What is Proprietary Estoppel?

14 Feb 2024 | Sophie Price

Table of Contents

What is Estoppel?

In general terms, estoppels operate where one party has acted on the basis of a statement made by another party, who is now attempting to change their position on the matter, contrary to what was previous said. The aim of an estoppel is to prevent this from happening.

What is Proprietary Estoppel?

Proprietary estoppel operates to modify rights over property and is capable of giving rise to new rights. In this respect, it is unlike any other form of estoppel in that it can give rise to a new cause of action. It is primarily applicable in respect of land, but is capable of affecting other proprietary rights.

What is a Proprietary Estoppel Claim?

To bring a successful claim for proprietary estoppel, the claimant must prove:

  • A promise was made
  • The promise was relied on
  • The claimant suffered detriment as a result, for example, by working for free or spending money on the land or property with the expectation that they would inherit the same from the promisor.

These elements do not exist in watertight compartments. They are connected and are analysed by the court as such. A greater degree of detriment cannot, however, overcome an absence of a representation, promise or assurance.

Proprietary estoppel commonly arises in the context of farming disputes, and promises such as “one day, all this land will be yours” are made to the claimant, but the promisor dies without having fulfilled the promise.

What is the difference between proprietary estoppel and promissory estoppel?

Proprietary estoppel relates to land. This means that if the promise concerns the legal ownership of land or buildings, then a claim would be brought in proprietary estoppel.

For promises in relation to assets other than land, the legal basis is a promissory estoppel claim (also referred to as equitable forbearance). Promissory estoppel is an equitable development of estoppel by representation (another form of estoppel) which applies to representations as to contractual rights. The key difference between the two types of estoppel is that promissory estoppel requires a pre-existing legal relationship between the parties, which does not apply to proprietary estoppel claims.

What must you prove in a successful promissory estoppel case?

There are no hard and fast rules about what amounts to a “promise,” or what the claimant has to do to  “rely” on the promise to their “detriment.” Proprietary estoppel is an equitable doctrine, which means it is concerned with equity or fairness. The court will consider all the circumstances of the case to decide whether the conduct being complained of is unfair and if something should be done about it- that is, whether it is unconscionable.

Below is an non-exhaustive list of factors the court would take into consideration when assessing a claim for proprietary estoppel.

  • Who made the promise, to whom and when
  • Whether the deceased was in a position to make the promise
  • Whether the promise was clear and not merely a throwaway statement
  • Whether there was any consideration for the promise

What award can be achieved from a successful proprietary estoppel claim?

The court has a high degree of discretion as to how it will provide a remedy. The key motivation for the  court is to avoid an unconscionable result. For example, it can order the land to be transferred outright to the person who thought they would inherit it, give them a right to live on the land for a certain period, or simply give them a negative right to not be evicted from the land.

Proprietary Estoppel Case Law

Two new proprietary estoppel cases in quick succession are particularly note-worthy, clarifying that a claimant must prove the nature of a promise or assurance to succeed on the basis of proprietary estoppel.

Gladstone v White

The claimant in the first case lost her claim and had to leave the £15m stately home in which she had lived for several years. The elderly owner, David Gladstone, had been long-term friends with solicitor Leigh White, who moved into the property in 2017.

Gladstone had also appointed her as one of his executors and trustees and made her a beneficiary of the estate trust. The background is complex but, suffice to say that the friendship unfortunately soured and White was asked to leave the property. Gladstone also sought to remove her as trustee.

White refused to move out and claimed that Gladstone had promised her on numerous occasions that she would inherit the stately home. She failed to convince the court that she had relied on any such assurance because of the context in which it was given; and the “telling” absence of any written confirmation to that effect.

The court found that Gladstone intended only that White would have a “significant managerial role” rather than any beneficial entitlement. His comments during conversations fell far short of a promise that she would be its absolute owner.

Mate v Mate

In the second case, the High Court once again ruled that no promise of “sufficient clarity” was made in a case involving a farming family. Julie Mate claimed that her mother promised to leave her a share of the proceeds of the sale of farmland.

However, she later discovered her mother and brothers had agreed to sell part of the land to a developer without her knowledge a year earlier. She also claimed that her brothers – partners in the family business – had known of the alleged promises, which they denied.

Julie claimed to have relied on the promise to her detriment, having paid for a planning consultant for years in relation to plans to develop some of the farmland.

The court emphasised that it is a question of fact whether a defendant was aware of someone else’s promise or assurance and acted in a way that makes it unconscionable for them to resile. Mere standing by or acquiescence can be sufficient.

Julie had not demonstrated there had been promises clear enough to entitle her to believe she would receive an equal share of the sale proceeds. The judge ruled on the evidence that whatever was said to her by her mother was “too vague and unspecific a promise for it to have been reasonable to rely on it”.

Nor was there any evidence that her brothers were aware of what their mother may have said to Julie.

How our proprietary estoppel solicitors can help

In any proprietary estoppel claim, the individual relying on a promise or assurance must demonstrate that a sufficiently clear promise or assurance was given. If this first hurdle cannot be satisfied, the issue of detrimental reliance on an alleged promise will not fall to be considered.

If you’re considering making or changing your will, it is wise to consider whether anything you have said to those close to you could be taken as an assurance or promise that could lead to a dispute.

The contentious probate lawyers at Osbornes are experienced in disputes involving proprietary estoppel claims. If you believe you have a claim, contact us for specialist advice by calling 020 7485 8811.

Share this article


Speak to a Solicitor about a Proprietary Estoppel Claim

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    • A private client team offering a range of services to assist with private client matters including trust and probate services. A friendly approach with a keen eye for detail.

      Legal 500 2024

    • I have been a client of this firm for a number of years and been impressed by particular individuals, the care and thoughtfulness with which they have worked.

      Legal 500 2024

    • An efficient firm which provides an excellent service at highly competitive charging rates.

      Legal 500 2024

    • The team receives a steady flow of instructions from high-net-worth individuals and families on an array of tax planning, wealth preservation, estate and succession planning issues

      Legal 500 2024

    • I think this firm has excellent strength and depth in this area, for both contentious and non-contentious work, and they can hold their own against any other firm.

      Legal 500 2024

    • I have found them to be incredibly knowledgeable and pragmatic in settling claims for their clients.

      Legal 500 2024

    • The contested estates team is strong with talented young solicitors doing good quality work

      Legal 500 2024

    • The nimble team acts for a broad range of high-net-worth individuals and families on a variety of complex estate and trust litigation.

      Legal 500 2024

    • Osbornes has a ‘strong private client department’ and ‘the firm seems to be going from strength to strength’.

      Legal 500 2024

    • Thank you for managing my case, following a complete fiasco before I contacted Osbornes Law. I know that the work involved was rather complicated, possibly frustrating and often time consuming. I was impressed with your current knowledge of the case when we had the first meeting at your office. I regard a face-to-face meeting as imperative in developing positive relationships. Members of your team, such as Alex and Ella were impressive too, with their efficient, friendly manner of working.
      I am grateful for your patience, advice and excellent support at a difficult time. Hopefully it won't be necessary to contact you again regarding this matter! I will definitely use Osbornes Law in the future.


    • "Jan Atkinson, with her steely, steady, calming presence, instils confidence in the most highly-strung of us clients. With her masterful knowledge of the law, old and new, and its application, Jan can navigate through the most complex of cases to a successful end."

      Legal 500 2021

    • "I find Osbornes’ client-friendly approach welcoming and refreshing"

      Legal 500 2021

    • "A medium-sized London firm dealing with big litigation and doing it extremely well because of a depth of expertise and experience."

      Legal 500 2021

    • My family had the pleasure of Jan Atkinson working with us on the will and probate issues of [my mother's] estate in Camden and Ireland after she passed on last year. Jan and her assistant(s) offered us a fantastic service at a sad time.

      Client Review

    • "Jan Atkinson stands out for her wide-ranging knowledge and experience of estates; whatever problem you throw at her, she has seen it all before and is able to find a creative and sustainable solution. She has exceptional commitment to her clients and explores every avenue to find the best solution for them"

      Legal 500 2021 - Jan Atkinson

    • The team is very caring, experienced and detailed and was clear about the  next steps and offered very helpful advice and suggestions

      Legal 500

    • Jan Atkinson has extensive experience in private client matters, which underpins her excellent skills in the contentious probate area. Plus she is strong on international matters

      Legal 500 2020 - Jan Atkinson

    • A small but formidable team, punching above its weight. Jan Atkinson is a seasoned pro. Approachable but no push-over

      Legal 500 2020 - Jan Atkinson

    • "They are an outstanding firm to work with. They are consistently impressive in their work."

      Chambers UK

    • "Elspeth Neilson is very reliable and practical."

      The Legal 500

    • "The team frequently deals with cross-border estates for high–net-worth individuals."

      The Legal 500

    • "The team were extremely professional in putting my needs first. There was a joined-up approach to catering for the client, and all lawyers involved were briefed and constructive."

      Chambers UK

    • "Service prompt and effective. I have absolute confidence in Maggie."

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • I am happy with the service that I got and would recommend you to other potential clients.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • I found Osbornes always very helpful and efficient.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • We are very pleased with the services of Osbornes. Highly professional and through with close attention to detail.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • I would highly recommend Jan Atkinson in any probate matter and Osbornes Solicitors in any other legal matters.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • Jan Atkinson is a very proficient lady whom I would highly recommend to anyone involved in probates.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • Thanks for all your work and explaining everything so clearly. For any legal matters in the future I would not hesitate in instructing Osbornes.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • We have found your service to date as the most informative we have come across.

