Landmark Decision: A Surrogate Mother’s Rights Are Not Erased in English Law
Naomi Angell
Table of Contents
In the world of surrogacy, legal rights and parental responsibilities can be a complicated issue.
Non-profit surrogacy is legal in the UK, but if you use a surrogate, they will be the child’s legal parent until a parental order is made. A parental order takes legal parenthood and parental responsibility away from the surrogate and delivers them to the intended parents.
Many people choose to write the arrangements into a surrogacy agreement, covering important aspects such as how the child will be handed over, any expenses that may be covered, and whether the surrogate mother will retain visitation rights. However, solicitors are barred from drafting surrogacy agreements, and they are not enforceable in a court of law.
While many surrogacy arrangements work amicably, the difficulties can be significant if the arrangement breaks down. A judge may decide to take your private surrogacy agreement into account when making a decision. But since the agreement is not legally binding, you essentially are relying on each party keeping their word.
This issue was graphically illustrated in a recent landmark decision by the UK’s High Court. The child’s intended parents, a same-sex couple, asked the court to sever all legal ties and contact between their surrogate and the child she carried for nine months on the basis they were a ‘motherless family.’ That was not what the mother wanted, nor what the parties had previously agreed.
What Happened?
The child, referred to as ‘Z’ in court proceedings, was born in September 2020 through a surrogate, known as ‘G’.
G used her own egg and was impregnated with sperm from one of the intended parents, a gay couple referred to in the case as ‘X’ and ‘Y’. The couple were married and had been together for years when they decided to have a child through surrogacy.
The men agreed that G would have contact with the child after it was born. However, their relationship with the surrogate broke down during the pregnancy. After taking the child into their family, the couple reneged on their promise and refused to let G have contact with her biological son.
The men then commenced a series of legal actions against G that would cut her from the boy’s life.
The case has been widely reported in the media. According to reports, the couple claimed that seeing his mother would confuse the child, as he was being raised in a ‘motherless family’ within the LGBT community. Having regular contact with her would be homophobic, they said, as it implied that having same-sex parents made the child’s family incomplete.
No Cutting Ties Between Child and Surrogate
In this landmark case, the court had to consider whether a Step-Parent Adoption Order should be made.
If granted, the Step-Parent Adoption Order would have made the non-biological father the child’s legal parent alongside the biological father. The order would have wholly extinguished ties between the child and his mother.
After hearing expert evidence, the court declined to make the Step-Parent Adoption Order—meaning the surrogate mother retains her legal rights and parental responsibility for the child.
There was no argument about where the child should live. The child will continue to live with the married couple under a Child Arrangements Order (agreed by the surrogate mother).
The Judge also made a series of further orders for the non-biological father to have parental responsibility, to define the time that the surrogate mother could spend with her child, and to regulate how the three adults will manage their parental responsibilities and make important decisions about the child’s upbringing.
What Does This Mean For Surrogacy Arrangements?
This is the first case of its kind in the UK.
It highlights just how important it is to enter into a surrogacy arrangement with your eyes wide open, and a full understanding of the impact of the law.
The most important thing to know is that the surrogate is the child’s legal mother unless the intended parents get a parental order from the court. If the surrogate mother wishes to retain her parental rights, or there is any other type of dispute, you will have to go through a full court case and the judge will decide what the arrangements should be in the best interests of the child.
The court may take into account any surrogacy agreement entered into between the parties, but the judge won’t be bound by it and can do whatever it thinks is right for the child.
In this case, one child psychologist who gave expert evidence said that the intended parents were attempting an ‘erasure of mother’ from their family, which did not reflect reality and was not in the boy’s best interest. The court agreed.
What About International Surrogacy?
Outside the UK, the picture is more complex. Surrogacy is illegal in some countries and restricted in others. Some countries recognise and uphold written surrogacy agreements; others do not. In any event, UK law still recognises the surrogate as the legal parent until you have a parental order, even if the baby was born overseas and the surrogate is not named on a foreign birth certificate.
If the surrogate is married, her husband is automatically considered the child’s legal father until a court issues an order to change this. This rule applies whether the surrogacy takes place at home or abroad.
