Mutual Wills

13 Nov 2017 | Katie de Swarte
two ladies talking

Table of Contents

The High Court’s decision in the recent case of Legg and Burton v Burton [2017] has highlighted the issues surrounding the doctrine of mutual wills, which many people are unaware of.

What is a mutual will?

Mutual Wills are Wills made by two (or more) people with an agreement not to revoke (i.e. cancel or change) their will in the future once one of the two people has died.

Is a mutual will the same as a mirror will?

No, two people making wills on the same terms does not mean that the wills are mutual. For a mutual will to exist, there must be evidence of an agreement (not just hope) that the second to die will not revoke their will.

What are the consequences of making a mutual will?

If the requirements of a mutual will are met, a constructive trust is imposed on the surviving party. This means that he or she cannot make a new will in the future disposing of the property subject to the trust. The surviving party must adhere to the terms of the mutual will agreement even if they received no benefit under the will of the first to die. Although a marriage or entering into a civil partnership revokes a will, the terms of the agreement are still binding on the party to the mutual will.

What are the problems with making mutual wills?

There are a number of practical problems involved with making mutual wills, the main ones being:

  • Although the survivor cannot amend their will to dispose of the property received from the estate of the first to die – they are not under a duty to account for this property, so they could spend all of the estates during their lifetime so there is nothing left on their death.
  • The parties are restricted as to what they can do with their property in the future, and their ability to adapt their will to a change in circumstances is limited.

More information on: Naidoo v Barton: undue influence and the risks of mutual wills

I have a mutual will – what do I do?

If you have a mutual will that you no longer require, it may be possible to revoke this, but due to the complex nature of such wills, it is vital to obtain professional advice in the first instance. If you would like advice on making a new will, please get in touch with a member of our Private Client Team on 020 7485 8811.

Share this article


Contact us about a Mutual Will

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. handwriting

      Is A Handwritten Will Legal?

      Are hand written wills valid? It is not unusual for clients to need their will prepared and signed promptly because...

      Read more
    2. osbornes hampstead office

      What is a Mirror Will?

      Mirror wills are mirror images of each other and practically the same in every way. They suit couples, married or...

      Read more
    3. night sky

      5 Things You Should Never Put in a Will

      When it comes to writing a will, you want to make sure that your wishes are known and that the...

      Read more
    4. Forged will pic

      Forged Wills

      If the contents of a will comes as a surprise, then one of the things to consider is whether the...

      Read more
    5. man looking at a lake

      Can Someone With Dementia Make A Will or...

      It’s a sad reality in an ageing population that more people than ever suffer from dementia in the UK....

      Read more
    6. Businessman and Male lawyer or judge consult having team meeting with client, Law and Legal services concept

      Beware of appointing your children as executors

      Where tensions exist between family members, making your children the executors of your will can cause huge problems with probate,...

      Read more
    7. older man on a bench

      How to Divide Assets in a Blended Family

      In this article we look a scenario for someone who is making a will where they are married with children...

      Read more
    8. lady singing document

      Making a Will by video link

      The Government has recently announced plans to allow for the witnessing of Wills and Codicils by video conferencing. This is...

      Read more
    9. guide dog

      Leaving money to charity in your will

      Why leave money to charity in your Will? Leaving money to charity in your will is a significant source of...

      Read more
    10. garden

      Property up to £1m can be inheritance tax...

      Changes to Inheritance Tax Allowances Changes to inheritance tax allowances mean married couples can leave property worth £1 million tax-free from 6...

      Read more
    11. hampstead office

      Hampstead solicitor becomes notary public

      Hampstead solicitor Elspeth Neilson of Osbornes Law has qualified as a notary public (a notary), meaning she can now certify...

      Read more
    12. property in spain

      Property abroad? Beware of forced heirship rules

      Whether it’s a holiday home, an investment property or a place you want to retire to, if you own...

      Read more
    13. unwanted call

      What is fraudulent calumny?

      Rise in ‘fraudulent calumny’ Maggie Leiper, a private client solicitor at London law firm Osbornes Law, says she’s seen...

      Read more
    14. house in regents park london

      Residence Nil Rate Band

      What is the Residence Nil Rate Band? The Residence Nil Rate Band is an additional nil rate band. It can...

      Read more
    15. international flags on wall

      Assets abroad? Why you may need more than...

      As more of us become internationally mobile, it’s increasingly common to own assets abroad. Yet lawyers say many people...

      Read more
    16. a couple doing DIY

      Can You Write Your Own Will?

      Is writing your own will legal? While writing your own will is technically legal and can be valid if executed...

      Read more
    17. 25.3.2019

      Cross Border Issues – Wills and Succession

      An increasing number of individuals have connections with more than one jurisdiction. Conflicting rules can significantly affect their estate planning...

      Read more
    18. person receiving bad news

      What happens when someone dies without a will?

      Dying without a will When someone dies without a Will, the Intestacy Rules apply. These rules, which are set out...

      Read more