Lease Extension Negligence
Shilpa MathuradasTable of Contents
What is Lease Extension Negligence?
Solicitors Negligence when a Tenant claims a new lease of a flat under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993
From failing to advise a client when they purchase a leasehold property about the issues they will experience with a short lease to serving a defective notice, this area has particular pitfalls which may result in a claim for professional negligence against solicitors and surveyors dabbling in this area!
Whether you are a tenant or landlord, it is important to instruct a law firm and surveyor who are familiar with and specialises in the area of lease extensions. There are far too many solicitors and surveyors who hold themselves out as a specialist in this practice area but are not.
Deciding to purchase a leasehold property
However, the negligence may not start with your lease extension solicitor but with your conveyancer who fails to advise you on the purchase that your lease is below 80 years and therefore this will leave you with a larger premium to pay for a lease extension and further that you will have difficulty selling the property as it is unlikely to be mortgageable leaving cash purchasers only who will be in a position to buy. If you had been advised of these issues, you may have at that stage decided not to proceed. However, it is likely a conveyancer will already be alert to this due to the issues raised by a lender.
Secondly in order to initiate the process and to be in a position to serve a notice, the tenant must have owned the lease for at least two years. Where leases are in danger of going below 80 years, it is common to find a tenant to serve the notice and then assign the benefit of it simultaneously with the lease on sale. This allows a buyer of the flat to take advantage of the right to a new lease under the Leasehold Reform Housing and Urban Development Act 1993. The assignment needs to be correct failing which it will not be effective and could leave a new buyer having to wait two years before they acquire the right to extend their lease. This could be devastating especially if at that time the lease falls below 80 years and marriage value is payable making a lease extension more expensive.
Section 42 Notice
The Section 42 notice must be correctly prepared and served on the competent landlord. Further, a copy of the notice must also be given to the intermediate landlord. Failure to serve a valid notice could be an expensive mistake as the initial notice will be deemed withdrawn and the leaseholder has to pay the landlord’s reasonable legal and valuation costs up to the date of withdrawal. Further, the tenant cannot re-serve another notice for 12 months., In some circumstances, the leaseholder may simply serve another notice without withdrawing the first. This is because their first, invalid, notice would be treated as a nullity and would not, therefore, need to be withdrawn before another notice was served. The 12 months would not apply in that case and the new notice could be served straight away. However, the tenant cannot escape paying the liability for the landlord’s reasonable costs for having to deal with the notice though.
Registration of notice
It is also important once a notice has been served that it is registered as once it is served it is registrable against the title to the freehold and any other intermediate interests as a land charge or notice. The initial notice will not be binding on future owners if it has not been registered. This could have consequences on a tenant if the freehold property is sold before a tenant’s claim is concluded. Ultimately, the tenant would have to start again and if the lease has been assigned in the intervening period the new tenant will have to wait two years to enable it to serve a notice of its own right There is of course, also the damage that the lease falls below 80 years so the lease extension becomes much more expensive.
Counter-notice
Once the notice is served the landlord will have to serve a counter notice by the date stated in the notice. Here solicitors acting for the landlord will need to be careful as failure to serve a valid counter notice by the date specified in the initial notice allows the tenant to apply to the court for an order granting it the new lease on the terms the tenant proposed in the initial notice. Once the counter notice is served the parties have between two and six months to come to an agreement. After the first two months of negotiation either party may apply to the tribunal for a decision on the disputed issue which is usually the premium.
Application to the Tribunal
If the tenant fails to apply to the tribunal within 6 months of the date of the counter-notice, the tenant’s claim for a new lease will be deemed withdrawn and it will have to wait to serve a further notice.
Completion of the New Lease
Thereafter once the terms of the acquisition have been agreed between the parties or where such terms have not been agreed between the parties but have been determined by the Tribunal, the lease must be completed within two months of that date known as “ the appropriate period”. If the lease has not been entered into by the end of this period either party can make an application to the county court for an order either to:
- Perform the obligations arising from the initial notice ;
- Be discharged from the obligations arising from the initial notice,
The application to the court must be made in the period starting with the end of the appropriate period and ending two months thereafter. If no court application is made within this time frame and the lease has not been completed, the tenant’s notice of claim will be deemed withdrawn and the tenant cannot make another application for a new lease during a period of 12 months from the date of withdrawal
Beware of the pitfalls when applying or opposing the grant of an extended lease as it could have disastrous consequences for a tenant or landlord if it is not done properly or if any of the time limits are not met.
Share this article
Contact
Contact Shilpa today
For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811
Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you
Related InsightsVIEW ALL
- 12.8.2024
Buying a Second Home
Guide to buying a second home Almost three-quarters of a million households in England own a second home, according to...
Read more - 27.5.2024
The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Bill 2024
The Leasehold and Freehold Reform bill was one of the last pieces of legislation to make it through Parliament on...
Read more - 22.3.2024
The Renters Reform Bill
A Review of the Renters Reform Bill The 2019 Conservative Manifesto made a commitment to end “no fault evictions”. This has...
Read more - 22.3.2024
Client successful in TOLATA proceedings
The case related to proceedings under the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 (“TOLATA”) in respect of joint...
Read more - 23.1.2024
Freehold Service Charge Disputes
Service Charges & the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Bill The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Bill was introduced to Parliament on 27...
Read more - 23.1.2024
Will 2024 bring changes to the conveyancing process?
The National Trading Standard Estate and Letting Agency Team (NTSELAT) has recently released new guidance relating to information on both...
Read more - 23.1.2024
Know your Rights (of Way)
If you have a question or concern over a right of way on your property, it is important to seek...
Read more - 23.1.2024
Party Wall Etc Act 1996 v Common Law
The case of Power & Kyson & Shah [2023] EWICA Civ 239 The case of Power & Kyson & Shah [2023] EWICA Civ 239...
Read more - 8.11.2023
Leasehold update: A new Leasehold and Freehold Bill...
Yesterday, 7th November 2023, in the King’s Speech we heard the following: “My Ministers will bring forward a bill to...
Read more - 27.10.2023
The Building Safety Act 2022
Introduction to the Building Safety Act 2022 This much awaited Building Safety Act 2022 was introduced into Parliament on 5th May 2021 as...
Read more - 22.8.2023
Reasonableness of Service Charges
Reasonableness of Service charges under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 It is well known that the relevant costs that a...
Read more - 19.5.2023
Declaration of Trust for Property
If you are buying a property jointly, you may want to consider making a declaration of trust to record your...
Read more - 11.5.2023
Overlooking Nuisance Claims
Overlooking Nuisance Claims – net curtains not necessarily! I refer to the article https://osborneslaw.com/blog/overlooking-nuisance-claims-buy-some-net-curtains/ which concerned the...
Read more - 10.5.2023
Government Announces Leasehold Reforms
The government announced in 2021 the introduction of various leasehold reforms which will affect the leasehold system for properties in England...
Read more - 13.2.2023
Transfer of Equity Stamp Duty
Do I Pay Stamp Duty Land Tax When Transferring Property into My Partner’s Name? When it comes to property...
Read more - 13.2.2023
Shared Ownership Stamp Duty
Do you pay stamp duty on shared ownership? When you buy a new shared ownership property, you are given two...
Read more - 8.2.2023
Severance of a Joint Tenancy
Severing a Joint Tenancy Normally, when couples buy a property together they do so as joint tenants. This means they...
Read more - 8.2.2023
Tenants in Common vs Joint Tenants
Tenants in Common vs Joint Tenants: Which is best for buying a property together? When buying a property with someone...
Read more - 5.2.2023
Japanese Knotweed: Knot in my backyard again!
Huge legal bill after selling home with Japanese knotweed Many will have read the recent case in which a furniture...
Read more - 20.1.2023
Stamp duty tax to remain the same until 2025
Good news for buyers as the current SDLT rates will remain until 2025 Buyers looking to purchase this year will be...
Read more - 23.9.2022
First-time buyer stamp duty exemption
Stamp duty is the bane of every home buyer, with only first-time buyers being exempt from paying the tax if...
Read more - 30.8.2022
What is a transfer of equity?
Transfer of equity in divorce Transfer of equity refers to the process of transferring part or all of a property...
Read more - 9.6.2022
TOLATA Claims
What are trusts of land? Property ownership is not always a straightforward legal issue, particularly where the parties are cohabitees...
Read more - 8.6.2022
Right to Light Explained
What is the Right to Light? The right to light is a type of ‘easement’ – a legal right giving property...
Read more