Contested Will Claim Succeeds on Capacity

20 Oct 2021 | Katie de Swarte

A sad case in which a bereaved father made a will without the requisite mental capacity to do so has clarified who bears the burden of proving testamentary capacity. In these types of cases, the burden of proving these cases can be far from straightforward.

Our specialist dispute lawyers are experienced in contested wills and testamentary capacity claims and are known for their sensitive but incisive approach to the issues. The starting point in such claims is that there is a presumption of testamentary capacity, but where there is sufficient evidence of mental impairment or lack of testamentary capacity on the part of the testator, the burden of proof shifts to the other side.

Slight evidence will not be sufficient to reverse the burden of proof, but if real doubt is raised, it is then for the propounder of the will to prove the deceased did have capacity.

What was the case about?

This was an appeal ruling following confusion over how the burden of proof should be treated in a capacity case, which led to an error on the part of the District Judge.

The deceased made a will in 2017 in tragic circumstances. He was highly vulnerable, having lost his wife five months earlier and his son four weeks before that. Just over two months before making the will, he had significantly failed a screening test for cognitive impairment.

The deceased had made an earlier will in 2014 which benefited his daughter, but he explicitly excluded her in the 2017 will. She brought a claim on the basis that her father lacked testamentary capacity, and was not of sound mind, memory or understanding at the time.   

The district judge decided that rather than getting bogged down in the issue of burden of proof, he would proceed on the basis that the daughter bore the burden of proof, and see where that led. She lost her claim and appealed. 

The High Court described that approach as “a recipe for confusion”. There had been sufficient evidence before that judge to raise serious doubts as to capacity such that the burden of proof would shift to the defendant to prove capacity. He had, effectively, got it the wrong way round: it was for the defendant to prove capacity, not for the claimant to disprove it. 

Employing the correct approach would have led to a different conclusion. The defendant had failed on the facts to prove that the deceased did have testamentary capacity when he made the 2017 will. The judge ordered the 2014 will to be proved and the daughter could claim her inheritance under it. 

What does this mean?

This ruling illustrates the shifting and, at times, confusing nature of the evidential burden of proof in testamentary capacity cases. It is important for anyone with concerns surrounding the testamentary capacity of a will-maker, whether or not they are now deceased, to seek specialist advice from wills disputes solicitors.

If you wish to make a will or are concerned about a loved one making a will and have worries around mental capacity issues, we can assist. The team can advise how to make a valid will, but be protected from potential claims based on capacity. 

Katie de Swarte is an associate solicitor who specialises in contested claims. Katie is able to advise you on whether you can bring such a claim, based on the facts of your circumstances, and is also able to assist in defending such a claim. Katie is featured in the Legal 500 as a recommended solicitor in London.

To speak with Katie please call, or complete an online enquiry form.

Share this article

Contact

Contact Katie de Swarte today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    • Katie de Swarte and Elspeth Neilson have both instructed me recently, and both seemed to me to be able to build excellent relationships with their clients and to run their practices very efficiently

      Legal 500 2022

    • Katie de Swarte is hardworking and has great empathy for her clients

      Legal 500 2022

    More Insights about Contesting a WillVIEW ALL

    1. 20.10.2021

      Evidence Needed When Contesting A Will

      ‘Scrap King’ Multi-million Inheritance Dispute Confirms the High Standard of Evidence Needed to Contest a Will   Gary Goodwin, son of...

      Read more
    2. 20.10.2021

      Contested Will Claim Succeeds on Capacity

      A sad case in which a bereaved father made a will without the requisite mental capacity to do so has...

      Read more
    3. 20.10.2021

      Contested Will Claim Against Estate Fails

      The recent reported case of Shearer v Shearer highlights that adult children cannot expect an estate to support their affluent...

      Read more
    4. 13.9.2021

      Controversy over validity of the will

      Our client is the executor and one of three residuary beneficiaries of the estate of her late uncle. The will...

      Read more
    5. 8.9.2021

      Challenge on grounds of lack of capacity

      Osbornes Law acts for the potential claimants, the adult daughters of the deceased who assert his last Will to be...

      Read more
    6. 8.9.2021

      Claims over two £8m estates

      We act for the executor of the £8 million estate of his son who was embroiled in acrimonious divorce proceedings at...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL