Court of Appeal Judgement on Secondary Victim Cases

13 Jan 2022 | Nicholas Leahy
Judge signing arrest warrant

Judgment was today handed down by the Court of Appeal in the cases of Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Foundation Trust, and the two linked cases of Polmear v Royal Cornwall Hospital NHS Trust and Purchase v Ahmed, all of which are secondary victim cases in a clinical negligence context.

The Court of Appeal had to decide whether legal proximity existed between the Defendant and a close relative (secondary victim) where there was a gap in time between the negligent treatment, and the horrifying event or injury. Such proximity is necessary to establish liability in these types of cases.

The Court found for the Defendant in each of these cases, on the basis that they were bound by a previous decision of the Court of Appeal, in the case of Taylor v. A. Novo (UK) Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 194.

However, this is not the end of the road for these cases as the Claimants in each case have applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court. In his lead judgment, Vos MR said that if he were starting with a clean sheet in these cases, then “I can quite see why secondary victims in these cases ought to be seen to be sufficiently proximate to the defendants to be allowed to recover damages for their psychiatric injury”.

The application to appeal to the Supreme Court is opposed by the Defendants, and so it remains to be seen how the law will develop (if at all) in this area.

The Clinical Negligence team at Osbornes Law can advise on potential secondary victim claims. Please contact our specialist clinical negligence solicitors by calling, or completing an online enquiry form.

 

Share this article

Contact

Contact Nicholas Leahy today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    • "Nicholas Leahy works extremely hard and understands the commercial sensitivities of clinical negligence litigation."

      Legal 500 2023

    • Excellent service from Osbornes throughout on a difficult clinical negligence claim. Nicholas Leahy who handled the claim was responsive and professional throughout, while also providing pragmatic advice and clear drafting.

      Client review

    • Working with Osbornes Law was the best decision I could have made. Nick was really attentive to my issue and did a very thorough job. He truly made the process headache free! Highly recommend them.

      Client review

    • Nick Leahy has been my Solicitor throughout this journey and has been absolutely amazing; kind, approachable and extremely supportive... Through some dogged determination by Nick we achieved our goal without having to go to trial. I cannot thank Nick, Stephanie and all of the team at Osbornes highly enough for achieving a very favourable settlement, the outcome of which will make a huge difference to myself and my family.

      Client review

    Medical Negligence InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. 23.11.2023

      Maternity Negligence Claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant, C, in her birth negligence claim against Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust for maternity...

      Read more
    2. Cancer treatment in a modern medical private clinic
      21.9.2023

      Large Compensation for Delayed Laryngeal Cancer Diagnosis

      Actress receives financial award after life-changing missed cancer diagnosis. Jodi Newton acted for a client who was belatedly diagnosed with...

      Read more
    3. Fatal Medical Negligence Claim
      21.9.2023

      Delayed cervical cancer diagnosis claim

      Jodi Newton acted for a woman who died following a delayed cervical cancer diagnosis. The deceased could have been diagnosed...

      Read more
    4. 19.9.2023

      NHS England Waiting Lists: PM Blames Doctors’ Strike

      NHS England’s waiting list has been growing over the past decade, rising from 3 million in 2014 to 7.7 million in July...

      Read more
    5. hospital
      19.9.2023

      Fatal Claim: failure to diagnose appendicitis case settles...

      Stephanie Prior was instructed in a claim against Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust, where our client’s mother (JC) tragically passed...

      Read more
    6. model of a spine
      19.9.2023

      Spinal Fracture Case Settles for 6-figure Sum

      Spinal Fractures following cessation of Denosumab injection Stephanie Prior was instructed in a spinal injury claim against Mid and South...

      Read more
    7. Beautician hold syringe for young female client
      13.9.2023

      Delayed skin cancer diagnosis

      We are pleased to have successfully settled a client’s claim for a delayed cancer diagnosis – Basal Cell Carcinoma (“BCC”)....

      Read more
    8. waiting
      31.8.2023

      NHS waiting lists hit an all-time high

      Medical Negligence Solicitor Jodi Newton explains: England’s NHS waiting lists have hit the highest number since 2007, reaching a record...

      Read more
    9. baby
      31.8.2023

      Hyponatraemia – Symptoms, Causes & Negligence

      What is hyponatraemia? Hyponatraemia is a condition where sodium levels fall below a certain level, which can be dangerous. All...

      Read more
    10. Ambulance vehicles at the Royal London Hospital
      10.8.2023

      Ambulance Delays Affecting Rapid Patient Treatment

      In 2017, the Secretary of State for Health accepted the new ambulance performance standards recommended by NHS England, meaning that the 11...

      Read more
    11. Fatal Medical Negligence Claim
      1.8.2023

      Failure to Treat Bowel Condition

      Jodi Newton, a Partner in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes Law, has recently settled a long running case against...

      Read more
    12. private hospital
      26.7.2023

      Private Healthcare Negligence

      Can you claim negligence against a private hospital? Yes – it can be a little more complicated than bringing a claim...

      Read more
    13. hospital
      19.6.2023

      Prison Healthcare Negligence

      Nicholas Leahy, a solicitor in the Clinical Negligence Department at Osbornes Law, has  recently successfully settled a long running case...

      Read more
    14. new born baby
      9.6.2023

      Early Notification Scheme – is it helping or failing...

      What is the Early Notification Scheme? The NHS Early Notification Scheme (“ENS”) has reached its sixth anniversary. Established in April 2017,...

      Read more
    15. 5.6.2023

      Are pharmacy closures putting patients at risk?

      It has been reported in the press that chemist closures will have an impact on patients living in deprived or...

      Read more
    16. Confidential file
      11.4.2023

      Osbornes Instructed After Local Authority Data Breach

      Osbornes Law has recently negotiated a settlement on behalf of two clients who had their personal information inadvertently released to...

      Read more
    17. pregnant lady
      23.3.2023

      Private Pregnancy Scans and Substandard Care

      In the news, it has been reported that private clinics that offer pregnancy scans to women are not meeting the...

      Read more
    18. baby hand in mothers hand
      7.3.2023

      5-figure settlement for infusion leak to mother

      Elline Demetriou has reached another successful outcome for a Claimant, who pursued a post C-section birth injury to mother claim...

      Read more
    19. Cannula in right arm of indian man
      14.2.2023

      The risk of extravasation injuries during iron infusion...

      Many patients with low iron, particularly during pregnancy or postnatally, may be advised they need an iron infusion such as...

      Read more
    20. water
      9.2.2023

      Perineal Tear case settles for 6-figure sum

      Stephanie Prior recently settled a claim relating to a woman who delivered her baby after a traumatic labour. Her son...

      Read more
    21. dentist
      23.1.2023

      Court avoided after settlement agreed in dental negligence...

      The Medical Negligence team have recently negotiated the settlement of a complex dental negligence case. Our client experienced a number...

      Read more
    22. Doctor With Stethoscope And Files
      13.1.2023

      Delayed diagnosis of appendiceal cancer

      The medical negligence team at Osbornes Law has recently settled a case involving a patient who passed away following a...

      Read more
    23. hands of surgeon
      14.12.2022

      Successful settlement for negligent care during kidney transplant...

      Claimant v Royal Free London NHS Trust Osbornes have reached a settlement agreement on behalf of a Claimant who brought...

      Read more
    24. Modern dental office interior
      10.11.2022

      Successful claim against dental practice after negligent treatment

      Osbornes Law have reached another successful outcome for a client, who pursued a claim against dental practitioners due to medical...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL