character be used to prove...

      Read more
    5. lady holding a cup

      Case Law: Dementia-Induced Mild Cognitive Impairment

      Dementia is a harsh reality for increasing numbers of families. Sadly, it means the disputed wills solicitors at Osbornes Law...

      Read more
    6. the moon

      How to prevent someone contesting a will

      It is fairly rare in my experience for a parent to write a child out of their will but that...

      Read more
    7. last will and testament disputes

      Contesting A Will Case Studies

      Will dispute on grounds of lack of capacity Our contesting a will solicitors acted for the claimants, the adult daughters...

      Read more
    8. couple holding hands

      Understanding Testamentary Capacity

      What is testamentary capacity? Testamentary capacity refers to a person’s legal and mental ability to create a valid will....

      Read more
    9. toy houses on coins

      Unsuccessful Inheritance Act Claim

      The case of Shearer v Shearer The recent reported case of Shearer v Shearer highlights that adult children cannot expect...

      Read more
    10. hat on back shelf of car

      What is reasonable financial provision in 1975 Act claims?

      Understanding “Reasonable Financial Provision” “Reasonable financial provision” under the Inheritance Act 1975, refers to the financial support that is reasonable for...

      Read more
    11. older lady

      Undue Influence in Wills

      What is Undue Influence in Wills? Undue influence occurs when someone pressurises another person to change their Will to gain...

      Read more
    12. Last Will and Testament

      Left Out of a Will: What Can I...

      I was left out of my parent’s will. What can I do? Understanding Your Situation Whilst testators in England...

      Read more