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates Client

    • Jan Atkinson is confident with a straightforward approach. Her practice covers both contentious and non-contentious matters, including wealth planning and estate administration.

      Chambers UK

    • I would like to thank everyone in my case for the excellent job!

      Wills, Probate & Disputed Estates client

    More Private Client InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. Forged will pic

      Forged Wills

      If the contents of a will comes as a surprise, then one of the things to consider is whether the...

      Read more
    2. 14.2.2024

      What is Proprietary Estoppel?

      What is Estoppel? In general terms, estoppels operate where one party has acted on the basis of a statement made...

      Read more
    3. 14.2.2024

      Duties of Trustees

      When someone sets up a trust, they will appoint trustees to manage the trust and its assets. The exact duties...

      Read more
    4. Deed of variation to a will

      Deed of Variation: Making a Change to an...

      What is a deed of variation? After someone dies, it is possible for the beneficiaries to change the way the...

      Read more
    5. Constructive Trusts

      Constructive Trusts

      Property rights are not always clear-cut. Sometimes, a person who does not legally own a property could be entitled to...

      Read more
    6. osbornes law writing pad

      What is a Codicil?

      What is a codicil to a will? Life has a habit of changing and your will may need to change...

      Read more
    7. man looking at a lake

      Can Someone With Dementia Make A Will or...

      It’s a sad reality in an ageing population that more people than ever suffer from dementia in the UK....

      Read more
    8. waiting

      Can a Lasting Power of Attorney Be Challenged?

      The number of people recognising the importance of making a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) has risen dramatically in recent...

      Read more
    9. older lady

      Undue Influence in Wills

      Contesting a Will Due to Undue Influence Undue influence occurs when someone pressurises another person to change their Will in...

      Read more
    10. 10 tips

      Wills Disputes: The Duty To Account Is Not...

      Beneficiaries frequently ask us whether trustees or personal representatives can be required to provide a financial account. Their request may...

      Read more
    11. eu flags

      German Court Rules on EU Succession Regulation

      Succession laws vary from country to country which historically made the administration of cross-border estates potentially complex. Since 17 August 2015, the...

      Read more
    12. couple holding hands

      Are trusts protected from divorce?

      Can trusts protect an inheritance from your spouse? A trust is a separate legal entity. Neither spouse owns its assets....

      Read more
    13. the moon

      How to prevent someone contesting a will

      It is fairly rare in my experience for a parent to write a child out of their will but that...

      Read more
    14. primrose hill london

      Gifting Property to Children

      Can I gift property to my children? Gifting a property to your adult children is a relatively complex transaction but...

      Read more
    15. house in regents park london

      Contentious Probate Case Studies

      Contentious probate involving business assets Our contentious probate solicitors act for the defendants to a claim issued to pronounce in...

      Read more
    16. Closeup of a hand signing

      Do you need to register your trust?

      The Trust Register was introduced in 2017 as part of anti-money laundering regulations. Previously, only trusts with a UK tax liability...

      Read more
    17. Businessman and Male lawyer or judge consult having team meeting with client, Law and Legal services concept

      Beware of appointing your children as executors

      Where tensions exist between family members, making your children the executors of your will can cause huge problems with probate,...

      Read more
    18. money in different currencies

      Does your will deal with cross-border assets?

      If you own assets in more than one country, it’s important to make a robust Will that deals effectively...

      Read more
    19. older man on a bench

      Married with children from a previous relationship – how...

      There are several ways of doing this. If sufficient assets are available apart from the family home, dividing those between...

      Read more
    20. Elderly woman hold smartphone feels disappointed by received bad news

      Family Tensions and Deputyship 

      Disputes between a deputy and the family of the individual concerned, can escalate and become increasingly distressing if issues are...

      Read more
    21. Couple having counselling

      Particularly sensitive issues around mental capacity

      Mental capacity, the right to sex and the carer’s risk of prosecution  Does everyone have the right to a...

      Read more
    22. Woman signing document

      Inheritance Claims CFA Success Fee Judgment

      The Court of Appeal upholds the recoverability of CFA success fees in 1975 Act claims. An individual who claims reasonable provision...

      Read more
    23. scrap metal

      Evidence Needed When Contesting A Will

      ‘Scrap King’ Multi-million Inheritance Dispute Confirms the High Standard of Evidence Needed to Contest a Will   Gary Goodwin, son of...

      Read more
    24. inheritance tax form

      Dispute Surrounding Interpretation of Will

      The ‘nil rate band’ offers an incentive to testators to make their will in a tax-efficient manner, maximising the amount...

      Read more