Lisa Pepper discusses recent divorce jurisdiction cases of Agbaje and Sharbatly

13 Aug 2019

Many marriages are a meeting of not only two minds but two jurisdictions. Relationships are often international. On divorce, the jurisdiction where the couple married doesn’t matter, provided they had a ceremony recognised as valid under English Law.

The choice of jurisdiction in divorce and financial proceedings is a common issue. Careful advice needs to be taken from lawyers in both jurisdictions to weigh up the pros and cons of where to commence proceedings.

Even after choosing that jurisdiction, if it isn’t England, in certain circumstances a spouse can still bring a financial claim here after they have been awarded a financial settlement in another country. The Application is made under Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984.

The case of Agbaje v Akinnoye-Agbaje [2010] in the Supreme Court is well-known by Family Lawyers. It set out the circumstances in which a spouse who divorced in another jurisdiction can make a financial claim. It also set out principles for subsequent cases in how the court should decide the amount of the financial award.

Following on from Agbaje, the case of Sharbatly v Shagroon [2012] in the Court of Appeal refused an Application by the Wife under the MFPA Act. The husband had obtained a talaq divorce in Saudi Arabia. She was refused not because of the talaq divorce, but because they had not had a valid marriage ceremony recognised under English Law. 

Sadly, it is all too common that spouses can think an Islamic religious ceremony equals a valid marriage here. 

It remains the case however that if a valid marriage ceremony took place and the parties then divorce and have a financial settlement outside this jurisdiction, in certain circumstances a spouse is not prevented from applying for a “second bit of the cherry” and bringing a claim here.

Lisa is an experienced family lawyer specialising in all aspects of family law. Follow Lisa on twitter @LisaPepperLaw. 

Share this article

Insights from our London Divorce LawyersVIEW ALL

  1. 19.10.2021

    The Same-Sex Divorce Process

    What Happens When a Same-Sex Relationship Breaks Down? Recent news of Rylan Clark-Neal and Dan Neal’s divorce after failing...

    Read more
  2. 19.10.2021

    What is a Decree Absolute?

    A Decree Absolute is the final stage in divorce proceedings and the document that officially ends the marriage.  This article...

    Read more
  3. 19.10.2021

    What is a Decree Nisi?

    In England and Wales, there are three key stages to the divorce process:  The Divorce Petition The Decree Nisi The...

    Read more
  4. 28.9.2021

    Family Courts Backlogs Exacerbated by Pandemic

    Court backlogs: Divorcing couples face ruinous costs as last-minute court hearing cancellations become commonplace Divorcing couples are facing ruinous costs...

    Read more
  5. court of appeal

    Beneficial Interest in Property

    The Court of Appeal provides further clarification on interests in property Andrew Watson, a London based divorce lawyer in our ...

    Read more
  6. 27.4.2021

    What does divorce in your 60s...

    The rise of ‘silver separators’ The latest divorce figures from the Office of National Statistics (ONS) show that divorce is...

    Read more