To transfer legal parenthood, you need to apply to the British courts for a parental order and terminate both the surrogate mother’s rights and those of her spouse or civil partner. There may be issues of citizenship to deal with as well.
Because of the complexities, it is crucial to get legal advice before starting on a surrogacy journey. Even if everything seems to be going smoothly, unexpected issues can still arise as this case shows. Forewarned is forearmed. A surrogacy solicitor may not be able to draft a formal surrogacy agreement, but they can get all the ducks in a row to help you prepare for the journey that lies ahead.
Contact us
To speak with one of our family solicitors, contact us by:
- Filling in our online enquiry form; or
- Calling us on 020 7485 8811
Share this article
Contact
Contact us today
For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811
Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you
"Osbornes handle a significant amount of complex, high-value divorce work."
"Osbornes have talented fee earners at all levels."
"Osbornes is a top-end firm, a very well-established name. They have high-value matters, deal with complex matters and have a good team."
"Lisa Pepper is a standout mediator - smart, sensitive and able to narrow the issues with ease."
"Lisa is good at cutting to the chase and identifying issues. She gets people talking and brings people together."
"Lisa is excellent - she's efficient, has a very good rapport with her clients and has an enormously outgoing energy. She is very effective in managing clients' cases."
Osbornes is vastly experienced and able to think around the issues and consider them in a new and refreshing way
Osbornes is a really good team that gives a first-class service which is both sensible and insightful but also supportive of the client's needs.
Osbornes Law offers affluent clients representation in high-value, complex family matters.
"Osbornes Law have a very broad family practice which does all areas of family law at a high level. They have an excellent practice; they are top quality across the board."
Osbornes have been a sound firm forever. They have phenomenal work and an excellent skill set.
Osbornes have high-end partners doing high-end work. They are very impressive.
They have an excellent practice; they are top quality across the board.
Osbornes have a very broad family practice which does all areas of family law at a high level.
He is very hard-working, diligent and thoughtful in his approach. He is on top of the detail and makes strategic decisions.
He commits himself to getting the best results.
He’s a really tough litigator that you certainly want on your side. He will defend his clients to the hilt.
Mark is an immensely capable lawyer, with vast experience and a well-deserved reputation for getting the very best for his clients.
Lisa Pepper is extremely hard-working and adored by her clients. She is a very empathetic and approachable lawyer.
She’s an extremely supportive and kind lawyer and has an increasing mediation profile too
The Osbornes mediation team is excellent and has some good individuals.
"Continues to receive a growing number of instructions from high-net-worth individuals, frequently with cross-border components, and advises on a steady flow of complex cohabitation matters, often involving large property portfolios."
Andrew secured me the best financial settlement for my claim. He is a credit to Osbornes Solicitors.
"It has a strong and experienced team of solicitors who don’t take bad points, work sensibly to get a settlement and who you can always pick up the phone and speak to. They are good lawyers and know the strengths and weaknesses of their clients’ cases. They don’t posture and always pursue their clients cases appropriately. "
"Mark Freedman is a very capable lawyer, renowned for not being a pushover and pushing his clients’ cases as much as he can, but will always talk sensibly about settlement. He is among the best – tenacious, good judgment and tactically aware."
"Mark Freedman is a dynamic and highly experienced family lawyer who fights extremely hard for his clients and is always in their corner, thus ensuring their loyalty and confidence. In a trial you would always want him on your side."
"Bridget Thompson combines her excellent legal knowledge with a clear, succinct and robust style of advice and advocacy. Her approach clearly inspires a high degree of client confidence in her"
"She has impressed me as someone who fights my corner but also understands the importance of resolving issues without unnecessary escalation. She is calm and reassuring."
"Her mediation practice is exceptional; she is also a great solicitor and has a breadth of skill which is really useful."
"He is really experienced and wise. He has a lovely manner about him and clients feel safe with him."
"Jo Wescott is top notch and widely recognised as a rising star throughout the profession. She brings a winning combination of great judgement, an immense work ethic, and a relaxed and charming way with opponents and clients alike. Someone you want on your side”
"Osbornes is pre-eminent for family law in North London. Mark Freedman is a real rainmaker. He is an excellent lawyer and has a top-notch practice"
Mark Freedman is intelligent and personable and has a good selection of high-net work cases.
"Exceptional value for money. Highly competent and reasonably priced. Mark Freedman: one of the best in the field."
"Client-focused. Ready to fight the clients’ corner, but also ready where possible to steer client from unnecessary dispute. Mark Freedman – very experienced, with good instinct for the eventual result. Clients love him and he thinks ahead and directs the client to the best result for the client."
Mark Freedman is a serious player. A fearless family law litigator, who protects his clients’ interests passionately.
Breadth of knowledge and willingness to go the extra mile is what makes it stand out. Mark Freedman – devoted to his clients
Mark Freedman frequently takes on high-value financial and children proceedings that involve complex tax, trust and accounting issues. Sources praise the "tenacity and common sense" he brings to challenging disputes.
"Mark is very experienced, competent, good with clients and takes a sensible approach to cases. He knows exactly what he's doing."
"An exceptional outfit. They take on difficult cases, fight hard and win."
"They are an outstanding firm to work with. They are consistently impressive in their work."
"The team frequently deals with cross-border estates for high–net-worth individuals."
"Mark Freedman is a real heavyweight litigator who has dealt with some very significant cases."
"Mark Freedman boxes clever, keeps his powder dry and when it comes to the end game he negotiates a really good deal."
"Mark Freedman has a specific focus on high-net-worth divorces and finance cases where there are overseas assets and trusts."
"Lisa Pepper somehow manages to get parties to settle on matters where there isn’t much hope to start out with."
"Well-regarded family practice assisting clients with substantial matrimonial disputes and sensitive children proceedings."
"Mark Freedman draws acclaim for his work in high net worth divorce cases, including those involving company structures, family trusts and overseas assets."
"He never gives up. He fights for you to the end and has boundless energy."
Bridget Thompson heads the family team, where client care is the top priority.
Mark Freedman advises high-net-worth clients and knows his stuff.
Highly regarded for his experience as a litigation and mediation expertise, Mark Freedman is tenacious and determined. Clients really feel that he is fighting their corner.
[The Family Law department] handles significant matrimonial finance cases and complex nuptial agreements. Respected for its expertise in cross-border children law matters.
They have a really good, strong team, with the junior elements punching well above their weight. It doesn't matter who you talk to; they are all switched on."
Osbornes fields a sizeable team with many standout lawyers.
"Mark Freedman receives a lot of instructions from clients based abroad, often relating to complex divorce proceedings. Sources say: “His main strengths are his enthusiastic passion for the job in hand and his total dedication to his clients.”
This team is perhaps best known for its children work, often involving complex international dynamics.
Accreditations
Related InsightsVIEW ALL
7.3.2023What is legal parenthood and how is it...
This issue was in the news recently, when a married Oklahoma same-sex couple were in court over a dispute about...
Read more
31.8.2022What if my partner predeceases me before we...
A review of a recent case concerning consent during fertility treatment. When going through fertility treatment as a couple, it...
Read more
31.8.2022Declaration of parentage after mistake at register office
Recently in the news has been the outcome of the case of Osborne & Anor v Cambridgeshire County Council [2022] EWHC 1982 (...
Read more
5.7.2022Proposed Changes to Gamete Donor Anonymity Laws in...
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) has proposed changes to the law surrounding gamete donor anonymity in the UK....
Read more- 18.11.2021
Legal considerations in the surrogacy process
What Are My Surrogacy Options at Home and Abroad? When you’re considering surrogacy as an intended parent, you may...
Read more - 31.1.2019
Change in Surrogacy Law
Recent changes in surrogacy law, allowing a single person to apply for a parental order, represent a significant step towards...
Read more - 26.2.2018
Thai Case Shines The Light on International Surrogacy
This week, a story reported by the Telegraph raises some interesting questions about international surrogacy. The reporting states that a 28...
Read more
