Court of Appeal Judgement on Secondary Victim Cases

13 Jan 2022 | Nicholas Leahy

Judgment was today handed down by the Court of Appeal in the cases of Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Foundation Trust, and the two linked cases of Polmear v Royal Cornwall Hospital NHS Trust and Purchase v Ahmed, all of which are secondary victim cases in a clinical negligence context.

The Court of Appeal had to decide whether legal proximity existed between the Defendant and a close relative (secondary victim) where there was a gap in time between the negligent treatment, and the horrifying event or injury. Such proximity is necessary to establish liability in these types of cases.

The Court found for the Defendant in each of these cases, on the basis that they were bound by a previous decision of the Court of Appeal, in the case of Taylor v. A. Novo (UK) Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 194.

However, this is not the end of the road for these cases as the Claimants in each case have applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court. In his lead judgment, Vos MR said that if he were starting with a clean sheet in these cases, then “I can quite see why secondary victims in these cases ought to be seen to be sufficiently proximate to the defendants to be allowed to recover damages for their psychiatric injury”.

The application to appeal to the Supreme Court is opposed by the Defendants, and so it remains to be seen how the law will develop (if at all) in this area.

The Clinical Negligence team at Osbornes Law can advise on potential secondary victim claims. Please contact our specialist clinical negligence solicitors by calling, or completing an online enquiry form.

 

Share this article

Contact

Contact Nicholas Leahy today

For a free initial conversation call 0207 485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you







    • "Nicholas Leahy works extremely hard and understands the commercial sensitivities of clinical negligence litigation."

      Legal 500 2023

    • Excellent service from Osbornes throughout on a difficult clinical negligence claim. Nicholas Leahy who handled the claim was responsive and professional throughout, while also providing pragmatic advice and clear drafting.

      Client review

    • Working with Osbornes Law was the best decision I could have made. Nick was really attentive to my issue and did a very thorough job. He truly made the process headache free! Highly recommend them.

      Client review

    • Nick Leahy has been my Solicitor throughout this journey and has been absolutely amazing; kind, approachable and extremely supportive... Through some dogged determination by Nick we achieved our goal without having to go to trial. I cannot thank Nick, Stephanie and all of the team at Osbornes highly enough for achieving a very favourable settlement, the outcome of which will make a huge difference to myself and my family.

      Client review

    Medical Negligence InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. 23.1.2023

      Court avoided after settlement agreed in dental negligence...

      The Medical Negligence team have recently negotiated the settlement of a complex dental negligence case. Our client experienced a number...

      Read more
    2. 13.1.2023

      Delayed cancer diagnosis results in five figure settlement

      The medical negligence team at Osbornes Law has recently settled a case involving a patient who passed away following a...

      Read more
    3. 14.12.2022

      Successful settlement for negligent care during kidney transplant...

      Claimant v Royal Free London NHS Trust Osbornes have reached a settlement agreement on behalf of a Claimant who brought...

      Read more
    4. 10.11.2022

      Successful claim against dental practice after negligent treatment

      Osbornes Law have reached another successful outcome for a client, who pursued a claim against dental practitioners due to medical...

      Read more
    5. 9.11.2022

      Transfer time from ambulance to A&E causing...

      The Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch (HSIB) have identified that patients may come into risk of harm whilst waiting in ambulances...

      Read more
    6. 9.11.2022

      Breast cancer screening mammograms and negligence

      Breast cancer screening has improved significantly in the UK due to research bettering the understanding of this terrible disease, which...

      Read more
    7. 28.9.2022

      Women more likely to have symptoms ignored by...

      An increasing number of women in the UK feel brushed off by GPs when presenting with real symptoms, with many...

      Read more
    8. 21.9.2022

      Are maternity services safe? – Part 2

      In April last year I wrote a piece about government setting up a taskforce to look into why there are...

      Read more
    9. 8.9.2022

      Poor interpretation of CTG can result in stillbirth...

      Poor interpretation of a Cardiotocograph, more commonly known as a CTG, is a leading cause of stillbirth and brain injuries...

      Read more
    10. 9.8.2022

      New interactive rating tool reveals NHS wait times...

      Amidst record-breaking heatwaves and a lengthy patient waiting list due to COVID backlogs, it is not surprising that this summer...

      Read more
    11. 1.8.2022

      Successful settlement for birth injury that led to...

      Stephanie Prior’s case relating to the death of Gabriela Pintilie has settled and has been approved by the High...

      Read more
    12. 14.7.2022

      Insulin overdose in hospitals due to limited staff...

      A century ago, insulin was first used to treat a 14-year-old boy dying of type 1 diabetes A hundred years later,...

      Read more
    13. 6.7.2022

      GP Negligence claim leading to fatality successfully settled

      Osbornes acted for a Claimant who brought proceedings on behalf of the estate of her late son, X, relating to...

      Read more
    14. 6.7.2022

      NHS aims to reduce waiting times with Elective...

      The NHS recently recorded their waiting list to be at 6.5 million, a record high. Much of this backlog is due...

      Read more
    15. 29.6.2022

      Nottingham Maternity: Donna Ockenden to Chair Independent Inquiry

      An interim report on the state of maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust has just been released. However,...

      Read more
    16. Neglijenta medicala spital din UK
      23.5.2022

      Justice for client who suffered serious birth injuries

      The Clinical Negligence team at Osbornes Law have recently negotiated the settlement of a case in which our client sustained...

      Read more
    17. 28.4.2022

      Calls for Public Inquiry into Vaginal Mesh Surgery

      A leading professor from the University of Oxford has called for a public inquiry into the use of vaginal mesh...

      Read more
    18. 14.4.2022

      Severe abdominal pain prolonged due to failed surgery

      Jodi Newton was instructed in a claim against London North West University Healthcare NHS Trust where our client suffered serious...

      Read more
    19. person receiving bad news
      11.4.2022

      Late Cancer Diagnosis Crisis Within NHS

      The Health and Social Care Committee recently released a 52-page report on cancer services, expanding on the crisis in England (...

      Read more
    20. 6.4.2022

      Stephanie Prior Comments on the Ockenden ‘Maternity Scandal’...

      Following the publication of the Ockenden Report, an independent review of maternity services at Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust,...

      Read more
    21. Explaining NHS Never Events
      5.4.2022

      NHS Gynaecology waiting lists rise due to coronavirus

      It has been reported today in the press that as a consequence of the coronavirus pandemic, gynaecology waiting lists in...

      Read more
    22. 23.3.2022

      Nerve injury following bowel surgery

      Stephanie Prior was instructed in a claim against Luton & Dunstable University Hospital where our client sustained an injury to...

      Read more
    23. 23.2.2022

      Record high waiting lists put cancer patient lives...

      In early January 2022 there were nearly six million people in England waiting for routine operations and treatment: a record high....

      Read more
    24. Neglijenta medicala spital din UK
      23.2.2022

      Women from ethnic minorities experience worse maternity care

      It has been reported today that the government has set up a new task force to look into why there...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL